Okay, so it's been a while since debating and I'm probably off my game, but this would still be a damn good match. I feel 100% confident in saying that no matter who wins, most of Stamford will die.
As for prep time and location it is a wash. Neither will probably know anythign about the other, and both don't care about the people of Stamford either.
Exodus' 2 strongest powers are his shield (which he can use to crush cities) and his telepathy. He's fought off some of the most powerful physchics and telepaths in the MU including Xavier and Sersi and has even shown to be able to reverse Xavier's mental controls on people. Ultimus has a wide variety of powers, but absolutely nowhere does it state any sort of psychic defense. Without a psychic defense, his mind is open to Exodus and he is absolutely dead. Exodus would either turn him into one of his willing followers, or simply shut down his brain killing him.
As a whole, the Eternals have many different cosmic powers. They have superhuman strength, with many being able to lift in excess of 15 tons. They have such a fine control over their bodies with the cosmic energy that they are almost completely unkillable, making them immortal. As seen in the most recent series, acid, energy, falling, and many other ways have been used to kill the Eternals leader, Ikaris, but only to fail.
The Eternals also have many other fantastic powers, such as being able to fly and levitate others, being able to achieve speeds of hundreds of miles an hour. They have superhuman speed and are also able to teleport themselves, but can become taxed and even disorientated afterward. Their other abilities include being able to shoot beams of energy from their hands and eyes, telepathy, and they can also transmute objects, which means they are able to change objects from one thing to another.
If Exodus didn't feel like doing this, he could just simply crush him under his forcefield or destroy him with his energy blasts. Exodus' forcefield (which is among the strognest in the MU) is always up and pretty much protects him fomr anything Ultimus could try and throw at him.
Since this is addressed later, I'll just skip this part and cover it below.I actually found an argument that might show that Ultimus could very well know about Exodus. It will be shown below, in some interesting facts I discovered that might change this battle somewhat.
But a durability to telepathy doesn't mean much when Exodus has rocked other people who are known to have amazing telepathic defenses. Jean Grey and Xavier together couldn't beat Exodus telepathically, and another time he knocked out Cable with his telepathy.Ok, this is the point I wanted to touch on. Little is know about Ultimus, but one imporant fact is that he is a "Kree Eternal." The discovery of this comes from his previous alias, Demon Druid. (This also explains his powers, too.) Now, I'm having trouble pinpointing the specific attributes of the Kree, but I do know Ms. Marvel has telepathy blockers with her human/kree physiology. Let's focus on the attributes of the Eternals:
If you combine these powers with the powers of the Kree, it shows why his durability and powers are so staggering. It's also stands to reason he'd have a durability to telepathy.
I honestly think this is stretching it quite a bit. To think that Sersi went over every single battle she ever fought and logged them so that they are in the Starforce database seems a little thin. There isn't any proof of him being in a database, of course there isn't any proof he isn't in it either. I personally think it's a stretch, but I guess that is up to the individual voter.Now, how can Ultimus know about Exodus and gain an advantage in the fight? You pointed out that Exodus fought Sersi, who is a known Eternal. Sersi was also involved in Kree affairs; thus, it stands to reason, especially with Ultimus being a member of the Starforce, that he might very well have information about Sersi through either Kree or Eternal sources.
Why would cosmic energy trump Exodus'? He has fought and beaten Sersi before who has huge amounts of cosmic energies and her powers didn't trump Exodus' just because they were Cosmic.The problem is that Ultimus has a forcefield, too; and, it's very likely this won't work as well as figured. (And, they both have energy blasts, though different in origin. Ultimus' are cosmic while Exodus' are pyroplasmic. I'm not positive, but in my mind I give Cosmic powers and the ability to manipulate it over Pyroplasmic.)
But a durability to telepathy doesn't mean much when Exodus has rocked other people who are known to have amazing telepathic defenses. Jean Grey and Xavier together couldn't beat Exodus telepathically, and another time he knocked out Cable with his telepathy.
Exodus survived, his powers reverted to normal, and he returned to leading the Acolytes.
Together they took Quicksilver, the Knights of Wundagore, and the Heroes For Hire prisoner. Quicksilver eventually escaped, gained control of Isotope E himself, turned the isotope on himself, and became more powerful than he had ever been before. Exodus apparently proved no match for the super-charged Quicksilver and was soundly defeated.
