so your saying those TWO years he scored six thousand pts in which there really was no comp???
I'll believe it when i see it.. no offense... but i would LOVE to see a chart of that
After 1980-81 he never again averaged 25ppg.
Kareem played ONE year before Wilt came down to Earth after having a ridiculously stellar year, and by Wilt's standards it still wasn't awesome.
That was Kareem's rookie year. Wilt averaged 27.3ppg and 18.4rpg that year (note that 18.2rpg - the following season - was his career worst) after that season Wilt dropped to 20ppg the following season, with his career worst rpg numbers, and in the following final 2 years of his career never averaged 20 again with 14.8 and 13.2 ppg season.
When Kareem came in Wilt was either pretty much done by his standards or was definitely on the downward slide.
Wilt was also just one player.
Hakeem had to go head-to-head in the mid to late 90s with the deepest centre pool in history.
Hakeem
Shaq
David Robinson
Patrick Ewing
Alonzo Mourning
Dikembe Mutombo
That's easily a best 6 pronged centre grouping the league has ever had. Easily. Without a shadow of a doubt.
Then you've got second tier guys who, were they playing at other times in league history would be considered much better:
Rik Smits
Vlade Divac
Zydrunas Ilgauskas (when healthy was at his best those days, granted not healthy often)
Arvydas Sabonis (who granted his best days were behind him outside of the NBA, but he was still one of the better centres on the planet and in his prime a top 10 centre ever IMO)
Then there were also some premier PFs who would also man up on Hakeem at the 5, through that era to cover for weaker centres.
Guys like Shawn Kemp, Charles Oakley, Horace Grant, Derrick Coleman, Chris Webber, later Tim Duncan.
Hakeem went against a quality opponent damn near every night.
The best possible argument that you could make for Kareem is that there were less teams so the less talent they had then covered it a little bit. But there were more teams than when Wilt and Bill Russell were playing as well... so the talent WAS thinner than it probably should have been.
1984-85
Hakeem's rookie year stats:
20.6ppg - 11.9 rpg - 2.68 bpg - 0.538 fg%
Kareem's stats:
22 ppg - 7.9 rpg - 2.1 bpg - 0.599 fg%
Bear in mind that that was Hakeem's ROOKIE season... it takes players a little while to heat up and find their place generally... especially if their position is deep and they consistently see quality opposition, which you've already said was the hardest time with 80s ball...
Fact remains, when Kareem entered the NBA, it wasn't Wilt or Bill Russell or Moses or any of the guys who you named who were the top dogs, none of these guys were in their prime.
The top dog at centre when Kareem came in was Willis Reed.
A man who I would say wasn't as good as Patrick Ewing... or a number of players who Hakeem had to take on at ANY point in time in his career.
The 'worst' best, or next best (because for a long time Hakeem WAS the best) player that Hakeem had to play was never at that Willis Reed level.