Oooh! Oooh! Let me!
1. Negan is a dumb characte who doesn't translate to the screen. I've given Jeffrey Dean Morgan a lot of flak, but I'm not sure any actor can make "pee pee pants city" and "easy, peasy, lemon squeezy" not sound dumb. Like the Governor, Negan should probably have been toned down for the show. As it is now, he's like a villain thought up by a bunch of studio execs, taking the worst instincts from the 90's. "You like the Governor! Well buckle your seatbelt, 'cause Negan's in town! He's edgy! He's in your face!" He's like the Poochy of the Walking Dead. Don't be surprised if the next time we see him he's riding a skateboard down a hill, wearing sunglasses while bashing in a walker's head
2. A lot of people think Jeffrey Dean Morgan was miscast. Some because he's not particularly physically intimidating, others because they just find him to be annoying. For me, I think his performance is too one note and predictable, with little nuance. Now I know some of you like him, but I don't know how you could disagree with this assessment. I mean, you know he's going to whistle, and lean back, and emphasize every...other...word! You know he'll have that one moment where he's really serious and lowers his voice, and you think something might happen, and then he breaks into that s#it eating grin of his. I find it pretty hard to find him scary since he telegraphs everything, and I can anticipate what he's going to do next
3. Because he's so over the top, his acting stands out as being particularly jarring, since everyone else acting opposite him is giving much more restrained performances. It's like he walked in from a completely different show
.