Iron Man The Official Iron Man Rate & Review Thread

Rate it

  • 10, Wonderful, Amazing, Rad-Tastic!

  • 9, Really Awesome

  • 8, an Action packed fun movie

  • 7, A good film

  • 6, I liked it

  • 5, Okay

  • 4, Dissapointment

  • 3, Bad

  • 2, Sucked major Iron Balls

  • 1, Hated it! Worst film I've ever seen!

  • 10, Wonderful, Amazing, Rad-Tastic!

  • 9, Really Awesome

  • 8, an Action packed fun movie

  • 7, A good film

  • 6, I liked it

  • 5, Okay

  • 4, Dissapointment

  • 3, Bad

  • 2, Sucked major Iron Balls

  • 1, Hated it! Worst film I've ever seen!


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know. I'm wondering if it's just the initial excitement. People haven't been able to pick it apart yet.

It's not that people haven't been able to pick it apart. It's that it's a hard film to find flaws with. The most negative review I've seen had to resort to picking apart superhero movies and origin stories just to cite flaws.
 
Also I have to add how much I loved the score to this movie. Both the soundtrack and the score kicked ass. Rock music used right. Guitars and drums instead of trumpets and violins and wailing women. Thank god! No Jesus music! :woot:
 
I prefer movie scores, but the rock music in this worked for an Iron Man movie.
 
Debuting in 1963 alongside other Marvel staples like the X-Men, Iron Man has been one of Marvel's staple heroes, even if for long periods of time he bordered on the B-List when pared against types like Spider-Man and the X-Men, with his solo title struggling in sales in recent years. CIVIL WAR rejuvenated him and Avi Arad, ever the TOY BIZ man, has always had a special place in his heart for the armored avenger. With Marvel finally managing to gain complete productive control over their movie universe (or at least the universe that is left after pawning Spider-Man, X-Men, Fantastic Four, Daredevil, Blade, and Ghost Rider to other movie studios), it made sense to use that as the perfect chance to bring Iron Man to the big screen. On the surface he has many similarities to Batman; a billionare playboy by day who fights crime with a genius IQ and an armada of gadgets at night.

But there is a lot more to Tony Stark and after a cartoon in the 90's that had one miss (and one hit) season, and an utterly underwhelming animated DTV last year, IRON MAN blazes onto the big screen in a burst of glory. Jon Favreau directs a comic book film masterpiece that managed to breath life into a genre that was almost becoming overstuffed and riddled with mockable cliches (see SUPERHERO MOVIE). Marvel has complete control over the product and it showed, with 80% of the story being faithful to the comics with only minor details being updated. And in Robert Downy Jr., Marvel found the perfect actor to play the flawed and eccentric Tony Stark, who is probably the coolest big screen superhero right now.

Really, the entire cast does a terrific job. Jeff Bridges was great as Obidiah Stane, shaving his head for the part and being able to flex between stern businessman and sterner megalomaniac, but in a more subtle way; he wasn't Norman Osborn (or the movie Dr. Doom), cackling away. And Gweneth Paltrow has one of her best roles in years as Pepper Potts, part Gal Friday, part love interest, whose character manages to ignore becoming a hysterical, crying damsel hanging from a rafter somewhere like Lois Lane or Mary Jane. Hell, you could even argue she saved the day at the end. Terrance Howard's Rhodey manages to strike the right chord, although he was a bit underdeveloped and seemed more like a routine than a character. But he served the right moments, the right balance to Stark.

The plot mirrors the comics, although it thankfully updates the adversaries for modern times; Vietnam works fine for the 60's, but Afghanistan is appropriate for 2008. While promoting his newest weapons technology, Stark is injured in an explosive attack and shrapnel is lodged near his heart. Kept alive by Prof. Yinsen (a good Shaun Toub) via an ad-hoc "iron lung" device, his captor Raza (Faran Tahir) and his "Ten Rings" terrorist organization wants Stark to build his missles for them. The Ten Rings are obviously an allusion to the Mandarin, and Raza himself gave off that appearance with the large ring and waxing philosophical about Genghis Khan. But he worked a lot better than the over-the-top Emperor Ming cliche that the 616 Mandarin often became. It was an update for the times but it works. It isn't like the comics that still in many ways fight the wars of yesteryear, with heroes still battling Nazi's or Asian Threats. Heck, I could argue this was the least-Liberal film to touch on the current war in ages. Most Hollywood movies after 2003 or so depict Middle Eastern terrorists as innocent Teddy Bears who'd become angels if only us rotten Americans would just say "please" and "thank you". Not IRON MAN. He gets hooded and water-boarded by his captors, who while not the most efficient lot (they're shocked when a weapons designer actually builds weapons to try to FREE HIMSELF), they are deadly and dangerous as they are, sadly, in real life.

