Contest of Marvels II Thread 1

[kytrigger]

Metalhead Vs Photon

Metalhead HITS HIM WITH A BIG STICK!!!!

Winner - Metalhead

Rebuttal

NUH UH!!!

Winner- Photon

 

[Phaedrus45]

Voting May Begin!

 

[Harlekin]

Caliban
Wind Dancer - Good debate, and although I love Squirrel Girl, I do not feel comfortable taking into account her wins against people such as Thanos. That would make her entirely too powerful for this competition.
Photon - Nice try JH, but Photon is just a league too high for Metalhead.
Moon Knight

 

[kytrigger]

Caliban
Squirrel Girl -While I didn't just use her wins against people like Thanos as the end all reason for her to win, I did use them as a reference of her experience. She does have more than Wind Dancer, especially in tough battles. This tips the favor to her in an otherwise awesome match and debate.
Moon Knight
Photon-because he's stick-proof

 

[wiegeabo]

Caliban
Squirrel Girl (went back and forth several times)
Photon
Moon Knight

 

[hippy fascist]

Caliban
Squirrel Girl (she may well be a joke character but those wins are in continuity)
Photon
Moon Knight(with a debate this could have gone either way)

 

[Phaedrus45]

*Caliban

*Squirrel Girl - (Great debate...but, the way things are going, we're going to have quite a few debates about continuity and whether humorous books should be taken into account. BTW, SG's wins over people like Thanos didn't play into my decision.)

*Photon-Genis

*Moon Knight - (I had to debate against Whirlwind last season, and I learned what a joke he is. Moon Knight takes this easily.)

 

[Hellstormer]

Moon Knight (I feel kinda bad because I understand Powered is going through some tough stuff but MK has faced tougher in worst conditions)
Caliban (I couldn't find any support for Flatman so...)
Wind Dancer (I'll admit I didn't read the entire debate but it seemed like, in the first couple rebuttals, that Wind Dancer has the major advantage and I've seen how much she has grown and how strong she is through the pages of New Mutants and New X-men)
Photon (Ummmm yea he's like a God)

 

[Zoken]

Caliban
Squirrel Girl
Photon
Moon Knight

 

[WOLVERINE25TH]

Caliban
Photon
Wind Dancer
Moon Knight

 

[Phaedrus45]

Results So Far:

Caliban currently beating Flatman 8-0
Squirrel Girl currently beating Wind Dancer 5-3
Photon currently beating Metalhead 8-0
Moon Knight currently beating Whirlwind 8-0

 

[PinnyPed]

Caliban
Wind Dancer
Photon
Whirlwind

 

[Darren Daring]

Caliban
Squirrel Girl
Photon
Moon Knight

 

[DarkHellRider]

Caliban
Squirrel Girl
Photon
Moon Knight

 

[Ahura Mazda]

Caliban
Wind Dancer (I have a real problem with Squirrel Girl as a character in this contest, but I must say Zoken debated very well)
Photon (Not much to say, even before the insane super uber power surge he was too much for metal head)
Moon Knight

 

[Midnight Ice]

Caliban
Photon
Wind Dancer
Moon Knight

 

[Phaedrus45]

Results So Far:

Caliban currently beating Flatman 12-0
Squirrel Girl currently beating Wind Dancer 7-5
Photon currently beating Metalhead 12-0
Moon Knight currently beating Whirlwind 12-0

(PinnyPed's votes cannot be counted. He/she only has voted in two threads and doesn't have a high enough post count.)

 

[Ahura Mazda]

(PinnyPed's votes cannot be counted. He/she only has voted in two threads and doesn't have a high enough post count.)

That sucks for me ... but it is only fair

 

[Iceman]

Edit - Double

 

[Iceman]

Caliban (easy victory)
Squirrel Girl (not sure that she should be included in this tournament)
Photon (easy victory)
Moon Knight (hope to see some good matches with this character in later rounds)

 

[Hellstormer]

Moon Knight (hope to see some good matches with this character in later rounds)

Don't worry I know this character inside and out I have almost every appearence of him.

Results So Far:

Caliban currently beating Flatman 12-0
Squirrel Girl currently beating Wind Dancer 7-5
Photon currently beating Metalhead 12-0
Moon Knight currently beating Whirlwind 12-0

(PinnyPed's votes cannot be counted. He/she only has voted in two threads and doesn't have a high enough post count.)

Wow one-sided thread here.

 

[Phaedrus45]

Don't worry I know this character inside and out I have almost every appearence of him.

You have quite the battle ahead of you next round, though. Dang, I wouldn't want any of my characters facing Photon. There is just too much left to chance with him.

 

[Hellstormer]

You have quite the battle ahead of you next round, though. Dang, I wouldn't want any of my characters facing Photon. There is just too much left to chance with him.

Is my next battle really with Photon? That's gonna be a toughy can I get a full moon?

 

[JewishHobbit]

You have quite the battle ahead of you next round, though. Dang, I wouldn't want any of my characters facing Photon. There is just too much left to chance with him.

Yeah, that sucked so much. I was excited about getting my X-Men 2099's in the tourney this season, then I somehow managed to only get Metalhead... and he goes against Photon first round. That sucks. Next season they're sooo going first on my list... after Nico.




And my vote

Caliban
Wind Dancer
Metalhead
Moon Knight

Awsome debate with SG... but I just wasn't yet convinced.

 

[Darthphere]

Caliban
Wind Dancer
Metalhead
Moon Knight