

http://s11.photobucket.com/albums/a...hunderbird.gif&refPage=300&imgAnch=imgAnch317
http://s11.photobucket.com/albums/a...hunderbird.gif&refPage=300&imgAnch=imgAnch317JewishHobbit said:Thunderbird III Vs Halloween Jack
Now this is a tough match for me to debate because I love Jack oh so much,... but alas, he must die!
JewishHobbit said:Neither of these characters will be aided by the location, and neither will know anything about one another. Jack is from the future, and though he is currently in the main 616 timeline, he hasn't been seen since his first appeaance in an issue of X-Force.
JewishHobbit said:Now, that being said we have both parties showing up in this town that is inhabited. Neal wouldn't provide much of a threat, and Jack isn't one to just cause turmoil, until he's ready for it. He'd be flying around as a bird, or just disguised as a person, until he finds Neal. He would then study him, but Neal would have no reason to use his power, so Neal would get nothing from him that way. Jack isn't a man of patience, so he would eventually just show himself, probably in the form of a bird or beast, or child with a knife, etc.
JewishHobbit said:Talk would ensue and finally I picture Jack endangering a human life to force Neal into using his powers. He'd would do so, firing off a bit of plasma to the ground, and Jack would have his answer.
All is going Jack's way so far, but the thing is that Neal is no dummy. He was trained by the best of the X-Men in Jean and Cable, then Xavier, then Storm and lastely Bishop. He would know that Jack is trying to gage his powers, and so he showed them... but not all of them. Jack would know that he can shoot plasma, but Neal hadn't shown him that he can actually turn his form into Plasma.
The way I see it, Jack would take advantage of this and keep the hostage as a shield until he strikes in the form of a snake or something quick. He would quickly attack and flea, attack and flea, etc. Probably taking the forms of a snake, a beast, a bird, etc. I know that he can retain the powers of another person copied, but I actually do not remember him ever using that ability in the comics. He mostly just turned into animals or beasts and that was it. He never used Meanstreak's speed, and he was around him constantly. So I don't think he'd use that much. Also, Jack is smart, very smart.
What do we know about Halloween Jack. He is a different version of Loki with extensive shape shifting powers and power absorption. Also, he remembers and can reproduce all the powers he has stolen before. He is however a bit insane. I would say think of the movie character The Mask and add absorption powers to him. Now Thunderbird is a powerful being but he is going up against an insane shape-shifting, power absorbing, magic using god–like being.
Of course, thunderbird would not have a clue who Halloween Jack is as he is a 2099 character whereas HJ would know about Thunderstrike as a historical character.
The way I see this battle happening is for Thunderbird using flight will go searching for Halloween Jack. Of course, he has no idea what he is searching for because HJ could just as easily be in the form of a fly or a cow. As Halloween Jack has the powers of Meanstreak, among others, he can use whatever form he is in and super speed over to Thunderbird and simply touch him…at that touch he also gains all of Thunderbird’s powers. The battle could only go one way and that is the defeat of Thunderbird.
I would just like to note one thing, Halloween Jack was the villain of the 2099 X-Men series……yes it was him against all of the X-Men of that timeline and he was formidable.
Ahura Mazda said:Rebuttal
No he does not ...let me tell you why![]()
I will admit it is unlikely but not impossible that he knows but that really does not matter.....in any case as you say thunderbird would know nothing....
You seem to forget something as soon as Halloween Jack touches him he gains use of his powers as well as his psyche and knowledge of said powers. A bit like Rogue...
The thing is in the comics he is rarely put in a position where he needs to but in this scenario you know he could. Plus he would have full knowledge of Thunderbird just from a touch which he can take looking like a child as you so eloquently mention. Once he touches him he will have full use of his powers plus all the other powers he already has use of. I also would like to put forward that he necessarily has meanstreak's powers as he has touched him many times. He just never needed to use them.
Also as you say he mostly used his changing into well known forms but mostly is not always and when circumstances demand it Halloween Jack can be very powerful. One wehere he is a match for the full x-men.
Therefore with plasma powers, superstrength, superspeed, shape shifting abilities, and a true devlish streak Halloween Jack would take this.
Lets not forget, Halloween Jack is endowed with the full powers of Loki among others, as well.


