SV S5 complete episode fan rankings

AgentPat

Squeaky wheel
Joined
Apr 16, 2004
Messages
15,238
Reaction score
0
Points
31
I was going to bump this thread, but I think it will be better to start fresh now that the season has ended. People's opinions have probably changed since that last thread was created.

You guys (and gals) know the drill. Use whatever criteria you want to rank the episodes, but rank 'em top to bottom, most favored to least favored. I'll tally the responses after a few days so everybody can see what SHH posters prefer. But remember, ranking on a 1-10 bases doesn't work. I need to see ALL episodes in ORDER of preference. Telling me you think Episode X was a 5 out of 5 when two or more other episodes share that same ranking will disqualify your list from being included in the tally. Also, please make sure you list ALL 22 episodes. The math won't work if you miss an ep.

Aight... here they are, in broadcast order:

01 Arrival (FOS; alien Ken and Barbie; Brainiac intro)
02 Mortal (Wonder twins; Clark and Lana consummate)
03 Hidden (Gabriel programs ICBM to destroy Smallville; Clark dies and gets his powers back)
04 Aqua (Aquaman; Fine is formally introduced)
05 Thirst (Vampire ep)
06 Exposed (Tom Wopat and Dukes of Hazard reunion; Lois striptease)
07 Splinter (Fine's silver Kryptonite cause Clark to be paranoid)
08 Solitude (Fine tries to get Clark to destroy the Fortress in order to release Zod)
09 Lexmas (Holiday ep - Lex is shown what could have been with kids and a marriage to Lana; Clark plays Santa)
10 Fanatic (Jonathan's campaign heats up; Lex has a fan)
11 Lockdown (Deputy who survived alien Ken and Barbie's slaughter in Arrival want to make the spaceship public knowledge)
12 Reckoning (100th episode - Clark proposes to Lana; she accepts; she dies; Clark reverses time (!); then Jonathan dies)
13 Vengeance (Andrea is the Angel of Vengeance, a mild mannered employee of the Daily Planet by day, and a costumed vigilante at night)
14 Tomb (serial killer sets his sights on Chloe and Lois after one of his victims is discovered behind a wall in the Talon)
15 Cyborg (Teen Titan Victor Stone is Cyborg, the six billion dollar man)
16 Hypnotic (FOTS Simone and her magical amulet; Clark breaks up with Lana)
17 Void (Flatliners homage ep; Lana, Lex and Clark communicate with deceased family)
18 Fragile (Welling directorial debut featuring girl who breaks glass)
19 Mercy (Saw homage ep, featuring Martha and Lionel)
20 Fade (Contract killer Graham seeks to repay Clark for saving his life - by killing Lex)
21 Oracle (Fine infects Lex with the virus serum; Lionel reveals he is the Oracle for Clark)
22 Vessel (Fine releases a world-wide computer virus; Zod possesses Lex; Clark is imprisoned in the Phantom Zone)

Now, rearrange the list to your preference. I'll do the rest. :)

Here's my list to start the thread...

01 Hidden
02 Mortal
03 Arrival
04 Splinter
05 Reckoning
06 Vessel
07 Oracle
08 Solitude
09 Mercy
10 Vengeance
11 Cyborg
12 Fragile
13 Aqua
14 Fade
15 Hypnotic
16 Void
17 Lexmas
18 Thirst
19 Exposed
20 Lockdown
21 Fanatic
22 Tomb


Gosh, that was a tough call with some episodes. Next?
 
  1. Hidden
  2. Splinter
  3. Mortal
  4. Mercy
  5. Cyborg
  6. Vessel
  7. Vengeance
  8. Reckoning
  9. Arrival
  10. Oracle
  11. Solitude
  12. Lexmas
  13. Fragile
  14. Void
  15. Fade
  16. Thirst
  17. Lockdown
  18. Fanatic
  19. Exposed
  20. Aqua
  21. Hypnotic
  22. Tomb
 
My list has changed some from the other thread...

