X-Maniac
High Evolutionary
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2003
- Messages
- 15,181
- Reaction score
- 604
- Points
- 103
So you don't agree, and thus I must bend my knee to your opinion?
Yeah, not really. It isn't fussing, it isn't over-analyzing and the scene certainly wasn't fine. You don't play up a relationship and then speed right through it at the most crucial of moments.
Raven gasps, cries two tears, chooses Charles, and then after a 15 second conversations, leaves with Erik, with her last words being to Hank. They are brother and sister. You don't do that to a sibling.
This is forgetting the fact they just left them on an island that was just attacked by US and Soviet fleets. How exactly are they suppose to get off the island? They can't call for help and could be attack again at any moment.
The problem you have is that you're speaking in absolutes about human behaviour as if all people must act the same in any given situation, or as if they must act according to your expectations.
It's usually a sign of people being very young and not knowing the changes that come with many more years of life - such as the people you leave behind and end up never speaking to again (oh yes, plenty of that happens). Real life often consists of phases, usually driven by circumstances, and there will be people from whom you just move on.
The other problem is that you are being far too literal about everything and insisting on a spoon-feeding, dot-to-dot connection for every occurrence. The power of that scene is in Charles realising he can't feel his legs and repeatedly saying so as the camera fades from him; that would probably be totally lost if we had subsequent scenes of him being taken to hospital or if Magneto said 'Azazel, come here, teleport Charles to the nearest hospital with which you are familiar, then come back because i have to make my dramatic exit.'
Raven had formed quite a bond with Magneto, including what looked like a sexual relationship. Magneto accepted her fully for what she was.
I found that scene fine; you didn't. I doubt we are ever going to agree.