The Good Citizens of Metropolis: The Casting Thread

Superman - David Corenswet

Lois Lane - Summer Bishil



I kind of feel like her role on The Magicians was her audition as a somewhat meaner, far more vulgar Lois Lane who’s also capable of magic.

Also she’s only five years older than he is, for those of you who’ve still got heart palpitations over Amy Adams having the audacity to be 9 years older then Cavill.


Yet, it's totally fine for a woman to bang an alien!!

I have always liked the idea of Lois being this older, work first Lady... her career is peaking, family moment probably gone (in her eyes).. she doesn't even know how or who will be there for her etc. I feel like, she also needs to be a bit quirky, that she is in love with an alien and it's not lost on her that her perfect man, isn't human.
 
Last edited:

I like Cox but he would’ve been all wrong.

EDIT: I guess the tweet got deleted. It was Mark Millar saying Matthew Vaughn would’ve wanted Charlie Cox to play Superman back in 2010.
 
Honestly, I’m intrigued by the idea of Millar’s proposed trilogy, but I don’t trust that there wouldn’t be stuff in there that I’d absolutely hate.

If DC were to get him to do his story as a stand-alone graphic novel(s), I’d definitely read it, but as films, where it could easily be all the Superman we get for a decade, I’m not so sure.
 
You know who’d make an interesting Kent? Daniel Radcliffe. I don’t think he’d be a right fit for Superman even if he was taller, but I could see him nailing the reporter aspect of the dynamic.
 
Yeah he’s always kind of naturally awkward so that makes sense. The thing is, a lot of suggestions in here I could easily see making a great Clark Kent. Even the Adam Driver suggestion, which I’m vehemently against. Because it’s finding someone who could do that and also seamlessly make the transition to Superman where it gets tricky, and very few end up making that cut, in my eyes.
 
I have the inverse problem with a lot of suggestions. They can play Superman, but don't have the comedic chops for Clark Kent. Don't want Henry Cavill again where Clark Kent is literally just exactly the same, but with glasses.
 
I should rephrase: it's finding someone who seems like they'd be good at both which is tricky. Because I also agree there are a few here that have the look and I could see them being all superheroic, but couldn't see them pulling off the charming dorkiness of Clark Kent.
 
As someone who was not originally on the Corenswet bandwagon, everything I have seen of him lately makes me a believer. First of all, I am a height snob, in that I believe Superman should be above 6ft one, a true 6 ft one, and the dude is six four.. But Corenswet seems to possess the Clark Kent dorkiness and the Superman stateliness. He seems to honestly be a dork trapped in the body of a Superhero. He also seems to possess the charm Superman/Clark has lacked lately. His instagram is so amazingly charming, I for one am sold. He is a band geek trapped in the body of Superman, and I would love to see that portrayed on the big screen.
 
I should rephrase: it's finding someone who seems like they'd be good at both which is tricky. Because I also agree there are a few here that have the look and I could see them being all superheroic, but couldn't see them pulling off the charming dorkiness of Clark Kent.
I think a big problem here is the “handsome guy on SNL” syndrome, as I’ve coined it. They either go way over the top or the joke is that they’re an incredibly handsome guy being a nerd. I know the Chris Reeve version of Clark is a bit much for some people, but it’s really an incredible performance just from body language alone. His posture is totally different, the way he moves. It’s not just Superman in disguise it’s a whole separate character. The easy trap to fall into is Hemsworth in Ghostbusters, which is funny, but pretty surface level.
 
Ah, see, I don’t want Clark to be a full-on performance à la Reeve this time. That’s where a Supes story loses me because that’s where most of his most important daily relationships are formed. He has to be mostly genuine in them for me to invest, just downplaying certain super qualities. That’s the part I really loved about Dean Cain’s Clark. He was naturally a dork who used his powers in cheesy ways to amuse himself, played off uses of superpowers as klutzy moments and came up with lame excuses for always rushing off for Super-emergencies that just enhanced the “dork” image, making everyone just roll their eyes and think, “typical Clark.” He had goofy moments, but he was still being himself at the end of the day. That’s what I want for Clark this time around.

But I agree Hemsworth in Ghostbusters ain’t it, lol.
 
I think Clark & even Superman need some performance but I don’t what klutzy Clark back. I always feel the real person is Clark when he’s with his parents on the farm, with Lois (when they’re a couple) and with those of his friends that know his secret. Dean Cain really nailed Clark Kent, a mixture of Dean Cain Clark and Chris Reeve’s Superman is what’s required imo. Obviously not emulating those performances but taking similar approaches. Which is how I feel those late 80s/early 90s comic books from John Byrne, Dan Jurgens etc approached the character.
 
Ah, see, I don’t want Clark to be a full-on performance à la Reeve this time. That’s where a Supes story loses me because that’s where most of his most important daily relationships are formed. He has to be mostly genuine in them for me to invest, just downplaying certain super qualities. That’s the part I really loved about Dean Cain’s Clark. He was naturally a dork who used his powers in cheesy ways to amuse himself, played off uses of superpowers as klutzy moments and came up with lame excuses for always rushing off for Super-emergencies that just enhanced the “dork” image, making everyone just roll their eyes and think, “typical Clark.” He had goofy moments, but he was still being himself at the end of the day. That’s what I want for Clark this time around.