JewishHobbit said:The Mask is a great comparison!

JewishHobbit said:As mentioned in my debate, the heroes of the 20th century weren't as well known. Main names were known, but not minor ones. Heck, when Miguel O'hara brought up Spiderman, most didn't know who he was talking about. A minor name like Thunderbird wouldn't be remembered, I think it's safe to say.
JewishHobbit said:Not a bad idea but Jack seldom used other people's powers (truth is, I can't remember one time where he did). I know that the bios say he can do this, and he probably could, but it didn't happen enough to where it was common, so him doing it so much in this match would be unlike him and a bit of a stretch.
JewishHobbit said:Jack was a great character, but he's not as formidable as it sounds. First off, he never faced all the X-Men. He took out Luna with a surprise attack, and then pursuaded Meanstreak to follow him to Vegas. Then at vegas he fought Meanstreak and Krystalin, and lost. That was the only time he's faught the X-Men. While in Vegas we see him fight the Enforcers, but they're pretty much a joke, so that wasn't anything big, and he had Meanstreak's help at that. Then he fought a huge brute guy and was losing until Meanstreak saved his butt. Big Brute guy attacked again later, but Doom killed him without hesitation. After Krystalin and Meanstreak's defeating him in Vegas, that was the last we saw him in the X-Men 2099 book. Now there's a continuity err after that, but both stories dont' make Jack look very good either. The world was flooded by Atlantis, and the heroes of the world fled. Jack became a contestant in Vulture 2099's arena of death, and in it he coward and was killed by one punch by a bahemoth character. Not good for Jack. The other side of the continuity err was that when the world was flooding, he traveled back to the heroic age (current age). He fell in love with Domino and sadistically tried to capture her. Domino single handedly kicked the crap out of him... and Domino sucks. That's not saying much for Jack.
In truth, I don't think Jack ever won a fight on his own, with the exception of his attacking Luna from behind.
JewishHobbit said:This is true, and I'll grant you the touching thing... so we'll let this point go.
JewishHobbit said:Again, I'll let this go also. I don't remember it ever stated in the comics, but since I've read several bios mentioning it, I'll let it ride..
JewishHobbit said:Okay, deal... I like the idea of him becoming a child and touching him to get his powers. That could work well, and I can see him doing that. However, would he actually use the powers? Or Meansteaks? The thing is, he could have used them against the brute that attacked him (Lynton Synge I think his name was) but he didn't. He jumped around all agile like for a while, but in the end he was being choked in a headlock begging the guards to shoot the man... and then Meanstreak came along and saved him. He obviously didn't use speed there. Why would he use it in this match?
JewishHobbit said:Also, he would probably then know that Neal can turn into Plasma, but can he predict when it'd happen? No. He has to attack somehow, and that means he has to get physical. Now, he can get burnt close up when the time is right (as he has been hit in mid attack before) or he can get burnt when a plasma blast hits him. Remember, Neal's plasma blasts are extremely quick, like a lazer beam. It isn't slow sludgy stuff. Jack could dodge it for a while, but eventually he'll mess up. And if he KNOWS that Neal can turn into Plasma, he'd be more hardpressed to come in close for a physical attack, which is about all he's good for.
JewishHobbit said:He would be a heck of a threat, but he's never utilized his might in the comics, and it goes to say he wouldn't here either. Heck, he wanted to take on Doom when he became President of the United States, and did squat. He spouted threats and promises, but no attack. Why? Because Jack is all talk no bite!
Zoken said:Hey Boss-Men, can we get a ruling on time of day? Topher's a vamp who's only known weakness is sunlight.