It didn't make a killing because it was basically Smallville: The MOVIE.
Only the teen angst was magnified to ridiculous levels with a bunch of unnecessary christ parallels and direct ripoffs from STM.
It's not some big mystery. It's pretty clear that people want something better than the OC in tights. We're not stupid, WB.... We've seen Superman, Lex, and his rogues done miles better than in STM so don't feed us the same lines, and plot points we have seen before and expect a happy audience. It's been a long time and we've already moved on. And i can't believe it takes a dissapointing box office to finally convince these guys to crack open a comic or something. Did they not learn from batman? Or even superman? What is so wrong with doing a modern superman for 2006???
You guys from wb reading this, listen:
Superman doesn't hate his powers.
Superman doesn't feel insecure unless it's about how well he can serve the people who love him.
Superman doesn't ditch Lois.
Superman doesn't leave for 5 or 6 years with his fortress completely ungaurded.
Superman doesn't crush some innocent person's car with a huge globe.
Superman doesn't waste time letting some punk shoot him in the eye or teeth or whatever.
Superman doesn't father a child before ditching lois.
Superman doesn't give luthor a chance to touch him.
Superman doesn't screw with his dog.
Superman doesn't kill, manslaughter or not. The only exception is when he has no other way to defend himself.
Superman doesn't spy on his former girlfriends.
Superman doesn't act like spiderman and bich and moan about how hard life is.
Superman doesn't walk on kryptonite and not feel a thing.
Superman doesn't just hear audio bits from Marlon brando in his head. His earth father was more of an influence on him than jor el.
He's superman, he likes who he is, he chose it, he accepts it. God...
But don't just listen to me, listen to the man himself too:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OxYCvsz6zFA&mode=related&search=