Infinity9999x
Avenger
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2005
- Messages
- 12,107
- Reaction score
- 638
- Points
- 103
In real life, yes, Riggs will be in his mid teens. Maybe. We don't know the exact pacing they're using for the show and if they intend to scrap any specific story lines.
I can think of one particular one right off the bat that may never see the light of day on the screen, and may even be altered.
That being said, 10 years worth of comic has only progressed abt 2yrs. In my personal opinion, I actually wouldn't mind if Carl ages on the show. Carl remaining 8 for a possible 7 season series show seems a bit stagnant.
Chandler Riggs never looked 8 to begin with. Even in the first season, he looked old enough to pass for 10 or 12. So I figure the Producers aren't really caring abt that aspect at all. But honestly, once again, they are BARELY following the story line. So, I doubt it'll be THAT big of a problem.
And honestly, I still don't understand the argument of 8 yrs old vs. Early teens going through post apocalyptic life. Whether he was 8 or early teens, he's still in his formidable growing years where his identity of self and the world around him is still being formed. So what difference does it make if he's 8 or 13. It's still a eff'd up world to live in. The things that happen to 8 yr old Carl in the comic can be made to be just as crazy and traumatizing to 13 or 14 year old Carl.
Well it would literally be impossible for him to stay 8 for seven seasons without recasting the actor every few years, and I doubt they'd do that. I also wouldn't wan to see that.
And honestly, I think it's pretty clear why it makes a difference between 8 and 13. 13 year olds are massively different from an 8 year old. An 8 year old probably still believes in Santa Claus, an 8 year old hasn't completely formed their sense of reality and fantasy, they still believe in monsters under the bed.
Bottom line: They're still innocent. A 13 year old is not. Heck, by 13 you can have a kid who's smoking pot and having sex. That's not usually the case at 8. Sure a 13 year old isn't fully formed in terms of their identity, but they're a heck of a lot closer then 8. or 10. The reason so much of Carl's arc in the comics has been so strong is because he's still so young.
It's much more shocking to see an 8 year old decide to kill another human being then a 13 year old doing it.
So no, thematically, Carl being 13 or older and going through the same stuff is quite different. Teens of that age are more independent, more able to take care of themselves then a child of 8 or 9.
There's a reason Lord of the Flies has all it's children below the age of 13. Because it's more shocking when we see children that young lose their innocence.
Honestly, I think a lot of people forget the massive changes children undergo from around 8 to their teen years. I have a brother who's 8 years old and that's why I can see how incredibly different they are. So yes, there's a huge difference between an 8 and a 13 year old going through what Carl goes through in the comics.