The Dark Knight Rises The Robin & Batgirl Casting Thread

[Hobodeluxe]

Let's kill two birds..er make that one bird and a cat with one stone and have a female Robin.

Ellen Page as Carrie

 

[anrrd_2]

never was a fan of carrie...and as much as i love EP, im not a fan of that match up

 

[Changeling]

Dick Grayson: Thomas Dekker
Tim Drake: Logan Lerman
Jason Todd: Tom Sturridge
Barbara Gordon: Kristen Stewart
Cassandra Cain: Katie Leung
Helena Bertinelli: Michelle Trachtenberg

 

[Matt.S99]

Trachtenberg as Huntress just doesnt work out at all. Shes too bubbly and ''electric'' and not bad ass enough, not to mention to young.

And the exact opposite for Stewart as Babs. Shes probably the worst possible choice for Batgirl.
Batgirl is supposed to be a happy, free spirited girl. Exiting and energetic. Stewart is the complete oppostie of that. She always acts mopy, depressed and even when she tried to look happy, it just looks forced.
Now, dont get me wrong, I like Stewart, but when people suggest her for Babs, I just tihnk that A)They know NOTHING about the character pre TKJ
B)They only suggest Stewart because shes become big because of Twilight
C)Both a&b

 

[anrrd_2]

Trachtenberg as Huntress just doesnt work out at all. Shes too bubbly and ''electric'' and not bad ass enough, not to mention to young.

And the exact opposite for Stewart as Babs. Shes probably the worst possible choice for Batgirl.
Batgirl is supposed to be a happy, free spirited girl. Exiting and energetic. Stewart is the complete oppostie of that. She always acts mopy, depressed and even when she tried to look happy, it just looks forced.
Now, dont get me wrong, I like Stewart, but when people suggest her for Babs, I just tihnk that A)They know NOTHING about the character pre TKJ
B)They only suggest Stewart because shes become big because of Twilight
C)Both a&b

ive been pushing KS for like 2 years...i get your pojnt on the mopy thing. still i think she would do well.

 

[Matt.S99]

If you wanted Babs to be emo , then sure.

either way, shes still a terrible choice. She is the exact same is like, every movie. Thats why she was pefect for Bella.

 

[anrrd_2]

fair enough. agree to disagree

 

[Matt.S99]

Dude, seriously, have you read a comic with Barbara Gordon when she was Batgirl? Watched any of the animated shows?
Cuz if you have, you would know that Stewart is totally wrong for the role. The girl cant even pull a smile convincingly, she sitll looks evil and depressed, even when she isnt.


Michelle onthe other hand has those big vibrant eyes, big smile and a quirky personality that is perfect for Gordon.

 

[Cunning Stunts]

When Dakota Fanning gets older (flame me if you want, I don't care, she's a phenomenal actress, especially given how young she is), I wouldn't mind seeing her take the role of Batgirl on.

I could also see Emma Stone pulling the role off.

 

[anrrd_2]

Dude, seriously, have you read a comic with Barbara Gordon when she was Batgirl? Watched any of the animated shows?
Cuz if you have, you would know that Stewart is totally wrong for the role. The girl cant even pull a smile convincingly, she sitll looks evil and depressed, even when she isnt.


Michelle onthe other hand has those big vibrant eyes, big smile and a quirky personality that is perfect for Gordon.

yes i have and yes i have...i think it is more my overconfidence in the actress than my lack of knowledge of babs.

 

[elgato]

I love Kristen (EW but not in twilight!!!)!!! But she would work better as Holly Robinson

 

[anrrd_2]

ok here we go....cassie, tim, and steph all in one shot

Spoiler

haha i kid i kidt:

 

[Majik1387]

I know you're kidding, but I will agree to them being decent kid/teen actors.

 

[elgato]

I sooo love iCarly!!





Ok, let's keep it as a secret :|

 

[Lane & Kent]

Helena Bertinelli/Huntress: Eliza Dushku

 

[Hobodeluxe]

Michelle Trachtenberg is too skinny. She looks like a twig with boobs

 

[anrrd_2]

ya know, ive been pushing k.s. for a long long time....but i think i'm starting to agree with everyone about her inability to smile. went on google images and entered her name, not one smile....not one! trachtenburg is now my definative choice for babs

she just screams barbara!

she screams oracle.

 

[Cunning Stunts]

Helena Bertinelli/Huntress: Eliza Dushku

If she's featured in these movies, I swear to God I will NEVER see it.

Michelle Trachtenberg is too skinny. She looks like a twig with boobs

Ever hear of... Training and dieting?

 

[Temple Fugate]

why dont we keep robin and BG out of this mmmmmkay?

nolan already said poo poo on robin

 

[elgato]

she screams oracle.

No, it screams Holly Robinson...well, she reminds me of Oracle also but I can't stop imiaging saying "Selina, I'm in trouble"

 

[Cunning Stunts]

why dont we keep robin and BG out of this mmmmmkay?

nolan already said poo poo on robin

... So, they can't speculate?

Sorry, but I can't really take someone's opinion into consideration when his or her signature states that 2008's WORST movie (not to mention, in my opinion, the decade's worst movie since Napoleon Dynamite) is even comparable 2008's (arguably) best.

I'm still praying that your signature is in jest.

 

[Temple Fugate]

... So, they can't speculate?

Sorry, but I can't really take someone's opinion into consideration when his or her signature states that 2008's WORST movie (not to mention, in my opinion, the decade's worst movie since Napoleon Dynamite) is even comparable 2008's (arguably) best.

I'm still praying that your signature is in jest.

it is a jest... to get people angry. one could call it a "troll"

 

[anrrd_2]

No, it screams Holly Robinson...well, she reminds me of Oracle also but I can't stop imiaging saying "Selina, I'm in trouble"

know i never even thought of that....

 

[Ledlunar]

The Jonas brothers could play all 3 robins from biggest brother to smallest, and they can recast Joker and have him beat them all with a crow bar

 

[Majik1387]

Wow. That was so funny. I'm literally LOL-ing. Seriously, I've never heard anyone hate on the Jonas bros like that. Ever.