BEST STORYLINE - GORDON AND THE GCPD TAKE ON GOTHAM (Byrd Man)
My biggest regret about dropping Two-Face at the beginning of this season is that I don't get to take part in this masterful, ambitious epic that Byrd has been crafting. But not only has Byrd handled Two-Face very well in my absence, but he's brought life to all levels of his organisation, right through to looking at its corrupting influence on city hall. And on the other side, he's brought to life a varied ensemble of detectives working for the Major Crimes Unit. In 1U, Byrd Man IS Gotham City. But remaining at the centre of it all is Byrd's flawless portrayal of Gordon, making him a figure strong enough to be the figurehead of this sprawling saga. Seeing the sheer scope of this multi-layered narrative, watching all the pieces gradually come together, has been a big inspiration on what I'm trying to start doing with Iron Man now, but I think the best I can hope for is a pale imitation. This reads like a master storyteller at work.
BEST HERO - SPIDER-MAN (Carnage27)
What, there are people playing in this game not called Byrd Man or wiegeabo!? While our very own Dynamic Duo have proven themselves to be a dominant force in this RPG, this season has really seen Carnage rise to the occasion as the dependable Third Man. His Joker made for a highly entertaining foil for Batman and Gordon, but the real highlight for Carnage this season has been his stellar work on Spider-Man. He's really captured the knack for bringing to life Peter Parker's everyman qualities, skillfully putting him in the position of POV character for us readers in scenes like the recent Stamford disaster. I remember back when Carnage27 first joined the games, so it's nice to see how far he's come where he can more than hold his own against the more experienced RPers. Great work!
BEST VILLAIN - LEX LUTHOR (Karem-Knight)
Curse you, Byrd! You stole my "Lex Luthor is an evil Obama" line! Rather than repeating Byrd (even though he was repeating me, grrrr....) I'll go a different route. Karem-Knight, we go back a long way in these games. You joined way back in late 2004, in the first season of the original Marvel RPG. And since then, I've watched you progress, watched you grow as a writer. And now, with Lex Luthor, I think you're doing your best writing ever. Playing the President of the United States for a season could easily have been a dull, thankless duty, simply lumbering along from one piece of plot-advancing exposition to the next, but you've attacked the role with relish. Your Luthor just has this squirming, phoney "niceness" that makes you want to punch him, it's wonderfully nuanced stuff. It's just a great villain. And I don't mean that in a "You get the award because we're thin on villains this season" way either. I'd put your Luthor up against any villain we've ever had in One Universe, including my own take on Luthor in Season 1, and would say you compare most favorably. I'm proud of how far you've come since the "glinder" days.
BEST DEVELOPED CHARACTER - BATMAN (wiegeabo)
I've had people praise my work before and say "Oh wow, Keyser, I love how you progressed a character arc over a whole season, impressive!" No, what's impressive is the work Wiegeabo has done on Batman, not just over the course of a season, but since near the beginning of the game, I believe since the end of the first season. You look at where he picked the character up from MaskedManJRK, and look at where he is now, and you can see a through line, a steady building and developing of the character's arc. The recent scene where Bruce revealed to Elektra that he is Batman had so much more impact because of the amount of time - spanning multiple seasons - wiegeabo has spent building the groundwork of the Bruce/Ellektra relationship. It's just remarkable patience, and it's paid off with a rounded, multi-dimensional take on the Dark Knight that, amidst a collection of great Batmen in our RPGs, could very well stand as the best interpretation of Batman ever in these games.
BEST FIGHT - JUSTICE LEAGUE VS AMAZO
I'm going to have to agree with Byrd on this one. This was a whole lot of fun to take part in, with the united heroes still having to fight against the odds battling a foe who outmatched all of them. And then you had that kicker of an ending that took the emotional impact of the fight to a whole other level. A prime example of the fun that can he had with collaborative RPing.
BEST POST - RHODEY'S DESPAIR (Optikal)
Out of everything I've done so far this season, I'd say the highlight for me was the scene between Tony Stark and James Rhodes in the hospital, shortly after Rhodes has been left a crippled amputee in a plane crash. I love RPing with Optikal, I feel that better than anyone he can really bring out the best in me as a writer. So I really felt the back-and-forth dynamics clicking so naturally with every post of this scene, until we culminated with this thing of beauty. It's just so powerful, filled with raw and genuine emotion, it's almost hard to read. I found it to be a really moving piece, and testament to Optikal's remarkable writing prowess. I wish he'd post more, because with this scene - and this post in particular - he not only showed that he is crafting an excellent, damn near definitive take on War Machine, but that in general he is a great writer whose posts are always worth reading.
Rhodey listened with his eyes closed, the words reverberating through what was left of him. Losing the limbs and being crippled weren't the only things at work in his mind. He felt like he'd lost part of his soul along with the parts of his physical body.
Before the accident, he'd had everything he'd ever wanted in life. Great friends, his dream career... respect and recognition. He'd overcome the obstacles of his meagre beginnings and actually made something of his life.
Now though, he lay there surrounded by medical equipment with the sterile clinic stench of the medical facility invading his lungs. He'd lost it all. He'd never fly again. He'd never run or drive again. He'd never get to stand with his best friend as one of them tied the knot. He'd never be able to prop Tony up and carry his drunken ass home again.
Rhodes was broken. Physically. Mentally. Emotionally.
He opened his one good eye to reveal the tears there. They fell easily, streaking down his stubble lined cheek to the corner of his mouth. He looked at his his friend with that one good tear stained eye. "I'm sorry Tony," He said, his face tightening against the floods of emotion coursing through him. "I'm sorry that I can't be more appreciative. I'm sorry that I can't hug you and tell you how much I love you... as a friend and as a brother. I'm sorry you wasted your journey down here to see what's left of me.
"You've always been there Tony. Always. You're a womanizing, self serving, arrogant drunk with an ego the size of Manhattan, but you've got everything. Yeah, I'm alive, but for what? I'll never have kids or a wife like a normal man. I'll never be able to serve my country. Hell, there's not even enough of me left to work as one of your lackeys! I'm a living corpse for christ sake!"
The room suddenly seemed very empty and the electronic beeping of his life support systems seemed very loud.
"I'm sorry Tony but there's nothing left to fight for."
Rhodes voice broke, a small quake in his usually solid persona.
"Nothing." He managed to whisper.
Rhodes held his stare for a moment or two, the tears flowing freely, his bottom lip trembling hard. He tried to fight it all back but all he could was turn his head away from the closest thing he had to a brother.
MVP - BYRD MAN
You want to know why I'm nominating Byrd Man for this award? Just click on the post-count for the IC thread. Byrd has the most posts in the game by a substantial margin. I like to think I post at least semi-regularly, but as of writing this he has me beat by exactly 50 posts. From crafting his aformentioned epic Gotham saga, to helping keep the Justice League alive and kicking on multiple fronts by playing both Captain America AND Superman, Byrd is the true workhorse of this game. What's more impressive is how many of those 148 (and counting) posts are excellent. Three very different characters, but he nails them all, while still making each distinct and having each serve a distinct role in the overall story of the season. Once again, Byrd proves to be an incredible asset to the RPGs, and pretty much the textbook definition of an MVP.