Why I think Cyclops is still alive

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

God, I really hope an X-Men 4 doesn't get made...

And if it does, I really hope it doesn't follow some of the ideas I've seen tossed around on these forums...

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

heh...boy scouts

 

[chaseter]

heh...boy scouts

That would make me laugh if some boy scouts found him! Even more if the scout leader recognized him! HAHA...Or...I would like it if he woke up, realized what had happened, yelled JEAN...NO! Gritted his teeth, clenched his fists in anger, looked up to the sky(camera overlooking him), opened his eyes and his beam shoots out. Have a far shot where we can see the beam shooting into the sky above the treeline.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

That would make me laugh if some boy scouts found him! Even more if the scout leader recognized him! HAHA...Or...I would like it if he woke up, realized what had happened, yelled JEAN...NO! Gritted his teeth, clenched his fists in anger, looked up to the sky(camera overlooking him), opened his eyes and his beam shoots out. Have a far shot where we can see the beam shooting into the sky above the treeline.

hell yeah

 

[D-scythe]

God, I really hope an X-Men 4 doesn't get made...

And if it does, I really hope it doesn't follow some of the ideas I've seen tossed around on these forums...

I agree. Some are really bad, lol.

Anyway, am I the only one not seeing the big picture here? Who cares if Scott is dead or alive? When you have Logan replacing Scott in a story he shoulda starred in, there are bigger things to worry about then whether he dies or not.

Besides, what does he have to return to? The X-team, who was like "Oh $hit, they killed Kenny!"? A very dead Jean, whom LOGAN saved from herself? Xavier, a surrogate father picked at his shortcomings to Storm?

 

[chaseter]

Hell, I think Fox should run a promotion for X4 by giving the fans a chance to write with the writer's on a certain scene. Throw out a scene on the website and tell the fans to write it out. Set rules like time limit, dialogue, expenses, locations, etc...and the winner can have a chance for their scene to be in the movie or a chance to work with the writer's! Give the fans an official voice.

 

[Obsidian]

Hell, I think Fox should run a promotion for X4 by giving the fans a chance to write with the writer's on a certain scene. Throw out a scene on the website and tell the fans to write it out. Set rules like time limit, dialogue, expenses, locations, etc...and the winner can have a chance for their scene to be in the movie or a chance to work with the writer's! Give the fans an official voice.

I think FOX should just stop putting so many restrictions for the writers to work with. Give them space and maybe they can pull of a decent script.

 

[Jigga]

my opinion is that phoenix wants jean to think she killed him. phoenix is putting the idea of jean killing scott in her head, so jean is freaking out because of that.

 

[oneteen]

Or that Jean overcomes the Phoenix/controls it enough to look for Scott at Alkali and stumbles upon his unconcious body. With his clothes all ripped up and everything.

 

[CapBeerCino]

I agree. Some are really bad, lol.

Anyway, am I the only one not seeing the big picture here? Who cares if Scott is dead or alive? When you have Logan replacing Scott in a story he shoulda starred in, there are bigger things to worry about then whether he dies or not.

Besides, what does he have to return to? The X-team, who was like "Oh $hit, they killed Kenny!"? A very dead Jean, whom LOGAN saved from herself? Xavier, a surrogate father picked at his shortcomings to Storm?

Sad and true. I wish I'd never watch x-3.

 

[Doright]

I think it's very possible even likely that he lives. I also think it could be an amusing story when he's found and he's $#@#@ off at Logan because no one took the time to look for him.

 

[Kurosawa]

I agree. Some are really bad, lol.

Anyway, am I the only one not seeing the big picture here? Who cares if Scott is dead or alive? When you have Logan replacing Scott in a story he shoulda starred in, there are bigger things to worry about then whether he dies or not.

Besides, what does he have to return to? The X-team, who was like "Oh $hit, they killed Kenny!"? A very dead Jean, whom LOGAN saved from herself? Xavier, a surrogate father picked at his shortcomings to Storm?

Exactly. The entire series sucked for Cyclops.

I wish they'd never even made the X-Men movies.

 

[D-scythe]

Exactly. The entire series sucked for Cyclops.

