BvS Jena Malone is in Batman v. Superman... Which role is she playing?

Which role is Jenna Malone playing?

  • Robin (Carrie Kelly)

  • Barbara Gordon (Oracle, Batgirl)

  • Dr. Harleen Quinzel

  • Cat Grant

  • Iris West

  • An Amazon from Themyscira

  • Other

  • Robin (Carrie Kelly)

  • Barbara Gordon (Oracle, Batgirl)

  • Dr. Harleen Quinzel

  • Cat Grant

  • Iris West

  • An Amazon from Themyscira

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Remember that Momoa was supposed to keep the secret 3 years!!! :funny:

I wonder if this secret worked after all.
 
If he's gonna give out anything out about the film, it will be something we can all guess so with that said, I wouldn't take everything he says too seriously. He said himself he can't speak much on it.

Yeah, good point.

Really if Selina Kyle was in this wouldn't know about it? We'd also be hearing from trades about the actresses up for this role because you can bet your a$$ a lot of talented and big time actresses would be gunning for the role.

Indeed. I don't see this passing unnoticed. We learned about Yung, Kurylenko and Gadot, even before the role was known and we also learned about Malone, even though it was really kept under the wraps. Among actresses auditioning for the role of Catwoman there would be some much bigger names than those mentioned above, and I don't see how we wouldn't hear anything at all.
 
While I want Blunt rumor to be true. It didn't have any support at that time. Man, I want Blunt for Catwoman so bad.
 
None of the trades had that story. John-An picked that news up from some obscure Spanish website. :funny: She was also filming Sicario at the time.

Yeah, I'm not believing it necessarily but like the Malone thing where most thought she was just set visiting, I wouldn't put it past Snyder to have some major surprises up his sleeve.
 
That's the attitude green!!! :bow:

Sorry but I want Blunt for Selina... :shrug:
 
He kept dropping HUGE hints every time he turned around!!

The only hint I remember is that he said he would never be Aquaman and what would be next, robin? he said he didn't suit that character, and if a role suited for him it was Lobo. Then he said that some fella made the rumor basing it on his opinion of BvS confrontation or something like that. Also the thing with the reporter, which have to fullfill (to be hit in the face) :sly:

If it wasn't for the trade sites, we wouldn't have known that EVER! before the movie's release.
 
That's the attitude green!!! :bow:

Sorry but I want Blunt for Selina... :shrug:

That's not the point I was making though. Remember that article you posted that said Emily Blunt was Selina Kyle in BATMANVSUPERMAN? Well it was obviously rubbish because she's not.
 
Yeah I remember it. I found it after all. It was when she was promoting Edge of Tomorrow.

Gezz man!! at least let us believe it for a second, it's a beautiful choice!! :argh: :o

I only will say this... if they kept Katana under wraps the time they wanted for Suicide Squad. I think Snyder (who is better with secrecy) can have some things under his sleeve... :shrug:
 
Emily Blunt is a much bigger name than the girl playing Katana. She would've been spotted coming into Detroit airport from 10 miles off the airport by papps. And Oh I never said she wouldn't be good that's another debate. I was debating in the validity of that crappy source.
 
The only hint I remember is that he said he would never be Aquaman and what would be next, robin? he said he didn't suit that character, and if a role suited for him it was Lobo. Then he said that some fella made the rumor basing it on his opinion of BvS confrontation or something like that. Also the thing with the reporter, which have to fullfill (to be hit in the face) :sly:

If it wasn't for the trade sites, we wouldn't have known that EVER! before the movie's release.

I remember him posting pics of him with Aquaman comics...that sold it for me. I knew then that he was Aquaman
 
^^ That was after Variety reported that he was Aquaman, wasn't it?

Emily Blunt is a much bigger name than the girl playing Katana. She would've been spotted coming into Detroit airport from 10 miles off the airport by papps. And Oh I never said she wouldn't be good that's another debate. I was debating in the validity of that crappy source.

Well, neither did I.

But we have to admit that there are multiple ways to make that really under secrecy (maybe she didn't came to Detroit but another location, after all, it's supposedly to be a cameo only, no need for too much time take out of her agenda. But that's another thing.

I said also that unfortunately the source didn't have anything to back it up. But it would be AWESOME :shrug: (Not saying you said it wasn't a good option :p)
 
^^ That was after Variety reported that he was Aquaman, wasn't it?



Well, neither did I.

But we have to admit that there are multiple ways to make that really under secrecy (maybe she didn't came to Detroit but another location, after all, it's supposedly to be a cameo only, no need for too much time take out of her agenda. But that's another thing.

I said also that unfortunately the source didn't have anything to back it up. But it would be AWESOME :shrug: (Not saying you said it wasn't a good option :p)

I don't believe so...
 
I won't be surprised if she is Babs. Hopefully she gets carried over into the solo if she is.
 

Thematically , it actually makes more sense that she's playing Barbara/Oracle rather than Carrie Kelly. With the illusions to the Joker killing Robin, and the focus on how Batman has become by BvS, it makes more sense that Barbara would be another character that was also hurt during the Joker's last spree.

Introducing a new Robin like Carrie Kelly would seem a bit of a distraction from the fact that he's lost the other Robin whom the audience hasn't seen. This way, you focus on Bruce's sense of loss for Robin without trying to explain there's this new Robin who the audience doesn't know but we also have to care about the other Robin we haven't been exposed to .
 
Thematically , it actually makes more sense that she's playing Barbara/Oracle rather than Carrie Kelly. With the illusions to the Joker killing Robin, and the focus on how Batman has become by BvS, it makes more sense that Barbara would be another character that was also hurt during the Joker's last spree.

Introducing a new Robin like Carrie Kelly would seem a bit of a distraction from the fact that he's lost the other Robin whom the audience hasn't seen. This way, you focus on Bruce's sense of loss for Robin without trying to explain there's this new Robin who the audience doesn't know but we also have to care about the other Robin we haven't been exposed to .
It also helps to establish this Batman's history by showing us ally's he once had, but potentially broke off contact with them. Plus Malone seems too old to play Carrie Kelly.
 
Another one of my dream castings becoming a reality? Yes please. :atp:

Rather not Oracle though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"