Silent Hill, while not amazing, is easilly the best video game movie made yet. One thing that really helps it is that the monster/visual designs are fantastic. It's a credit not only to the those responsible for the monsters, but also to how incredible the design work of Silent Hill is in the first place.
I think that one of the movies saving graces was how well done the visual effects were, how perfectly they replicated the art of the Silent Hill games in terms of "Hell" and the creatures.
The movies weakness though, is the script and the actors. Both could have been improved. Hopefully the movie does well enough that the studio makes a sequel (with probably having 5-10 million shaved off the budget because it's probably only going to do a little bit better than break even
).
My sibling saw the movie, she's a Silent Hill fan as I am, but she didn't like it and said it was "the most R-rated movie she's ever seen" yet she had no problem with Sin City or the violence in that. I've come across a few people who have said that the movie was "Too gory and disturbing", but honestly, I find horrible acts of violence much easier to swallow in the context of it being demons and dark gods and extremist religion than I do with something like Sin City. In Sin City, the violence is there without a shred of real justification, and these are 'normal' people, to me that's a lot more objectionable than something that's brought about due to hell and ocultists.
Those Nurses were pretty hot...
So Anyway Silent Hill is falling fast...
I'm not holding my breath about it making 10 million over the next weekend (which would bea 50% drop) I really hope is shows some legs and manages to surpass the production/advertising cost of 50 million so we can get our Silent Hill 2 with James.
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?page=daily&id=silenthill.htm
Of course DVD sales will help them out a lot... It might be a bit early to judge, but it dropped significantly from friday to sunday and some people are crazy so it seems the movie has bad word of mouth, plus there were like 10 people in the theater when I went to see it on monday for the 10 showing.