Mr. Socko said:...No, nothing is worse then a recast...
Mr. Vice said:No, this new batman franchise needs continuity, unlike the old franchise
El Payaso said:This franchise needs good actors. Holmes is the exception to that so far.
Super_Ludacris said:she still did a good job.
So good that she's being a spastic about returning and has half of the Bat-fans all over her case. What would happen if she did an excellent job, get lynched in the street?Super_Ludacris said:she still did a good job.
Super_Ludacris said:That sentence made no sense.
Flame on! said:So good that she's being a spastic about returning and has half of the Bat-fans all over her case. What would happen if she did an excellent job, get lynched in the street?
Fair.Super_Ludacris said:Well fanboys in general over-react and are fickle we know this despite being fans of the movie and the character ourselves at least we can seperate ourselves from the general comic book convention hysteria.
And Holmes' uncertainty is a reflection of the circus that is TomKat, however I would imagine getting pregnant etc would put plans such as filming on the backburner. With that said, the movie is still in it's eary stages. Like we arent even in pre-production (barely so if we are) and the script is even finished (or started?). So any speculation or uncertainy of who is returning other than the definites is moot.
I'm just saying she did a ok job and people are just judging off of the stigma of Tomkat. I dont want that ****ing circus either but who knows how things will change come 2008. Maybe she will return to normalcy, maybe she will quit acting all together, it's all in hindsight *shrugs*
Fair assesment?
El Payaso said:Bringing Katie back makes even less sense.
Two Face said:I hated where she slaped Bruce TWICE! once was enough.
I hate recasts but if Katie Holmes not returning to the role, I suggest Jennifer connelly or just write off Rachel character since she wasn't needed in the first place.
explode7 said:I'm not gonna even watch the poll results because I bet most of you nearly all have said yes since the truth is Katie suckes as Rachael.