Scrambling to keep his heart ticking and realizing the error of his ways, Stark creates his first suit of armor and frees himself, but at the cost of Yinsen's life. He makes it back to the states and starts to perfect his armor, taking responsibility for the horrors that his weapons have created upon the world. All the while, Stane is trying to steal his company from under him and employs underhanded and downright illegal means to do so. It all comes down with a showdown between Iron Man and Stane's own bulky armor, Iron Monger. While Monger is never named, he is homaged and mentioned.

The movie presents us with a flawed hero who manages to hit all the right angles. He is an uber genius but also someone who needs an assistant to recall his Social Security number. He can bed dozens of floozies in a week yet still genuinely care for those around him, even if he simply uses them for a while. And Stark had no end of notable one-liners.

IRON MAN was a movie that was the total package. It had drama, and a lot of intense action and suspense, but it also knew when to kick back and provide a comedic laugh, sometimes even better laughs than outright comedies provide. We all have our favorite moments that will be on YOUTUBE within the hour. From test flights gone wrong to quirky robot assistants, to the highs of seeing Iron Man take flight or rescue innocent civilians from the Ten Rings terrorists. One minute Iron Man is grappling for his life against Iron Monger, the next he is imperiled by a soccer mom hitting the gas. Some may say the last leg of the movie is predictable, and it is, but that doesn't make it bad.

Got to love the inclusion of SHIELD and the cameo at the end, finally starting to create a movie version of the Marvel universe. DC may want to do things first, but Marvel wants to do them RIGHT.

Iron Man himself was an incredible spectacle in three armors. They all looked great, all had the audience at the edge of their seats and all were great to watch. I caught a slight reference to ROBOCOP, in a scene where Iron Man plunges his hand through a wall to grab a bad guy.

Finally, the film turns some routine bits about superhero movies on their ear. Stark is no angst teenager given powers, nor is he someone who despite turning himself into an ultimate weapon, forgets how to have fun. And he doesn't even try to maintain a secret identity long.

I've made longer reviews, but I am preaching to the choir here. IRON MAN hit all of the right buttons and ranges of emotion. It respected the comic material enough to do it faithfully and well, but not in an overly gloomy, overly realistic way. It wasn't afraid to give you a chuckle before it made you gasp in awe. That is a rare feat. The only quibble I have, and it isn't a quibble really, but more like an observation, is merging Jarvis the butler with one of Stark's infamour AI programs, like HOMER from the comics and cartoons. JARVIS was basically his AI program. It isn't the choice I expected but it didn't really hurt things. Potts was more interesting than Jarvis anyway. The producers probably did not want anyone confusing him for Alfred.

This is a four star effort, and a 9 out of 10. There wasn't a lot of action, but when it did happen it was appropriate. Stark's character evolved over the film and despite being well over 2 hours long, the time doesn't drag at all because there is so much good stuff happening.

As for War Machine? "Maybe next time." Now that's how to do it.

A DARK KNIGHT trailer played before this film in my theater, but the Caped Crusader is in for a rough summer to try to match the well rounded chills and spills of this newcomer to the big screen's pantheon of superheroes.

If you like superheroes in any way, shape, or form, see and love IRON MAN. It is a summer blockbuster that doesn't insult your intelligence or is too ashamed of it's roots to revel in them. Despite being a Spidey-fan, it is good that the pinnacle for superhero filmdom no longer may be a web-slinger or a man from Krypton. It may be too soon for anyone to put IRON MAN at #1 (I wouldn't), but it is a easy Top 5. A movie that actually lived up to the hype on every level.

