Let me tell you the absolute gold-diggers' truth: ideally,
no one wants to see an active, continuous profit-maker die. And the only ones you're currently hearing predict Season 9 to be the "
Final" are the trades -- and they've said that before, haven't they?
However (and this is where I begin to sound like Gandalf), it shouldn't be surprising to anyone here to note that
Smallville has always been a "special case" with
other forces at work...in its creative, production, and broadcast nature. It's a little like another franchise currently out there... "a child of two worlds," you know...