I wish they'd never even made the X-Men movies.

Well, it wasn't all bad. There were fun parts to the ride. It was entertaining, if biased.

 

[Amm-arD]

so are people saying that its possible for Cyclops, Proff X AND Jean to come back?!?!

 

[Endeavor]

Cyclops didn't have the glasses on when they were kissing, remember? She had asked him to take them off.

 

[FaT_tONle]

I just don't remember Cyclops being Cyclops without Jean by his side... what kind of leader would he have been without Jean... That's why I didn't have major problems with it because a Cyclops story never really worked without Jean... the solution for X4... Storm and Beast take over... Iceman replaces Cyke as field manager... and Rouge/Kitty become the Jean/Storm of X1... then build around them with the younger guys and Gambit...

 

[Johnny Drama]

Whether he died or not, he was still absent from pretty much the whole movie and that is just unacceptable.

 

[Johnny Drama]

Can I also say that Brett Rattner raped Scott Summers from all sides? From front to back, sideways, upside down, with the lights on and again with the lights off. X3 can suck my balls.

 

[supermarvelman]

If they do make any sequals and they involve Mr. Sinister and/or Apocolypse, my guess is that Cylcops is will be back.

 

[Tommy]

If Fox gave a damn about fan reaction they had time to change the AICN script but they didn't.

They technically did. This is the exact quote from the piece on AICN:

The script describes Scott’s skin as “shivering” until he is simply de-molecularized.

Based on that, originally they were to show it happen and it was going to be a certain thing with point of no return. But what we got was a quick cut away followed by them dancing around the subject for the rest of the film.

Yes, Jean says "Before I kill someone else", but Jean didn't know WHAT the hell was going on. Her very own flashbacks, which we saw, were nothing concrete. That's the extent of what she remembered, and I think she just feared the worst. Hell Logan himself wasn't convinced by it. "I think she killed Scott" he says to Storm. THINK. That's why they held a funeral for Xavier and not Scott, because they weren't sure of his fate. Yes Xavier says to her that she killed Scott, the same Xavier that didn't know Jean was alive for how many months?

The fact of the matter is that no matter what, Cyclops had to have a very limited role in this film thanks to Singer. So no they didn't completely change what they had written for him, but they didn't make it a certain thing like they had originally planned. They gave us all hope.

Jean being unconscious was very conspicuous, as it was her being in a different place. I'd say it's a very big possibility that the real Jean managed to break through to prevent Cyclops from being killed, but at the same time control over his Optic Blast was lost, sending her over to where we saw her, knocking her out, and sending Scott back into the woods far enough from the site that Logan and Storm wouldn't find him.

Say what you will, but SOMETHING has to explain Jean being out cold. She took out Xavier, a much more powerful mutant, and was fine. She took out tons of people on Alcatraz, and was fine. Her powers were limitless, and that's why I believe something had to have happened to her to be knocked out cold, not to mention in a different location.

 

[The Kid]

Jean knew she killed her man. tis why she wanted to be killed.

he's dead.

 

[Sun_Down]

Jean knew she killed her man. tis why she wanted to be killed.

he's dead.

And Xavier knew too. People, the man is dead.

Do you guys not see the irony here? Comic book fans complain constantly that deaths are never permanent and that writers always find a way to restore the status quo. We say that it's insulting to constantly revert to our comfort zone, yet whenever something extreme happens, like the death of a character, we ***** and moan for them to undo it. Now a number of extreme events have occurred in the movieverse and before the dust can even settle, you're all asking them to restore the status quo! If they bring Cyke back, it will set the same precedent for death in the movieverse that we have in comicverse, and that should not come to pass.

 

[lordofthenerds]

He's dead. His skin was ****ing bubbling.

 

[ZombieONE]

(if there is a deleted scene showing him die then what im about to type has just been proven wrong)

they didnt show him die. so they could bring him back if they wanted. end of story.

 

[Kurosawa]

Can I also say that Brett Rattner raped Scott Summers from all sides? From front to back, sideways, upside down, with the lights on and again with the lights off. X3 can suck my balls.