The Catwoman/Selina Kyle Casting Thread - Part 2

[Willi Berg]

lol I mean Thomas is genuinely fine and has sources, I don't see him calling people out and shame them etc, but this game you get real and fake denials and either way denials means you'll get killed online, and you've got to take it on the chin or apologize for making s*** up for any reason.

If not then you'll just look like a baby. His buddies though however, loves to bash Mario and argue with El Maybe, so will be fun watching them go psycho and act righteous haha

Yes It's always fun to watch the madness of the "scoop game".

 

[Marvel united]

Janelle Monae

 

[ArmsHeldOut]

Can’t speak to Logan Browning’s talent, but it looks like I’m alone in thinking that she looks young as hell. I honestly can’t believe she’s 30. I dunno, to me, she looks more like a Batgirl than a Catwoman.

She reminds me a little of the actress who plays Barry and Iris's daughter on The Flash.

 

[ArmsHeldOut]

lol I mean Thomas is genuinely fine and has sources, I don't see him calling people out and shame them etc, but this game you get real and fake denials and either way denials means you'll get killed online, and you've got to take it on the chin or apologize for making s*** up for any reason.

If not then you'll just look like a baby. His buddies though however, loves to bash Mario and argue with El Maybe, so will be fun watching them go psycho and act righteous haha

We've been through so many of these buggers over the years. Remember "The Grey" and "Shoeless Joe?"

 

[Greenlite]

What a d***

 

[Greenlite]

We've been through so many of these buggers over the years. Remember "The Grey" and "Shoeless Joe?"

I missed out on The Grey, was he Liam Neesom in disguise?

Shoeless Joe, lol, Jett's source haha. I thought he got some exclusive pics etc, or did he get it from reddit or something?

I remember Zryson, I wasn't a member then, haha

And there was one guy pretending to be at SDCC broadcasting live in 2014, all the BvS stuff, lol "batman on the rooftop!!" NextNolan was it?

 

[Sawyer]

Ahh the joys of being extremely online...

 

[Black Narcissus]

Welp. This means she ain't even on the damn radar. I'm kinda bummed about this tho, she is a great talent and sexy af.

 

[Sawyer]

Welp. This means she ain't even on the damn radar. I'm kinda bummed about this tho, she is a great talent and sexy af.

Excuse me, sir? Sir! This is a family establishment, please keep your pants on.

 

[Black Narcissus]

Excuse me, sir? Sir! This is a family establishment, please keep your pants on.

Nay,

 

[BobJM]

Glad to see that the list has been pretty much debunked. I wouldn’t want MCU actors in Batman (Wright aside). Though Shipp could be good.

Zoe Kravitz has been my pick for a while now, but I think there are some reports that say she’s too busy to take the role.

 

[Marvel united]

 

[ArmsHeldOut]

I missed out on The Grey, was he Liam Neesom in disguise?

Shoeless Joe, lol, Jett's source haha. I thought he got some exclusive pics etc, or did he get it from reddit or something?

I remember Zryson, I wasn't a member then, haha

And there was one guy pretending to be at SDCC broadcasting live in 2014, all the BvS stuff, lol "batman on the rooftop!!" NextNolan was it?

His Twitter handle was/is Gabriel Grey. The VFX guy. I supposed it was just a few of us who called him "The Grey", though. lol

Yeah, Joe was initially Jett's source. He wasn't too bad. The regulars in the BvS thread (when BvS was still a thing) were especially taken with him for whatever reason.

Zyrson was just one of the more memorable trolls on here, no? TNN, similarly, wasn't a scooper; he was just a regular with an overactive imagination and a tendency to tell tall tales.

 

[Greenlite]

His Twitter handle was/is Gabriel Grey. The VFX guy. I supposed it was just a few of us who called him "The Grey", though. lol

Yeah, Joe was initially Jett's source. He wasn't too bad. The regulars in the BvS thread (when BvS was still a thing) were especially taken with him for whatever reason.

Zyrson was just one of the more memorable trolls on here, no? TNN, similarly, wasn't a scooper; he was just a regular with an overactive imagination and a tendency to tell tall tales.

Ohhhh that gabriel guy with funny font on twitter! I saw his stuff often, has disappeared for a while now, totally forgot about him.

I think roach was legit, unfortunately he doesn't post very often esp lately

 

[ArmsHeldOut]

Ohhhh that gabriel guy with funny font on twitter! I saw his stuff often, has disappeared for a while now, totally forgot about him.

I think roach was legit, unfortunately he doesn't post very often esp lately

Yeah, Roach had a great source, but he got hit with a cease and desist order or something to that effect. He still lurks the forums, but his scooping days are pretty much over.

 

[Black Narcissus]

If we going with a Marvel recast, she was wasted in that spidey flick.

 

[Invader Joker]

Yeah, I was about to mention how if WB were to use any Marvel actress for Catwoman, it'd probably be Laura Harrier since her character was so forgettable and Kevin Feige is definitely not going to miss her lol:

 

[Asr]

Laura Harrier is 29?! I thought she was under 18, holy hell. I legit thought we were going to need to call a creeper alert on that one.

 

[Greenlite]

To be fair there are plenty of actresses wasted in MCU, both sides really but prob MCU more.

 

[Greenlite]

Yeah, Roach had a great source, but he got hit with a cease and desist order or something to that effect. He still lurks the forums, but his scooping days are pretty much over.

That’s sad, he is a cool dude

 

[Poppy]

Okay so Polito made this big thread against Umberto to prove that his list was right and a few hours later an actress from that list debunked it herself...lol.

 

[Willi Berg]

Okay so Polito made this big thread against Umberto to prove that his list was right and a few hours later an actress from that list debunked it herself...lol.

The only thing his thread proved was that these "scoopers" get some things right but a lot of things wrong.

 

[Marvel united]

Okay so Polito made this big thread against Umberto to prove that his list was right and a few hours later an actress from that list debunked it herself...lol.

To be fair, the list itself may be less i
Inaccurate and more outdated. It could have just been some names thrown around by execs a month or so ago with no formal offers actually made.

I think that's what was essentially the same case with Polito's "shortlist" for Batman

 

[Willi Berg]

To be fair, the list itself may be less i
Inaccurate and more outdated. It could have just been some names thrown around by execs a month or so ago with no formal offers actually made.

I think that's what was essentially the same case with Polito's "shortlist" for Batman

It could be an old studio wishlist or some names bandied about early on. These scoopers seem to get into trouble when they try to mark something as 'definitive', when a lot looks to be gathered through hearsay between studios, agents, managers, etc.

 

[TheGuy]

Umberto laid a massive smackdown, though. Polito is nuts and trying to divert the issue. Regardless if at some point his shortlist was accurate, he got many of the fandom riled.