With the High Evolutionary de-powered, Quicksilver reverted to normal, and Thena incapacitated, Exodus attempted once more to destroy the High Evolutionary. However, he was again halted in his attempt, this time by the voice of the Black Knight. The Knight allowed Exodus into his mind where the mutant discovered that this Black Knight was his friend from centuries ago. The two then engaged in combat until the Black Knight defeated Exodus and once again sealed him in the crypt Apocalypse had created.
This experience apparently leads him to renew his conviction that mutants were superior and that they were intended to inherit the earth. Having formed a new Brotherhood consisting of Avalanche, Nocturne, Sabretooth, Mammomax and Black Tom, Exodus leads an attack on a group of humans but was thwarted by the X-Men. After escaping, this new Brotherhood decideds to attack the X-Men in their home. Two of the residents, a young mutant child and a cafeteria employee, die as a result. For the Brotherhood the attack proves a complete disaster, resulting in most of the Brotherhood, Exodus included, being sucked into the mutant Xorn's head. They reappear in Mojoworld and make a deal with Mojo to leave. It is unknown whether this deal will come up later.
These are major forces in the telepathic world. Now, Ultimus might have some small form of defense to telepathy, but he would need MAJOR power to keep out Exodus this way. And I don't think you can in any way say Ultimus has THIS much power since it has never at all been talked about.
Why would cosmic energy trump Exodus'? He has fought and beaten Sersi before who has huge amounts of cosmic energies and her powers didn't trump Exodus' just because they were Cosmic.
Also, another thing I will point out (without quoting your first post) is that Exodus' psychic vampire drain doesn't have to just work on psychics. Even though Ultimus uses cosmic energy for his powers, all he really needs is a brain to be drained of psychic energy. Exodus used to drain regular people all the time. In fact, he could easily get a power boost by draining the people of Stamford (however long they lived) if he needed to.
Just because Ultimus won't be actually battling Exodus telepathically doesn't mean Exodus can't still attack Ultimus telepathically. He has shown before that he like to attack both physically AND telepathically at the same time. And since Ultimus has NEVER been said to have any sort of resistance at all to telepathy, it's a safe assumption that he will be vulnerable.But, this isn't a telepathic battle for Ultimus and Exodus. This is a battle where Exodus for sure knows nothing about Ultimus, and where there is a chance that Ultimus might know about things that have happened with a fellow Eternal in the past.
Actually this is quite wrong. He has recently gone back to his origninal power levels (right around the time of Decimation (I'm not counting the House of M though since I'm pretty sure it's not canon). This is when he absolutely destroyed a SHIELD heli-carrier (which had an X-Men team already there), messed with the brains of those psychic twin defense people, freed some prisoners, knocked out Cable, stole some of Cable's memories, and then created a huge new Cerebro (I beleive out of the SHIELD wreckage to search for any more living mutants).Also, after researching Exodus a bit more, his power used to be at a much higher level than it is now. For example of this, I provide the following quotes after some of the defeats you mentioned:
This is after the feats you describe above, and right after X-Man defeated him soundly.
The new uber-powerful Quicksilver thing was a defeat, but as you say, this was super-charged Quicksilver.So, a super-charged Quicksilver was able to defeat Exodus after his powers reverted back to normal. While this isn't the usual Quicksilver, I doubt the higher-powered Exodus would have met his defeat in such a way.
So, now the reverted Exodus has been defeated by the Black Knight. Hmmmm....
So, Exodus is defeated a third time. This shows a misconception in our thoughts on Exodus' powers. He has been as powerful as shown, but obviously, times have changed.
he wasn't physically defeated by black Knight, and as for Quicksliver, this was the major upgraded version that could control time and all that crap. And anyway, the newer version of Exodus has reverted back to his old power levels while aligning himself with Sinister. The old version has defeated every single one of these people (except maybe Xorn, not sure they fought)that "defeated" him at his weaker levels.This is true to the old Exodus...the reverted Exodus isn't the same. After all, if Exodus was at this old levels, he wouldn't have been defeated by Quicksilver and Black Knight.
No he wasn't. He has the exact same power levels as he does now.When he fought Sersi, he was a different Exodus than he is now. Times change.
Why wouldn't he expect it? He knows nothign about him, so he will take the utmost precaution going in. he will also look into Ultimus' mind and see his powers.Ultimus isn't a regular person, and his durability is very, very high. His Kree and Eternal physiology puts him up on a higher par, and Exodus isn't going to expect this.