Bring on that Avengers Initiative!
 
i liked it
didn't think i would

only thing that bothers me is the hypocricy when it comes to the acceptance of genre films

the village set piece was money
didin't think jonF had it in him

third act was kinda weak tho

character work was great tho...not sure who to give credit to tho

Leslie bibb is gorgeous

howard sounds like a 7 year old lol

Bridges pulled off the best live action Luthor to date

Downey has added himself on the list of 9 born to plays when it comes to comic adaptations

Flyings like swinging was fun to watch...take note singer and co.

ILM = near perfect vfx

Gives me hope for Cap A movie...if done right it'll make u cry

gives me hope for the eventual civil war film!
 
Loved it!

Great action.

I can't get over how amazing the end sequence was (I.E. Iron Man and Iron Monger battling it out).
 
I really doubt we're getting Civil War, though The Avengers sounds inevitable after this film.
 
I just wonder how long we'll have to wait for an Avengers Movie. We might get an Iron Man Sequel in 2010. But then we need a Captain America, Thor and maybe even an Ant-Man Movie.
 
marvel studios seems to be all over millars work as of late
plus it's a good little story
 
ant man movie?

sorry but i know i had my doubts about b list iron being a strong fun movie

but ant man just doesn't sit right
 
The review in my local paper said something along the lines of

"The studio didn't want to cast RDJ as Iron Man, but they gave in. It's like casting Johnny Depp as Jack Sparrow--> He IS the character"

I honestly can't even put into words how much I enjoy this movie. Saw it again tonight.
 
I'm not liking the idea of an Ant-Man Movie either, but it seems to be what most of the fans want. So I go with the flow.

Anyway, the other two most important characters, before launching an Avengers Movie, Are definitely Thor and Cap. I just hope Marvel doesn't wait too long. I don't want RDjr to turn too old when they start working on the cross-over.
 
I'm not liking the idea of an Ant-Man Movie either, but it seems to be what most of the fans want. So I go with the flow.

Anyway, the other two most important characters, before launching an Avengers Movie, Are definitely Thor and Cap. I just hope Marvel doesn't wait too long. I don't want RDjr to turn too old when they start working on the cross-over.

This film is a huge hit already. I think they'll begin work on a sequel. I don't think he'd be too old to do an Avengers film.
 
i honestly think an iron man movie was kinda easy for marvel studios to make, especially with the cast and ilm and that script
the tech and everything it's just so real world

i honestly think a Thor movie will be hard
I hope they cast Dolph!
 
My iron man review:

Ok first off I was never really excited for this film until the reviews started pouring in on how amazing it was. Then I saw on rottentomatoes that it had a 94% rating. Then I knew I had to go see it. Went into to the movie expecting something good but came out not so impressed. The movie was nothing like it was hyped up to be. I mean, its ok. Theres bits and pieces of the movie I didnt like (dont really feel like going into detail) and all those just came together to make it the average superhero movie that it is. But one thing I loved about the movie was RDJ! He did the movie a big favor with his great performance.

Rating: 6.5/10
 
Did anyone else love the opening scene, when Stark is attacked? Very well filmed, I thought.
 
No bootleg pics allowed. The announcement says you'll be banned if you post any.
 
Ah, just post a manip of Samual Jackson with an eye patch. That'll do. :D
 
There was also too much comedy. I swear every other scene had some pointless comedy in it. But at least some of it was funny
 
I thought all of the comedy was spot-on. Plus, this is a movie based on Tony Stark. If you're looking for a dead-serious movie, The Dark Knight or The Incredible Hulk would be more up your alley.
 
Even if the comedy was too much at times, it was just too funny to really complain about. The 10% Thrust scene is probably the funniest moment I've seen in any Superhero movie.

And as I'm typing this message I'm still laughing like crazy because the fire extinguishing scene after the 10% thrust just popped into my head. :D
 
Even if the comedy was too much at times, it was just too funny to really complain about. The 10% Thrust scene is probably the funniest moment I've seen in any Superhero movie.

And as I'm typing this message I'm still laughing like crazy because the fire extinguishing scene after the 10% thrust just popped into my head. :D

I loved the "don't extinguish me or I'll donate you to a city college line", and then all the following warnings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"