Finally got around to watching the first episode of Lucha Underground.
Keep in mind...I gave up on both WWE and TNA about 3 months ago...
What I liked
The presentation was great. High quality production values but presented in more of an underground fight club way. So, the announce table intentionally looks like an amateur build and the venue is small with an inetionally dirty look, but it's professional and camera work solid. At the moment I actually prefer the production to TNA. Maybe that'll change once the novelty wears off...but TNA is trying and failing to look like WWE, whereas Lucha is blending the positives of the indies with high production values, camerawork etc.
Also, I loved the vignettes explaining the mythical history of the luchas and the tribes etc, presenting characters like Prince Puma almost as spirit animal warriors/heroes. This felt different from WWE and TNA, and I want more of that. They also had introductory videos for a few wrestlers that gave solid background on who they are.
The backstage skits are also quite different. At first it was a bit jarring...but...you know...I think I might be able to accept it. The backstage interactions are handled like scenes from a tv show...multiple camera angles, but not acknowledging them. There's a scene with Konnan talking shop with the owner of the company about the main event, and it was them kind of sparring verbally about Puma being handpicked by Konnan to be the future and how Johnny Mundo doesn't appreciate the history of Lucha so he was to be made an example of. It's kind of a bold move to basically tie the matches together with filmed tv scenes presenting what is clearly a tv show. I'm not sure how I really feel about that, but I'm game for the moment.
The action was good. Johnny "Morrison" Mundo is always a welcome performer for me, and I liked Prince Puma in the first time I saw him. Blue Demon and Chavo were just there so they could talk about the history of Lucha
What I didn't like:
Vampiro was terrible on announcing. Matt Striker was fine, but Vampiro seemed to have been reading a different script from everyone else. As soon as the episode started, he trashed the owner of the company as a guy who doesn't respect Lucha and he's Spanish, not Mexican, so he's a fraud. That immediately set me off because I REALLY don't need yet another show that revolves around a heel authority figure. But then the owner came out and basically said everything the crowd wanted to hear. He's a businessman that wants to bring the tradition of Lucha to the states, and yeah...it's about money as well (after all, this is presented as a fight club with financial rewards to the winners). But, turns out that Vampiro was right, since he proved to be crooked in the end...so Vampiro needlessly warned us of a heel turn ahead of time. However, despite my hatred for YET ANOTHER evil authority figure, I'm going to give this a few weeks to sort itself out...because the character is presented as a greedy promoter type scumbag.
Anyway...
Later, Vampiro trashed Konnan as being evil and this poisonous presence, but Konnan was never actually portrayed that way. Also, Vampiro kept using the term "rock star" to describe Prince Puma...who was the opponent of Johnny Mundo. Every time he said it it reminded me of the fact that WWE marketed Johnny as a rock star (even released a DVD under that title).
So yeah...Vampiro on announcing was my big complaint, with a big reservation on the heel authority figure angle and a still up in the air feeling on the tv show presentation of angles...but if you're a wrestling fan I'm not sure why you wouldn't watch this.