But I agree Hemsworth in Ghostbusters ain’t it, lol.

Great example, also, with Cain, you truly felt that he didn't rate himself, he just wanted to present himself as a gentleman. He was a normal guy but that's also what made attractive as he was a 'keeper'.
I do feel though, that Clark, at times, for certain people, should def play up the dork part. He interviews a kid and the kid starts to see through it, he should then just do something so dorky the kid rolls their eyes, in an embaressing dad way.

Also, Cain never showed off his muscles or meant too, he was conservative - that's how you do handsome but unassuming, compared to Hemworth where you kinda felt he was in on the joke... but also, that's just lazy - let's reverse the hot bimbo role.

I said this before, but when superman, I want that the be an act too, not all the time, but in crowds, or certain people, I want clark to actually be different, like I had this idea that when superman is first introduced to the public, he is not so much awkward, but stiff to alienate him almost, not in a bad way, but the movie starmen with Jeff bridges, an alien in human form and you can tell. I had this idea, which clark alludes to when talking to his parents or Lana, that he like, infant of criminals, turns into a t800 just to present something scary for them to tell others, I dunno, like imagine a bank robber running down an alley and out of the shadows comes superman, eyes glowing, not talking, bullets flying of him, he grabs the crook cold, throws him down, he's winded and going no where, then the as the van pulls off, in super speed superman is infront and it crashes into him, glad everywhere, the driver dragged out, thrown to the floor, he's winded, a garbage bin, those large ones superman tips over, debris everywhere, superman places them in there, closes the lid, bashes it so it warps and stays shut... then as they stare through a crack, superman stares back and just levitates and flies away.... that's badass.
I just didn't want superman to be too human too soon - just so that when sat next to clark in the DP, the superman people talk about seems different too. Also, do we want people knowing he grew up here or did he just arrive or do we want them not knowing?
 
My like of David Corenswet is that I think he possessed a certain dorky quality as is. Although Reeves performance as an actor was great, I always found the character kind of dull, in that it was a performance, not a living character. If you go to Corenswet's instagram, or see his stuff on youtube, there seems to be a certain aura that comes through. Like Tyler Hoechlin, he seems genuine, and that is what I have come to like. Corenswet has acting talent, the best since Reeve's but he has a certain quality, a je ne sais quo, that I think the camera will pick up, and I think his Clark could be epic, but so can his Superman. Like I have said, I was not originally sold, but since then, wow. I think his inherent charm could really shine, and that has been so severely lacking in the character as of late.
 
My like of David Corenswet is that I think he possessed a certain dorky quality as is. Although Reeves performance as an actor was great, I always found the character kind of dull, in that it was a performance, not a living character. If you go to Corenswet's instagram, or see his stuff on youtube, there seems to be a certain aura that comes through. Like Tyler Hoechlin, he seems genuine, and that is what I have come to like. Corenswet has acting talent, the best since Reeve's but he has a certain quality, a je ne sais quo, that I think the camera will pick up, and I think his Clark could be epic, but so can his Superman. Like I have said, I was not originally sold, but since then, wow. I think his inherent charm could really shine, and that has been so severely lacking in the character as of late.
I hear ya, I never really noticed that.... but Superman and Clark on farm felt kinda flat, like, you would just be like, have a beer and loosen up.... I mean, Superman, I like his portrayal... but def his natural persona as Clark, needed to differentiate itself.
Never really thought about that until now.....
 
Yeah, I feel like Corenswet could hit all the right notes. He’s definitely got the look and the height; pack on another 10-20 lbs. of muscle and he might be our most comic book accurate Superman since Reeve. But unlike Cavill (who comes off dry in the CK scenes) or Routh (who looked like he was secretly hoping he’d just get through his scenes without having to speak), I feel like Corenswet has that dorky charm that could really shine through when it needs to. I don’t think that he would need to turn into an all-out nerd but I think he would be able to find a comfortable balance between geeky and confident. I’m not crazy about the CWverse but I feel like Hoechlin’s Kent is the closest we’ve gotten to what the character has evolved into over the past several decades.
 
If MOS/BvS had given us a Clark in the DP who put on an act, of sorts, wether he's goofy, bumbling, Boy Scout, quiet, miserable, for a wink at the audience moment with Lois, just to give us the typical dynamics of the character of Superman, Clark in the office then the real clark... would have gone a long way.

For me, the appeal of a superman hiding amongst us.... that I could be that superman, as a child was so powerful a visual.
 
Has Dennis Quaid been mentioned for either Jon Kent or Perry White?
 
I went with Kyle Chandler as my Johnathan. Younger looking and I like the possibility that Clark could look like his son.
 
I just figured the Kent's don't need to be old geezers or have a dead Jonathan Kent.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"