I was hesitating for a long time about posting this as my opinion seems to be totally out of sync with the board's vast majority, but I'm simply curious: Why does (nearly) everybody think that Out of Time was a 10/10 but Rogue Time was only OK?
Because I have the total opposite opinion. Here's why:
Out of Time was certainly an interesting and important episode if for nothing else then for kicking the final story arc leading to the season's climax into gear. However, what really happened in that episode:
1. Well's identity as Eobard got confirmed. But to the viewer only. So far noone else knows. As for the viewers, I think the vast majority suspected this already.
2. They killed Cisco for pure shock value knowing that it will be undone immediately.
3. They had Barry and Iris kiss for pretty much the same reasons.
Apart from that the main villain arc with the Weather Wizard was pretty meh...
On top of that both of the last to points lead to problems. At least for me.
Let's get the Iris topic out of the way as I don't really care about it. It was probably only done to tease shippers, though I find it hard to believe that a Barry-Iris combination would have any shippers left at this point... Still, in that episode she clearly said she was thinking about Barry ever since his first confession. Now maybe Wells is right and it took the trauma of a life-and-death situation to get her to admit it and I don't have any problem with her reaction changing a bit in the alternate timeline. But categorically denying everything is a bit unrealistic.
Now for the more important point:
I like my villains to be a bit more nuanced and intelligent than the usual one-dimensional "because I hate you, and nothing on this world can change that" treatment they gave to poor Slade Wilson. (I'm still disappointed about that despite the rather good 2nd season, as I quite liked him as a good guy in season 1).
When Wells told Eiling that "he takes care of his own" I was ready (and hopeful) to believe that. When he gave up that piece from his suit to save Firestorm it looked like that was the case. He expressed in both episodes that he feels about Cisco like he is his son. I could have bought that too. IF he had found ANY other solution to Cisco finding out about him then killing him. He could have tried to convince him about his motives etc. Hell, he could have just left and disappeared without killing him. I'm sure after killing him he did not have any other choice either... Yet, he killed him, casting serious doubt about just how much he really cares. Compared to that his speach to Cisco in Rogue Time seemed much less credible, and his decision to prevent him from leaving too...
(I realize that what I just said above is just my personal wishful thinking regarding what I would have liked his character to turn out like and that the producers may have something different in mind, but it's disappointing none-the-less. And especially if it was purely done out of a whim just to shock people...)
Now for Rogue Time:
I found this to be the better episode of the two primarily because it builds so well on last weeks setup. The events pick up steam and due to the time travel element we got a chance to study the "little differences". It was both interesting to see how the time travel works on this show, like the often mentioned "inertia effect", but I also found it was a nice opportunity to "study" the various people's characters by observing the changes in their reactions and behaviour.
Besides, despite of the campy portrayal (or perhaps because of it) I quite enjoy Captain Cold. He was way more entertaining than the Weather Wizard. I just don't know why I keep thinking "Riddick" every time I see him, despite never have seen any of the Riddick movies...