01. Solitude
02. Arrival
03. Reckoning
04. Oracle
05. Vessel
06. Splinter
07. Cyborg
08. Hidden
09. Lexmas
10. Exposed
11. Aqua
12. Mortal
13. Fade
14. Lockdown
15. Fanatic
16. Vengeance
17. Mercy
18. Fragile
19. Void
20. Hypnotic
21. Thirst
22. Tomb
 
1. Hidden
2. Arrival
3. Splinter
4. Cyborg
5. Reckoning
6. Vessel
7. Oracle
8. Solitude
9. Mortal
10. Vengeance
11. Mercy
12. Thirst
13. Fade
14. Fragile
15. Hypnotic
16. Void
17. Aqua
18. Lockdown
19. Fanatic
20. Lexmas
21. Exposed
22. Tomb
 
The Good

01) Oracle
02) Solitude
03) Cyborg
04) Hidden
05) Vessel

The Okay

06) Mercy
07) Arrival

The 'Meh'

08) Lockdown
09) Reckoning
10) Lexmas
11) Aqua
12) Fade
13) Mortal
14) Splinter
15) Exposed

The Bad

16) Fanatic
17) Vengeance

The Ugly

18) Fragile
19) Thirst
20) Void
21) Hypnotic
22) Tomb
 
Hmm I would replace Cyborg with Lexmas. I consider that to be one of the year's better eps (Lexmas).
 
My problem with Lexmas was the whole ghost element....eh, belongs on Supernatual.

Santa existing in the SV universe was pretty messed up too.
 
1. Solitude

2. Oracle

3. Exposed

4. Splinter

5. Cyborg

6. Mercy

7. Aqua

8. Hidden

9. Arrival

10. Lexmas

11. Vengeance

12. Fade

13. Lockdown

14. Fanatic

15. Mortal

16. Fragile

17. Reckoning

18. Void

19. Tomb

20. Hypnotic

21. Vessel

22. Thirst
 
Kane said:
My problem with Lexmas was the whole ghost element....eh, belongs on Supernatual.

Santa existing in the SV universe was pretty messed up too.

It certainly deserves to be in your ok category though at least :o
 
1. Hidden
2. Oracle
3. Splinter
4. Reckoning
5. Mortal
6. Vessel
7. Mercy
8. Arrival
9. Solitude
10. Cyborg
11. Vengeance
12. Fragile
13. Lexmas
14. Thirst
15. Void
16. Hypnotic
17. Fade
18. Tomb
19. Exposed
20. Fanatic
21. Lockdown
22. Aqua
 
\S/JcDc\S/ said:
It certainly deserves to be in your ok category though at least :o

Okay would be episodes I cared about. 'Meh' are episodes I saw nothing special about.

Lex supposed to turn to the darkside all because of a dream? Just didnt seem right....funny thing is he didnt even actually turn to the darkside right after it. It took Brainiac and Zod to get it out of him.
 
Solitude
Reckoning
Arrival
Splinter
Mortal
Mercy
Cyborg
Vessel
Hidden
Oracle
Vengeance
Lexmas
Void
Exposed
Fragile
Lockdown
Fanatic
Thirst
Fade
Hypnotic
Tomb
Aqua
 
All-Time Favorites

01 Reckoning
02 Mercy
03 Hidden
04 Arrival

Great Episodes

05 Cyborg
06 Fanatic
07 Exposed
08 Lockdown
09 Oracle
10 Mortal
11 Splinter
12 Solitude
13 Void


Good Episodes

14 Lexmas
15 Vessel
16 Tomb
17 Fragile
18 Aqua


Okay Episodes

19 Thirst
20 Hypnotic
21 Vengeance
22 Fade
 
1. 522 - Vessel
2. 503 - Hidden
3. 501 - Arrival
4. 512 - Reckoning
5. 521 - Oracle
6. 508 - Solitude
7. 519 - Mercy
8. 518 - Fragile
9. 515 - Cyborg
10. 509 - Lexmas
11. 513 - Vengeance
12. 507 - Splinter
13. 502 - Mortal
14. 504 - Aqua
15. 517 - Void
16. 510 - Fanatic
17. 516 - Hypnotic
18. 511 - Lockdown
19. 520 - Fade
20. 506 - Exposed
21. 505 - Thirst
22. 514 - Tomb
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"