Did black suited Spider-Man kill a man?

[Spider-Fan]

At what exactly? I gave you examples of the spider-sense in the movie.

 

[Apollo]

if i was spider-man i would have seen eddie running to the bomb so i would quickly had web pulled him to safety and slap him across the face screamin "Damn Fool!"

 

[Noir]

at being good, SM3 was basicly a giant special effects heaven with a bunch of ****ing Dancing..

 

[Spider-Fan]

if i was spider-man i would have seen eddie running to the bomb so i would quickly had web pulled him to safety and slap him across the face screamin "Damn Fool!"

That is different than saying the spider-sense would have warned him. Brock jumping in there surprised him, and he was slow to react as a result.

And NOIR, you are entitled to your opinion, of course.

 

[Man-E-Toys]

Just admit it..

this movie Failed..

thanks for adding this great nugget of information to my thread.


can we please get back on topic?

 

[lordofthenerds]

at being good, SM3 was basicly a giant special effects heaven with a bunch of ****ing Dancing..

Dude, you're aware that you're coming off as border-line troll, right?

 

[Drizzle]

Alright, back to topic...

I don't think Spider-Man killed that guy. He just f**ked him up really bad. That guy's got hospital bills in the quadruple digits.

 

[CARNAGE-COMETH]

It's a Fake! Eddie Brock super imposed that image of Spider-Man crushing that guys skull in a cab window.

Spider-Man is a hero.

Although he has a pension for beating up women he would never....read my lips NEVER HURT ANOTHER HUMAN BEING.

Unless they cheat on him with his best friend but that doesn't count.

 

[DACrowe]

Nah.

I think it was showing how brutal and harsh black suited Spidey was being (which isn't far off) I mean we saw this in him trying to kill Sandman and Harry as well. It probably was music to JJJ's ears but at this point Peter was so far gone, he just didn't care anymore how he did his things, as seen.

 

[OverMyHead]

Wow, c'mon guys--Spidey fans.

You don't know where that scene is from?

That is another plot-hole curteosy of Sam Raimi. That is the scene where Sandman flung that one cop in the car behind the dump truck, and the girl was screaming, while her mouth was not even opened. That was seriously some horrible editing by Saimi's crew. You can hear the scream of a woman, but her lips aren't even moving. WTf?

 

[Deadpool876]

I think they just showed him being extreme to crooks, not kill them. There are a few pics like that in the scene.

If they died, I am sure it would have been mentioned.

Yeah, you're probably right. If Spidey killed him, it will be big news on NY city and MJ would have freak out on Peter.

Hmmm...also I'm wondering...if there's gonna be a director's cut dvd (I hope there will be one), I think there'll be scenes of black-suited Spidey being extreme at criminals; that would be cool, it will show how much evil influence the suit gives him..not just Pete doing his f****** dancing. t:

 

[plant_man]

ok, lets try this again. i was really surprised when my 1st thread was closed. i have no idea why. i said nothing offensive nor did anyone else who replied. i simply stated what i thought was fact. maybe this time other users and myself can discuss the topic at hand.

now let's take a look at this picture...
keep in mind, that this is symbiote spider-man who we all know has a chip on his shoulder and who takes it much further than regular spider-man would.

what do you honestly think he is doing in this picture? the few replies my other thread did receive honestly thought that spider-man was saving this guy. saving him from what? he looks way past saving. when i look at this picture, i immediatley come to the conclusion that spider-man grabbed this guy by the legs and smashed him through the windshield. i think that this is a pretty ballsy picture to throw into the movie but it does confirm the badass side of the symbiote.

i honestly can't interpret this picture any other way, but what do you guys think? did spider-man kill this guy?

He's killed before...and he'll kill againt:

 

[BrklynsVeryOwn]

Spider-Man wouldn't kill a normal thug and the Daily Bugle would have made a spectacle of it. He's smashing him through the windshield, and in movie world...anyone can do that without serious injury.

