Warriors Three Cast

Well, that's what indie films are for. Hollywood's blockbuster segment is a highly commercialized one; it's a natural consequence of studios dropping gazillions of dollars into those movies that they expect to make lots of money in return. Art for art's sake is a myth at this financial level.
 
Well, that's what indie films are for. Hollywood's blockbuster segment is a highly commercialized one; it's a natural consequence of studios dropping gazillions of dollars into those movies that they expect to make lots of money in return. Art for art's sake is a myth at this financial level.

Yea but in an era where LOTR exist where a filmaker was given carte blanche to do what he wants, it showed that you can make money while still being 100% hardcore dedicated to what you want to do as an artist. Same thing with the Dark Knight.

There are no reasons anymore to pander to anybody.
 
LotR wasn't a direct adaptation by any means, though. They changed stuff and I, for one, don't know whether the reasons behind those changes were political or not. Besides, LotR has a huge pedigree that Thor lacks. LotR is the most important work of fantasy literature ever--it's basically the father of the entire fantasy genre and it's renowned worldwide. Much as I love Thor, he's kind of been floating between A- and B-list since the '90s. He's no Spider-Man or Superman or Lord of the Rings.

Besides, every film is different. Different people make different decisions regarding their investment in films. Maybe Thor wasn't lucky enough to get someone as willing to take risks as whoever funded LotR. Maybe Branagh just decided that these people are the absolute best for the roles and looks aren't particularly important. Who knows?
 
LotR wasn't a direct adaptation by any means, though. They changed stuff and I, for one, don't know whether the reasons behind those changes were political or not. Besides, LotR has a huge pedigree that Thor lacks. LotR is the most important work of fantasy literature ever--it's basically the father of the entire fantasy genre and it's renowned worldwide. Much as I love Thor, he's kind of been floating between A- and B-list since the '90s. He's no Spider-Man or Superman or Lord of the Rings.

It remains to be seen wich of LOTR or Thor had been part of pop culture and were recognised the most over the years. But either way, there's no reason big enough to make compromises.

Besides, every film is different. Different people make different decisions regarding their investment in films. Maybe Thor wasn't lucky enough to get someone as willing to take risks as whoever funded LotR. Maybe Branagh just decided that these people are the absolute best for the roles and looks aren't particularly important. Who knows?

No doubt, maybe Kenneth thought they were the best actors possible for the roles or maybe the investors are not as courageous as New Line cinema that made LOTR.

But i'm the eternal romantic in this. I wish every genre movies would be made with the care and dedication of LOTR. Imagine Fantastic Four done as an epic three movie with a great director, top actors, great writing. Nothing dumb, everything looking like it's the greatest epic ever made.
 
Eh, it's a nice thought but I've just made my peace with the fact that it rarely ever happens. Movies are a business first and art second.
 
... in reference to Natalie Portman. Jane Foster...

Yeah, Natalie's portrayed every type from a Southern Baptist to an English woman in V for Vendetta. To be honest, though, she wasn't my first choice, but I think she will do fine.

(For some reason, I always saw Jane Foster as a Waspy or Irish-American type, like [news anchorwoman] Jodi Applegate--only younger.)
 
Definitely. He seems to be firmly back in the A-list lately, too. Marvel's giving the Asgardians a whole universe-spanning event with Siege starting next year, and Thor's own comic is still selling obscenely well compared to his earlier series.
 
I've been looking for examples of Tadanobu Asano's acting. He's apparently kind of an A-lister in Asia. Does anyone know if he speaks English, or heard him speak English?
 
I'm all up for dropping the issue. But I just find it funny that, rather than acknowledging the abundance of evidence from a variety of sources proving you wrong or at least saying "Okay, we'll agree to disagree on what the character's ethnicity is", you're trying to save face by make-believing your stance as "Okay, Hogun is obviously white in the comics, but I'll let them change his ethnicity for the movie, I'm fine with it." As if you'd done a thing to prove the character is definitively Caucasian in the comics

I don't have to justify why I think a character from a nordic realm who is usually drawn as caucasian to my eyes is actually caucasian. Thats ridiculous.

And its not like you guys are amicably "agreeing to disagree" with me on the subject. You've all basically told me i'm a ****** for not seeing that Hogun is asian, while posting pictures wherein he looks clearly caucasian with the exception of ONE. If everyone had said 'piccolo, lets agree to disagree', I would have stopped awhile ago. And I did. Until you decided it just bothered you SOOOO much you had to go it again.

rather than just saying numerous pics showing his Asian features "aren't quite Asian enough" or saying "Nah, I don't think so" when the Thor continuity experts like Corp or Vartha chip in with their evidence backing up his foreign heritage. Which you haven't.

You say foreign heritage as if he isn't a native of asgard. He is. When you find evidence of asian races indigenous to Asgard, besides "well he kinda looks like one in this picture", let me know. Maybe consult your thor continuity experts who know as much about Hogun as I do.
 
Last edited:
You should work on reading comprehension. I never said he was middle eastern or asian/mongolian only that he he seems to have more in common with those cultures than the rest of the Norse gods.

Ok. Thats your opinion, and thats fine.

The only ACTUAL visual clue that he may be Caucasian is that he has white skin, but he shares a number of traits with the middle eastern/asian/mongolian traits. At best it is ambiguous what his actual background is, than saying he is definitely Caucasian or Central/Eastern Asian. The only fact is that he is NOT from Asgard so casting against the rest of the Norse gods isnt uncalled for.

Cool with me. We're good then.
 
hmm the immrotal dorian grey as fandral, the punisher as stagg? ok, and uhmm, idk what the guy playing hoggun has done
 
You know who would have made an awesome Volstagg?
Gerard Depardieu

gerarddepardieu1241335c.jpg
volstagghead.jpg
 
He's already played Frank Castle, aka The Punisher, but now British actor and all-round top bloke, Ray Stevenson, is set to take another stab at the Marvel Universe in Kenneth Branagh's mighty Marvel adaptation, Thor.

Stevenson was cast recently as Volstagg The Valiant, one of the members of the Warriors Three (think the Jordanaires to the God of Thunder's Elvis), alongside Stuart Townsend and Tadanobu Asano. There should be one problem, though - Volstagg is, how you say, on the large side and, with filming set to start in January, Stevenson has very little time to bargain bucket his way to a new and improved waistline.

Luckily, Empire caught up with him recently and found that a solution is at hand, in the shape of a fat suit. "It's fantastic," said a beaming Stevenson. "I've tried the suit on, and what they've done is kind of sex him up: he's sort of slimmer but rounder."

We're not sure we're up for an exuberantly sexed-up Brian Blessed-alike, but Stevenson clarifies: "He's got every bit of that Falstaffian verve and vigour, and a bit of a beergut to suggest that enormous appetite, but he's not the sort of Weeble-shaped figure he is in the comics. He's Falstaff with muscles. I've got this amazing foam-injected undersuit that flexes with me. I can't wait!"

Neither can we. Thor also stars Chris Hemsworth (as the title character), Tom Hiddleston, Anthony Hopkins, Natalie Portman and Idris Elba. With a cast like that, it could well be bloody marvellous. Pun absolutely intended.
SOURCE
 
Nice find, Chewy!

And yeah, I imagined they were going for that when Stevenson was cast. A fat, but still very strong and badass Volstagg.
 
nice find so he will be in some sorta of fatting suit. Cant wait to see how everyone looks.
 
If he's as fun as he often is in the comics, I have a feeling Volstagg might end up being something of a show-stealer.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,265
Messages
22,075,558
Members
45,875
Latest member
shanandrews
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"