I think eventually Robin or a Robinesque character will be needed. For now, Batman and Bruce Wayne have plenty to deal with in light of TDK. I do have some ideas on introducing Robin:
--An enemy corporation to Wayne Enterprises gains access to blue-prints for some old military tech. They leak it to a trusted member of the Underworld in hopes of implicating Wayne Enterprises as a supporter of organized crime.
--A young man in the Narrows--20 or so--has joined one of the dominant gangs in order to survive. He joined young, and worked his way into the good graces of the gang leader. He hates what he does, but rationalizes it as a necessity of survival. He gains access to the technology and turns on the leaders of the gang. He murders them.
--Batman winds up investigating the deaths and learns of the new vigilante. Batman decides not to turn him in to the GPD. He sees the young man as a potential ally. So Batman mentors him, playing a role similar to that of Ra's. I'd like to see Batman use a variation of the fear gas, or some psychological techniques to discourage the vigilante from killing.
This would work best once the freaks have really started emerging. Roman Sionis aka Black Mask would be the best candidate for the business man who leaks the stolen Wayne Enterprises tech.
I don't know much about Robin beyond the Dark Victory origin; this may well be closer to one of the Nightwing characters...but its a more plausible origin. I have a hard time accepting that Batman as he has been written would take in a kid, let alone train him as an apprentice. A former gang member though, rehabilitated, is something I could see happening though.
That's an interesting thought. I have two objections:
1) Why would Batman trust an ex-gang member with his secret?
2) How is this character inspired by Robin, beyond being younger than Batman and male?
Now that Batman's a fugitive, it's dangerous to even meet with Gordon, let alone adopt, train and put an orphan in the line of fire. I don't think we'll see Nolan's version of Robin, especially now.
Except if he jumps a few years ahead (or plays a trick like that) in BB3. Then we can talk about it.
I think people who love these characters will talk about it regardless of how 'soon' its coming. Also... what's the danger, specifically with adopt and training such a kid? And what happens if that's the safest place for the kid at the time? Wouldn't that make it the right thing to do then?
Why would he need all those years to train? If he is limited to supporting Batman from behind/above at first, then he needs a year at most. After more years of training he will be ready to engage the enemies.
Well, let's imagine we have a 12 year old Dick Grayson, on par with the greatest acrobats in the world in skill. His parents die and, lets say, everyone in Gotham is out to kill him, and the safest place to hide is the Batcave. If he goes out, that night, he will have the following issues:
- He will not be familiar, at all, with suitable stealth techniques
- He will not be familiar, at all, with grappling and rappelling equipment
- He will not have a suit his size to protect him or anchor him for grapeling, neither will any of Bruce's contacts make armor for a child, and then again in 6-8 months when he outgrows it.
- He will not be acutely familiar with Gotham's landscape and layout
- He will not intuitively discern the best paths to go unseen
- He will not have a rational trained fight/flight reaction in the face of obstacles
- He will not know how to avoid gunfire
- He will not know how to avoid all forms of electronic security
- He will not know how to apply any of Batman's helpful technology
- He will not know, intuitively how Batman operates, and be constantly asking questions, or worse, not
- He will have no idea how he fits into the scheme of things, and will thus make conflicting decisions about what to do next
- I could go on... but he just doesn't know.
- He will not be of an age or experience level where a request to go out and risk his life can be viewed as credible by a rational person.
- He will not be of an age or skill level where taking him out to risk his life can be viewed as responsible by a rational person.
- He will not reach the standard of excellence that Bruce Wayne demands from everything and everyone.
- He will not be, by any means, emotionally stable, and thus, not dependable.
Batman does and knows a lot, and to believe that anyone can do this, even with years of Special Ops and Ninja training as a world traveler is PUSHING it. To say that a child can do any of it inside a year is just plain ridiculous. Hit Girl was ridiculous... but the whole movie was, so it made sense, it was fun and cool and we suspended our disbelief.
Nolan's Batman leaves little room for suspension of disbelief. There's no room for someone to have their Fridge Logic moment and say 'wait a minute... how'd he learn to do all that so fast.'
So when you take a kid, having world-class acrobatic ability is the only way it even seems remotely possible for this guy to do what Batman does before he's 30. At the very least, just to go out and 'shadow' Batman, he needs to have some sort of insurance that, say, if the GCPD descends upon them that Robin could retreat undetected and safely.
Robin would have to master:
- Stealth, including multiple arts of ninjitsu. Since Robin has no combat skills, this would take him significantly longer, even though the physical aspects off it would come naturally the mental aspects represent a paradigm shift in Dick's mind from a showy performer to a silent killer.
- Rappelling and Grappling and general mountain climbing practices. What Batman does is the equivalent of an Expert or Master climb. If the kid can't do that (and few people can) safely and quickly, he can't go out.
- Black Ops. He'd have to know all the electronic systems that he needs to avoid, on rooftops, on walls, in rooms, on doors, in the air, on street corners. He'd need to know how to break them down, set them up, diffuse and redirect them.
- Batman's method of operation. He'd have to be able to go into the field without asking questions. When things go wrong, Robin would just have to act from the plan. As you'll notice, in Batman's line of work, there is no time for lessons and take-aways as there are in comics.
I figure that takes 2-3 years, especially if Bruce has not decided to usurp the man's life, which brings me to my next point. Bruce is not going to see a need for a partner. He has non-costumed resources, but he really doesn't trust many people. Even if Robin is forced upon him in a way, a protege of Bruce, an acknowledgment of the future, would be an acknowledgment of his mortality. I can see TDK Bruce training a replacement for the future, perhaps one that does go off the handle and end up lending a hand at a crucial moment, or gets used as a gopher/messenger/eyes on the ground, but I just can't see Bruce training a partner.