 

[plant_man]

brock killed himself. peter saved him from the suit but brock decided to jump in after it once he saw pete throw the bomb.

petes spider-sense should have spotted broke about to jump in the explosion so peter should have had enough time to web pull him back!

I'd love to hear both these as defense in court...

"Well, my Spider-sense was acting up...and it sometimes picks up dangers of others..."
"Your what?"
"My Spider-sense. Anyway, Well Mr.Brock lept forward as I was trying to kill the Alien symbiote with the Goblin Pumpkin Bomb...and well....I kinda just killed him...I didn't mean to. I was trying to save him"

I think if Nolan got hold of it and made it more gritty it would have that scene....
I hope..

 

[Deadpool876]

Maybe black-suited Spidey did kill the guy or at least seriously injuring him and there will be scenes (at the dc dvd; I hope there'll be one) showing these and of the city hating him and MJ freaking out at Peter because he's becoming violent.

And remember near the end, (I think he said this, someone refresh my memory) Spidey said "I did terrible things" -- now this got me wondering, what terrible things could he have done besides the dancing, pushing MJ, exposing Brock, harrassing women (he was freaking out women in the street scenes u know)?

So maybe, just maybe that there will be a dc dvd with scenes of black-suited Spidey being extreme to criminals. That would be cool...and logical too because like I said earlier, it will show how much evil influence the symbiote had on Spidey at being violent, not just making him do those f****** dancing! t:

 

[Venom 19]

Nah, Venom is always the darkest.

Black Suit Spider-Man "killed" Sandman, for all he knew sadistically "killed" his best friend, and knocked MJ violently to the ground.

He didn't need to kill common thugs... has Black Suit Spider-Man even ever done that???

And Noir, learn the difference between fact and opinion... or good riddence.

 

[Paste Pot Pete]

I can't believe how off-base people are with this whole symbiote thing. He did not kill anybody.

I know a lot of people were disappointed by not seeing Spider-Man foaming at the mouth, firing a machine gun at bank robbers. "Isn't he supposed to be evil?" they ask. The whole "darkness within" thing.

But what people aren't getting is that someone's personal darkness is different from someone else's. Peter is a GOOD guy. Even under the influence of the symbiote, he's simply not capable of doing truly monstrous things. The most evil he can get is getting revenge on the girl he thinks dumped him, the guy who's been trying to kill him, and the guy who killed his uncle. It's letting out his inhibitions...which, for a nerd like Peter, aren't very extreme (they amount to dressing flashy and dancing like you think you're cool). That was his innocent little notion of badass-ery. But he still has the goodness and presence of mind to realize when he's finally crossed the line - when he hits MJ.

That's the whole reason Venom exists, to be a stark contrast to Peter. He doesn't have those morals that keep him from crossing the line. If he were the one who hit MJ, he wouldn't have stopped there. He'd have kept going and would've started killing. Peter wouldn't; that's why he's the hero and not the villain.

 

[Venom 19]

Well, Peter DID "kill" Sandman. He goes on to tell Aunt May that Spider-Man KILLED Sandman. Thus, yeah- Black Suit Spider-Man "kills." Just not a psychopath killing random thugs for no reason.

 

[Paste Pot Pete]

Well, Peter DID "kill" Sandman. He goes on to tell Aunt May that Spider-Man KILLED Sandman. Thus, yeah- Black Suit Spider-Man "kills." Just not a psychopath killing random thugs for no reason.

Well yeah. It's still different. If it makes any sense (and I hope this doesn't sound apologetic), Sandman was almost like a monster (especially to Peter at the time). He made a sand monster disintegrate. That's way different than smashing open the skull of a human being and watching their brains spill across the NY pavement.

 

[Venom 19]

Killing is killing. But, as I said before- and you agree with- there's a difference of having motivation and being a pscyhopath (going to bank robbers and snapping their necks or throwing thugs off of skyscrappers, lol- that would be fun!) But... still, he killed- yet had a 'good' motivation to. Which in the end he sees was the wrong way to deal with it.