Yeah, I've read him comment about not caring for the workout regimen before but I've never read or heard him say he didn't like doing the stunts. He did describe on Leno in 2000 a scene where he was on a wire extended out over the edge of a building and being somewhat trepidatious about it. But that was mainly told goodnaturedly and not as a indication that he didn't like doing the stunts.
Regardless of whether he enjoys working out or not, I do disagree with your earlier comment about Tobey's back drama being staged to get out of stunts and workouts for the sequels. To me that borders on questioning his work ethic. He's a professional and highly regarded by directors as a work-horse and preps immensely for every role he plays. Always willing to do whatever is asked for the sake of a role (as evidenced by SM1 and Seabiscuit). Tobey gets the script well in advance and for this third one even got to put his touches on it during the scripting stages. He would know the kind of prep expected of him for SM3 and I think he would do the needful. Knowing he has a back condition probably meant that Raimi expected more use of stuntmen from the start.
Not to harp on it but it just gets annoying hearing people constantly questioning Tobey's commitment to the character or to the franchise based on how much time in the suit he is spending or how bulked up he is. You haven't come right out and said it, but it's what I'm reading between the lines with most of your posts. How much Tobey works out or whether he enjoys it or not is irrelevant. The movie can be just as great with the use of stuntmen in the suit as it could with Tobey in it. Just my opinion.
I know Maguire had real back problems, I just think it was played up somewhat. I have always thought that the scene where PP falls onto the car, grimaces and says; "My back!" was a little dig at him and his back problems.
You're right, I haven't said anything about how committed he is to the character, because that was never my point. I will, however, point out that Maguire himslef has stated that he had no interest in the comics or character befroe the first movie.
Everytime I have made a statement that has been challenged, I have backed it up, and other people corroborate my points.
This whole thread started with a quirky thought; Maguire may well get more money for each minute of screentime than any actor ever has. I thought the idea was kinda cool. All of my arguments against Maguire having extended screen time may seem like slams, but they're not. They are just commonly known ideas about the production of the movie(s).
I'm not trying to troll, but I will take this a step further...if I am so wrong, someone show me a behind-the-scenes picture of Maguire in the full costume. and I'm not taking about the little "half" costume used for chest-up shots of Maguire with no mask. Show me a pic from this production of maguire in full costume, sans mask or some other way of confirming its him.
Also, with the success of the first and second movies, Maguire may not have even needed to bargain about work time. The studio may have come to
him with an offer of light shooting schedule, just to presweeten the deal.