TalismanRing
Cyclone Cookie Tosser
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2014
- Messages
- 5,095
- Reaction score
- 17
- Points
- 58
Has anybody seen this "leaked footage"?: https://vine.co/v/M0PKr0ABxhF
Ultron doing that Pinocchio dance is impressive.
Has anybody seen this "leaked footage"?: https://vine.co/v/M0PKr0ABxhF
Has anybody seen this "leaked footage"?: https://vine.co/v/M0PKr0ABxhF
I think that A1 scene is open to interpretation, personally - I never took it as him being worried or afraid he couldn't pick up Mjolnir. I took it as him taking a moment and realizing that his brother - who he has just witnessed brutally killing someone he considered an ally (if not a friend) - may be beyond any help and him realizing just what he might have to end up doing to stop Loki's madness. I took it as him steeling himself for what lies ahead. I didn't really take it as a 'worthiness' moment.2) Turning the hammer into a game is exactly what would make someone unworthy of wielding it. It's not enough to be worthy once or just for a bit of time, the user has to consistently be worthy or they lose it. There's a scene in A1 after Thor's fight with Hulk/the Avengers where he hesitates to pick it up. As if he reflected on his previous actions and was afraid he wouldn't be able to pick up Mjolnir again.
Has anybody seen this "leaked footage"?: https://vine.co/v/M0PKr0ABxhF
I think that A1 scene is open to interpretation, personally - I never took it as him being worried or afraid he couldn't pick up Mjolnir. I took it as him taking a moment and realizing that his brother - who he has just witnessed brutally killing someone he considered an ally (if not a friend) - may be beyond any help and him realizing just what he might have to end up doing to stop Loki's madness. I took it as him steeling himself for what lies ahead. I didn't really take it as a 'worthiness' moment.
Just my opinion though
I think that because Thor is Conscience, Mjolnir wouldn't relinquish it's self to Steve.I think that A1 scene is open to interpretation, personally - I never took it as him being worried or afraid he couldn't pick up Mjolnir. I took it as him taking a moment and realizing that his brother - who he has just witnessed brutally killing someone he considered an ally (if not a friend) - may be beyond any help and him realizing just what he might have to end up doing to stop Loki's madness. I took it as him steeling himself for what lies ahead. I didn't really take it as a 'worthiness' moment.
Just my opinion though
Generally I'd agree with you in most cases, but you're assuming everyone would just buy Ultron being a sentient being. One could easily argue the fault falls on the engineer for not programming the properly and/or taking all factors into account thus carelessly creating a loophole.
I don't know why people think Claudia Kim is playing someone significant. Her name has come up as soon as Joss said four female characters will have major roles, forgetting that Hayley Atwell is in the movie.
If it's revealed that she's anything but a minor irrelevant character, it would be cool to see.
I completely agree that Cap lifting Mjolnir should be saved for the right time, however in that case I don't think he should have even tried during the party scene since there is no logical reason why he wouldn't be worthy.
I think this scene also addresses the question about why only Thor can lift Mjolnir - it must be something more than just worthiness because, on occasion, Thor can be a bit of an idiot at times.
At the very least, Steve seems to tick the 'worthiness box' more than Thor does.
2) Turning the hammer into a game is exactly what would make someone unworthy of wielding it. It's not enough to be worthy once or just for a bit of time, the user has to consistently be worthy or they lose it.
Youll note that Joss didnt work on this project for 8 years then bail. He worked on the script for like 2 years, FINISHED IT, ACTUALLY MADE THE MOVIE AND DELIVERED. Hes the MAN. Mother****in *MIC DROP*
Noone bailed? LOL. OK. Denial isnt just a river in Egypt.
There's no debate. Thor had to sacrifice his life to be worthy. Steve was willing to, but he didn't, so he's not quite worthy... but he's real close, cuz he's a really really really good dude. Tony was also willing to sacrifice his life, even had his heart stop, but he's not a really really good dude, so he's not even close.
That's not what Odin said. All we know about Odin's definition of worthiness is that you have to sacrifice your life. That was the only thing that made Thor worthy. Any other brand or kind of selflessness, character, willingness to die, etc is all our own definitions of worthiness, that may or may not have anything to do with Mjolnir.
That blooper reel made me actually like the show more. I like the actors better than the characters, lol.
YEAH I have about 15 SDCC vids I had to watch, then finish watching Season 2 of Arrow, I get ya lolI still need to watch that AOS blooper reel, Ive been watching so much other stuff and keep forgetting.
They said he didnt bail? So hes still directing the movie? OK didnt know this. I apologize
Yes, there is debate, apparently
I don't get what your hang up is on this dying thing.
IF that is in fact Odin's ONLY ACCEPTIBLE condition for being "Worthy", it still wouldn't change the fact that Steve DID sacrifice himself, meaning there is no discernible difference between what he did and what Thor did, therefore, there is no difference in their level of worthiness. Just because steve didn't actually die, it doesn't change his level of heroics, selflessness, and self sacrifice. Are you gunna tell me that a soldier (IRL) who jumps on a grenade, but is lucky enough to have it be a dud, that he's not a hero?? That he is not completely self-sacrificing for the good of others??? That he is any less a hero than, say, a general who had killed thousands, but learned humility and died saving his platoon??? Because that's what it boils down to.
In this situation, intention is EVERYTHING.
It has nothing to do with whether the sacrifice led to the person actually dying.
Stop it.
Now.