Official JLA discussion thread - Part 2

[Mrs. Sawyer]

It all makes sense when you think about, and they were dating in pre-crisis time. Them being together looks much better than Kate and Renee, or Bruce and Selina.

Batman and Batwoman should always be together.

 

[Tron Bonne]

That's a pretty horrible idea on all fronts, really.

 

[twylight]

I think Batwoman should turn straight and start dating Bruce Wayne. That would be the perfect DC relationship.

"ohmygawd. You punched the lesbian out of her. HE PUNCHED THE LESBIAN OUT OF HER!" /youngneil

Seriously the first thing in my brain.

Parker, you are incorrigible.

 

[Mrs. Sawyer]

One punch!

Kate + Bruce

 

[SuperFerret]

"ohmygawd. You punched the lesbian out of her. HE PUNCHED THE LESBIAN OUT OF HER!" /youngneil

He punched the lesbian out of her, with his penis.

 

[Supergirl]

He punched the lesbian out of her, with his penis.

[Shortpacked]For a nickel.[/Shortpacked]

 

[The Batman]

[YT]lITBGjNEp08[/YT]

 

[The Batman]

It all makes sense when you think about, and they were dating in pre-crisis time. Them being together looks much better than Kate and Renee, or Bruce and Selina.

Batman and Batwoman should always be together.

I know (or think) you're probably taking this piss, but kate kane and kathy kane are two seperate characters.

 

[Mystirious]

I think Batwoman should turn straight and start dating Bruce Wayne. That would be the perfect DC relationship.

NO

Just no. That would be disgusting

I would boycott DC and get as many people as I could to also boycott DC if they ever made Kate Kane straight

The thought of her just kissing a man makes me want to throw up

Also you can't 'turn' someone straight and no normal lgbt person would ever want to be straight

That's a pretty horrible idea on all fronts, really.

Yep horrible and repulsive

I'm glad DC aren't bigoted or moronic enough to ever make Kate Kane straight. Because I would never buy a single DC product ever again if they did make her heterosexual

 

[Mystirious]

It all makes sense when you think about, and they were dating in pre-crisis time. Them being together looks much better than Kate and Renee, or Bruce and Selina.

Batman and Batwoman should always be together.

No they shouldn't

Batwoman is a lesbian. She's not going to waste her time dating Batman or any male. And if she ever did I would stop buying anything from DC as it would be horrible and bigoted to make ANY gay character straight.

I love Batwoman because she's a great lgbt character. I never want to see her in a heterosexual relationship

Also Kate/Renee and Kate/Maggie Sawyer are both better pairings than Kate with ANY male .

And

 

[Supergirl]

NO

Just no. That would be disgusting

I would boycott DC and get as many people as I could to also boycott DC if they ever made Kate Kane straight

The thought of her just kissing a man makes me want to throw up

Also you can't 'turn' someone straight and no normal lgbt person would ever want to be straight



Yep horrible and repulsive

I'm glad DC aren't bigoted or moronic enough to ever make Kate Kane straight. Because I would never buy a single DC product ever again if they did make her heterosexual

Actually many T people are straight. Gender and sexuality don't go hand in hand. A lot of transwomen are only interested in men, and a lot of transmen are only interested in women.

 

[Mystirious]

He punched the lesbian out of her, with his penis.

If Batman ever tried Kate would break every bone in his body. With her bare hands

And I would while I watched her do it

No normal gay person would ever want to be straight 'Ferret. Kate isn't going to waste her time with Batman

Especially when she's got Maggie Sawyer who is a million times hotter than Batman

 

[Drz]

Clearly it's bigoted for a homosexual to turn straight, but turning straight characters to gay is okay!

Ah hypocrisy.

 

[Mystirious]

Actually many T people are straight. Gender and sexuality don't go hand in hand. A lot of transwomen are only interested in men, and a lot of transmen are only interested in women.

Good point Supergirl and apologies to any straight transgender posters who may be posting here

I should have said no lesbian, gay or bisexual person would ever want to be straight. Of course many Transgender people are straight

Sorry for the poor choice of words. I definitely didnt mean to imply that transgender people who are straight arent 'normal'

 

[Mystirious]

Clearly it's bigoted for a homosexual to turn straight, but turning straight characters to gay is okay!

Ah hypocrisy.

