Another Positive Thor Review! !!new!!

Still A ThorFan

Sidekick
Joined
Aug 3, 2004
Messages
1,255
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Thor, God of Thunder, Comics AND Film?!?
It has been quite some time since I last checked in and did a little blogging, so I figured with the proper bug up my ass it was time to lay down some blog geekery. I know much has already been said about Thor, but for some reason, I never thought there would be much to say by me. I respect the Thor character, and love the legacy. I know there have been some great stories told, and hell ... I even love me some Beta Ray Bill ... but I've never really read Thor. However, it seems the Asgardian is making a big old comeback and he has my attention.

I was recently handed a copy of the greenlit Thor script by Mark Protosevich, and I absolutely loved it. While only a first draft of the script, this thing is epic! I just hope that a majority of what is in this first draft makes its way to that silver screen. Protosevich focuses his story on Asgard and Midgard, no modern day touches, no Dr. Don Blake ... and in that, it is amazing. I think a focus on earthly elements would water down the fact that Thor's a freakin' god. Like so many complaints with Transformers, what people wanted was giant robots, and not lame humans. In a Thor movie, you need to deal with gods, and this script does exactly that.

It is an origin story that has all of the characters you'd hope to see in Odin, Balder, Fandral, Volstagg, Thor, of course ... and who would you like to see as the villain? I hope your answer is Loki because the portrayal here is fantastically fun. While just words on the page, the moment where Loki dons his famous green and yellow duds with the long horns is so vivid and exciting. The film feels like Lord of the Rings meets Spider-Man ... and I only bring in Spider-Man because the first two films capture the comic-bookish feel so well. And that is what Thor is: It's epic, filled with adventure, but doesn't forget that it's a comic book and not an adaptation of a literary classic.

When Loki's scheming leads to Thor being banished from Asgard, he must forget his vanity, find Mjolnir, and make his way home. I'm going to leave it at that, so as not to ruin anyone's fun or expectations, let's just say that it is the real deal, and if you haven't been excited about the prospect of a Thor film, well, start getting excited! With Matthew Vaughn onboard I really feel that this will be a much-talked-about Marvel film when it hits that silver screen. Vaughn has proven with Layer Cake that he can do action, and then again on Stardust, although it wasn't reviewed very favorably and kind of came and went at the box office, he proved that he can do fantasy and effects. That being the case, this could be a match made in heaven.
 
VERY cool! Where's that from Thorfan?
 
Like so many complaints with Transformers, what people wanted was giant robots, and not lame humans.

Yeah, where is it from? Because the above is kind of stupid: Transformers (the cartoon, the lore) has always about robots dumped on Earth and deal
with human beings & creations. That's how they got their transformation modes by mimicing cars, planes, etc.
 
I think what SATF meant was that Transformers got some heat for being more about 'a boy and his car' with only a relatively few Transformers shown.
 
1. It's expensive to show more than a dozen different TFs in CGI
2. Taking a cue from the cartoon/comics, TF is about robots that socialize with humans. Spike and Bumblebee relationship is one of the most noted.
 
Yes but who gives a rats ass about the human characters? :oldrazz: I know I never gave a flying **** about Spike and his friends. What they could do was never nearly as cool as the Transformers.

So I totally get where this guy's coming from and the script sounds great. Thor is still going to be humbled and suffer the same punishment but without turning human. The search for Mjolnir is going to be awesome. :up:
 
Sounds good,epics are good and you can't go wrong with gods.Hopefully this one breaks away from the typical Marvel flick.Quick origin --> adjusting to powers and personal life --> villain emerges --> etc.

The blogger is also on the money about the current Thor series.Only 3 issues in and it's a doozy,highly recommended.
 
Mmmmm... Lord of the Rings meet Spider-Man, I like that.
 
I like that this isn't an origin movie but just kicks off with another adventure for Thor. Maybe Donald Blake can show up in an Avengers movie as a result of a spell or something since the guy has to fit in on earth anyway. Hell, it could just be an alias even...Nope. That's ******ed. Just go with the whole spell turning him into Donald Blake thing.
 
grrrr... I'm ticked that there's no Don Blake.. but screw it.. better he not be there at all than to mess it up with a bad script/actor..
still, it could have been great, "E.R. meets Superman"...
 
I still see there are some D.B fans around. Since I first wanted a Thor movie I didnt' want D.B to have anything to do with it, at least not the first film. If Thor took place on modern earth it wouldn't have been no different from all of the other movies we got so far with the secret idenitiies, personal problems and secrets. This is different, this is good.

I got the news from a competing site. Not sure if the moderators want me to shout them out so I won't publically. I think last time I did they removed my post.
 
Sounds good,epics are good and you can't go wrong with gods.Hopefully this one breaks away from the typical Marvel flick.Quick origin --> adjusting to powers and personal life --> villain emerges --> etc.

Yeah I agree 100%. This is something I try to explain to anyone who wants D.B in the film.
 
I'd rather they NOT have DB in the 1st film, and lead INTO that part of the history.
 
i dont like thor and i dont know why????
i think he is not that cool
 
Well have you Read any of the new series? Thor is being revamped in a very POSITIVE manner.
 
No need for Donald Blake if they're going for Asgard-only.

Donald Blake has to be done in the beginning or not at all.
 
I'm glad Donald Blake isn't in it. The Last thing we need is some E.R. story diluting amazing Norse God awesomeness.

Frost Giants, and Elves, and Trolls oh, my!
 
I still see there are some D.B fans around. Since I first wanted a Thor movie I didnt' want D.B to have anything to do with it, at least not the first film. If Thor took place on modern earth it wouldn't have been no different from all of the other movies we got so far with the secret idenitiies, personal problems and secrets. This is different, this is good.

Sounds like a very smart move, making a fantasy epic as opposed to another Superhero movie.
 
Yes but who gives a rats ass about the human characters? :oldrazz: I know I never gave a flying **** about Spike and his friends. What they could do was never nearly as cool as the Transformers.

So I totally get where this guy's coming from and the script sounds great. Thor is still going to be humbled and suffer the same punishment but without turning human. The search for Mjolnir is going to be awesome. :up:
fair, but a lot of people did like that those two became best friends.
It made it easier for us as kids to pretend that a transformer could be our friend. As well as making it easier to place ourselves in the stories. seriously as a kid how much would you have loved it if you had your own transformer.
I would not worry about the sequel, I bet we will see double the number of bots. more familiar faces, and some serious villans. Maybe some combining robots. They could rebuild devastator.
 
See I never wanted to be FRIENDS with a Transformer. I wanted to BE a Transformer. That was the difference between me and the other kids at the time I guess. I mean I see a Spike and Optimus Prime costume next to each other, you can bet your ass I'm going for Prime.
 
Reading this review, I wonder if Thor still ends up on Earth in the film, but without the whole Don Blake storyline?
 
Though it is part of Thor's Marvel origin..I never like the Donald Blake aspect. Thor was more interesting when he was just Thor. For most of the character's run he was just that. I think they figured out early on to bail on the DB angle.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"