Just heared the STRANGEST thing ...

[PikaZeroX]

Someone has the Claremont novel?

 

[Tony Stark]

"empire strikes back book............ in the original book, vader wan't his father, he told luke that he killed his father"

Thats becuase NO ONE knew Vader was Lukes father. Those pages of the script were blank. David Prowse was told by Lucas how to make Vader act in that scene. There was no dialogue spoken. The only ones who knew were Lucas, James Earl Jones and Mark Hammill.

So there no way Lucas would have told the author of the novel 10 months or whatever in advance for the official novel.

Not to get off subject here, but what actually happened was Prowse was given the line "Obi-Wan killed your father." Ivin Kirstner who directed Empire told Hammil right before the take, he said "this is what the line that is going to be read, but here's what's actually going to be said in the movie."

 

[Kelsl1317]

*sigh* If only I really believed it was true...

 

[Speedball]

Not to get off subject here, but what actually happened was Prowse was given the line "Obi-Wan killed your father." Ivin Kirstner who directed Empire told Hammil right before the take, he said "this is what the line that is going to be read, but here's what's actually going to be said in the movie."

Exactly what happened

 

[JokerNick]

Exactly what happened

yep, that was my bad.......... vader Rules

 

[Speedball]

yep, that was my bad.......... vader Rules

No, i think the thing about the book was right too. It was written before the movie. Star Wars Episode IV was actually a published story written by Lucas a few years before the movie came out. LOL, Luke Starkiller. He probably changed the story as he was having the film made. In the first drafts of the Script, the final duel of Episode V was actually going to fought outside in space, but was probably too complicated and expensive to film.

 

[Avalanche]

So many are so arrogant as to predict the outcome of a film even before it is out, and that is the thing that gets my goat

Since when did making predictions become arrogant!

Some people are convinced he will die. Some people are convinced he won't. I don't think arrogance is really a factor.

 

[strugler]

So who has the Claremont novel?

i ordered mine from walmart.com and they emailed saying i will receive it this thusday hopefully though.
i will let you know guys by thursday

 

[Wolverini]

This topic can be closed.

Cyclops does indeed die. How or when is uncertain. The pickup scenes with Marsden where not ment for any further development in the movie. My source received false information. It isn't the first time you know.

Terribly sorry for all you Cyclops fans out there

 

[WorthyStevens]

This topic can be closed.

Cyclops does indeed die. How or when is uncertain. The pickup scenes with Marsden where not ment for any further development in the movie. My source received false information.

Terribly sorry

What?

 

[jusblaze21]

This topic can be closed.

Cyclops does indeed die. How or when is uncertain. The pickup scenes with Marsden where not ment for any further development in the movie. My source received false information. It isn't the first time you know.

Terribly sorry for all you Cyclops fans out there

Seriously?

 

[Wolverini]

Well here's the whole story.

My source got word that James Marsden had pickup scenes last month. Apparently the pickups scenes where inside the mansion. My source believed this Mansion scene was with Professor X and other X-MUTANTS. This is not the case... this happened to be the scene where Wolverine tries to calm Scott down because "Jean is dead". He also got told that the scenes in the trailer were ment to mislead us thanks to several pickups Marsden had to do in a short amount of time.

Unfortunatly the man who passed on the information to my source was wrong. I will try and get every piece of information and pass it on to YOU guys regarding Cyclops's Fate

 

[Spidey 2007]

Well here's the whole story.

My source got word that James Marsden had pickup scenes last month. Apparently the pickups scenes where inside the mansion. My source believed this Mansion scene was with Professor X and other X-MUTANTS. This is not the case... this happened to be the scene where Wolverine tries to calm Scott down because "Jean is dead". He also got told that the scenes in the trailer were ment to mislead us thanks to several pickups Marsden had to do in a short amount of time.

Unfortunatly the man who passed on the information to my source was wrong. I will try and get every piece of information and pass it on to YOU guys regarding Cyclops's Fate

so your saying that it might be a possibility that those shots in all the traielrs arnt going to be in the movie?!?!?

i think i prefer him getting knocked out... lol


ugh this calls for an updated graph...

 

[Wolverini]

Another update

"There is still not solid word on what happens to Cyclops. Nobody knows wether he dies or still lives. From what I've gathered on information he just "vanishes"."

So ... im puzzled

 

[WorthyStevens]

Another update

"There is still not solid word on what happens to Cyclops. Nobody knows wether he dies or still lives. From what I've gathered on information he just "vanishes"."

So ... im puzzled

So we still have that.

What about that e-mail you got from the person that said Scott is unconscious and taken to the mansion along with Jean?

 

[Aiden]

hmmm

concerns me does this

 

[Wolverini]

Oooooooook


Jean rises out of the lake and Cyclops is baffled. He tries to talk but cant. Jean approaches him and comforts him by telling him : "Its allright ..." Afterwards she just has a power frenzy which she cant control. She "sends" Scott elsewhere and then collapses on the floor

 

[Aiden]

sends....

*scratches chin*

Any word on the runtime?

 

[Wolverini]

So we still have that.

What about that e-mail you got from the person that said Scott is unconscious and taken to the mansion along with Jean?

The man who passes on information to my source said that Scott was injured badly and has been taken back to the Mansion. If this information is correct , I dont know. Im still hoping though.


Man , I feel like a complete ******* right now ...

 

[Aiden]

Don't, it's not your fault

 

[ororoandme]

this whole experience reminds me of the Simpsons episode where Homer has a heart attack. He is in Burns' office while Burns is yelling at him :P

 

[Spidey 2007]

The man who passes on information to my source said that Scott was injured badly and has been taken back to the Mansion. If this information is correct , I dont know. Im still hoping though.


Man , I feel like a complete ******* right now ...

lmfao this is great... theres one thread proving cyke dies, and yet one over here that has some word on him living!!!



i still theink the x3 novel can be misleading!

 

[Wolverini]

I got a reply and asked how much "different" the movie was compared to the 2 NOVELS that are out.

Two words :

"Quite significant"

He cant go into details , yet certain things are twisted or alot different then in the Claremont / Kids novel

 

[Aiden]

hmmm

 

[Wolverini]

Things might turn out alot different then has been revealed.

Cyke's faith is uncertain because Claremont doesnt go into detail how he dies / vanished

The kids novel does though. "His skin shivering blabibla"

1/1 ... lets hope he lives. Marsden even said he wore the suit during filming. Maybe ... nah ... I wont say that

I still feel like a complete assh0le