Nope turning straight characters gay would be just as bad. It would perpetuate the evil lie that its possible to change someone's sexuality

I don't want any straight characters 'turned' gay

There are some I'd dig to see revealed as bisexual. But that is not really the same thing I think

I would never want any character with a history of heterosexual relationships turned gay just as I never ever want to see any gay characters turned straight

Both would be terrible

Stealing four tens of cake terrible

 

[Drz]

Nope turning straight characters gay would be just as bad. It would perpetuate the evil lie that its possible to change someone's sexuality

I don't want any straight characters 'turned' gay

So now you agree with Rob Liefeld? Interesting twist.

 

[Mystirious]

What be you talking about I dont agree with Rob Lifield

I would go drown myself if I ever agreed with him about anything

Peter David didn't make Shatterstar gay he revealed he was bisexual. And I love that he did and I love that he had Rictor and Shatterstar get together. I adore that couple with so much love

 

[Mrs. Sawyer]

Batman + Batwoman over all

 

[Colossal Spoons]

Nope turning straight characters gay would be just as bad. It would perpetuate the evil lie that its possible to change someone's sexuality

I don't want any straight characters 'turned' gay

There are some I'd dig to see revealed as bisexual. But that is not really the same thing I think

I would never want any character with a history of heterosexual relationships turned gay just as I never ever want to see any gay characters turned straight

Both would be terrible

Stealing four tens of cake terrible

Well at least you feel the same way in both situations

 

[Drz]

What be you talking about I dont agree with Rob Lifield

I would go drown myself if I ever agreed with him about anything

Peter David didn't make Shatterstar gay he revealed he was bisexual. And I love that he did and I love that he had Rictor and Shatterstar get together. I adore that couple with so much love

So it's okay to make Batwoman into bisexual and have her date Bruce Wayne? Okay.

 

[twylight]

Wow SF... way to make it way more gross than I intened it to be.

So it's okay to make Batwoman into bisexual and have her date Bruce Wayne? Okay.

Honestly, I don't see Kathy being with a guy, but I don't see why gay character can't 'turn' bi. It's not like it's downgrading.

 

[Scarecrow_King]

So it's okay to make Batwoman into bisexual and have her date Bruce Wayne? Okay.

thank you for this post.

 

[Mrs. Sawyer]

Nope turning straight characters gay would be just as bad. It would perpetuate the evil lie that its possible to change someone's sexuality

I don't want any straight characters 'turned' gay

There are some I'd dig to see revealed as bisexual. But that is not really the same thing I think

I would never want any character with a history of heterosexual relationships turned gay just as I never ever want to see any gay characters turned straight

Both would be terrible

Stealing four tens of cake terrible

Okay, I'm gonna stop my ridiculous trolling of Mysterious (yes, Batman/Batwoman is very ridiculous) for a second here and get serious.

First of all, I'm gonna say much on the subject since this isn't the right thread, but evil lie? You can have an opinion but that's opinion is harsh and wrong. What are bisexuals? So a gay guy can't fall in love with a girl? If he does, he's bisexual, meaning that this "evil lie" is a notion that doesn't even exist.

Next, I think Drz said it best. Changing straight characters into bisexual is bad too. Not as bad as turning them gay just for the hell of it, but still bad.

And now, back to what the original point of all this debate was about. Barbara and Dinah are straight. Screw interpretation. With interpretation, pre-crisis Batman would have been gay for Robin among other things. Don't get me wrong, it would be very hot haha, but it would not make sense. Until I see them actually liplocking in a DCU comic, they're straight. So take your fan-fiction and shipping and keep on dreaming.

 

[Scarecrow_King]

Okay, I'm gonna stop my ridiculous trolling of Mysterious (yes, Batman/Batwoman is very ridiculous) for a second here and get serious.

First of all, I'm gonna say much on the subject since this isn't the right thread, but evil lie? You can have an opinion but that's opinion is harsh and wrong. What are bisexuals? So a gay guy can't fall in love with a girl? If he does, he's bisexual, meaning that this "evil lie" is a notion that doesn't even exist.

Next, I think Drz said it best. Changing straight characters into bisexual is bad too. Not as bad as turning them gay just for the hell of it, but still bad.

And now, back to what the original point of all this debate was about. Barbara and Dinah are straight. Screw interpretation. With interpretation, pre-crisis Batman would have been gay for Robin among other things. Don't get me wrong, it would be very hot haha, but it would not make sense. Until I see them actually liplocking in a DCU comic, they're straight. So take your fan-fiction and shipping and keep dreaming.

I love you.

 

[Mrs. Sawyer]

I'm loved. t: