The Joker Thread - Part 1

where's did i just complain, im just askin a question ,u the only one gettin on ur high horses, dont worry u still can dream about jesse plemmons for u next joker tho.
Have you seen my extensive Joker theories? Also there has been many rumors of his involvement in this film, and now Drops confirms it as far as I'm concerned. It isn't baseless at all.
 
where's did i just complain, im just askin a question ,u the only one gettin on ur high horses, dont worry u still can dream about jesse plemmons for u next joker tho.
That would almost be funny if I ever, ever, even just once suggested Him as Joker but whatever dude
 
I don't think Jesse Plemmons is particularly suited for Joker but I find it hilarious that he's the go to example you're using for a "Nobody" in the role when he is super well known for being one of the most striking performances on the most acclaimed television program ever.
 
Some of your wardrobe suggestions are a little too subdued for me, but I actually like that one a lot.
For me it's about fitting into the somewhat grounded aesthetic while also standing out. Especially after seeing those recent set photos; I know it's a funeral and probably not the best representation of what Reeves is going for aesthetically, but everyone's wearing shades of black, so it makes sense for Joker to wear purple, even if it's a more minimalistic take on the classic suit.

It's realistic, like something he put together himself from a few different closets while still being relatively classic.
 
Last edited:
Chemist could be interesting and make him super smart, although it might be falling into line of a lot of other random comic book characters that are scientists or whatever, which might make it less unique. Definitely agree that it would be nice to not get the clown/comedian/military thing again.

I'd really love it if they just never explain what he is, he just shows up one day and is the true wildcard to the criminal world in Gotham, everyone is afraid of him - including other criminals and gangs. In TDK he works with them (I know he has his own plan and uses them, but he still has ties to them and talks with the mob) but in this maybe he's truly just on his own? I love the TDK force of nature idea, but remove any of the hints about a backstory entirely. I also don't really dig when Joker becomes super deranged like in Scott Snyder's Endgame, for example.

That's probs what I'd like to see (but I'm down with most directions tbh). I don't really find Joker as a character interesting at all, the interesting bit for me comes out of the moral positions he puts Batman in, so that's why I'd prefer no backstory at all and he's just straight up plopped there, current gangster, anarchist or not.

My thought: split the difference with some of your comments. Have a Joker of mysterious origin show up, but then lean heavily into the "dark mirror" angle. He's not just Batman's moral opposite, in many ways he's the anti-Batman: a brilliant obsessive polymath bringing to bare a vast array of skills and resources to enact changes upon the city. Only, since his founding morality is "amoral nihilism", the changes he is trying to enact are "Make the city a more anarchic land of crime and corruption, so I can sit as its king and do whatever I whim". He's not trying to sell some ideological point to the general public ( ala the Ledger Joker ), he's just trying to make the place more suited to his own use.

Perhaps have a scene with an almost literal "Joker cave", showing him having assembled his tools and gadgets, zany conspiracy boards across which he's plotted out his plans, stuff like that. Also, and this would probably be controversial: have him get committed to Arkham on being caught, and make clear that this is *deliberate* on his part. He's *not* insane, not in any criminal sense, he simply *chooses* to go there for reasons of his own ( facilitated via a mix of acting skills and corruption of the system ).
 
For me it's about fitting into the somewhat grounded aesthetic while also standing out. Especially after seeing those recent set photos; I know it's a funeral and probably not the best representation of what Reeves is going for aesthetically, but everyone's wearing shades of black, so it makes sense for Joker to wear purple, even if it's a more minimalistic take on the classic suit.

It's realistic, like something he put together himself from a few different closets while still being relatively classic.
I'm all for the dark and gritty, it's my preference, but I don't see anything more grounded and realistic about a subdued suit, vs a more colorful one. People wear really colorful clothing, no reason Joker can't. I think making sure it fits the aesthetic is more important, and to me the more toned down modern suits you're choosing fit the aesthetic less than something like a colorful 80s suit would. The realism comes from the logic behind it. Where Riddler's outfit is clearly all army surplus, make Joker's outfit a thrift store collage. Something in this area:
4f40b0df6071e1521b77cb6dcf362ff7.jpg
1980s-style-lookmarks.info_.jpg
 
I'm all for the dark and gritty, it's my preference, but I don't see anything more grounded and realistic about a subdued suit, vs a more colorful one. People wear really colorful clothing, no reason Joker can't. I think making sure it fits the aesthetic is more important, and to me the more toned down modern suits you're choosing fit the aesthetic less than something like a colorful 80s suit would. The realism comes from the logic behind it. Where Riddler's outfit is clearly all army surplus, make Joker's outfit a thrift store collage. Something in this area:
4f40b0df6071e1521b77cb6dcf362ff7.jpg
1980s-style-lookmarks.info_.jpg
My thoughts exactly. You put it perfectly; Riddler's wardrobe is mainly "army surplus", largely about placing practicality over appearance with the army jacket, gloves, cold weather facemask, etc which fits the characterization. Joker, on the other hand, should probably own some fancy suits that he most likely stole during a closet raid. The 80s suits you posted really do fit that kitschy vintage style he usually goes for in the comics. AND they also give him that timeless feel that might help vaguely imply that he's older than we think like in the New 52.

I'm not saying super loud outfits CAN'T work at all, I'm just not sure it's something they'd really want to do. At the very least I'm expecting, like, polka dots on a couple of his ties and/or bowties. Maaaaybe a warmer magenta coloring for the classic suit, but nothing flashy. I reeeeaaally like that second one you posted though because it's straight out of ASHOSE. Now you have me actually anticipating something like that lol
 
Last edited:
Damn, I never truly thought anything of it before, but this with a button down shirt and maaaybe a tie would be an interesting, distinct look for Reeves' Joker. @shauner111 This might be the solution to a potential Bowie problem if they go full TDKR with Leto in JL.

He even wore something very similar in ASHOSE.

1980s-style-lookmarks.info_.jpg
 
Last edited:
For me it's about fitting into the somewhat grounded aesthetic while also standing out. Especially after seeing those recent set photos; I know it's a funeral and probably not the best representation of what Reeves is going for aesthetically, but everyone's wearing shades of black, so it makes sense for Joker to wear purple, even if it's a more minimalistic take on the classic suit.

It's realistic, like something he put together himself from a few different closets while still being relatively classic.
But as we saw at the funeral scene, the fashion aesthetic of this film is NOT that grounded. Reeves is using the campy, over the top real world styles of the 1980s to make the theatrical aesthetic of the comics grounded. I think the example of Gordon Gecko or any of the New Wave rock stars is a good example of how a very theatrical Joker can look of this world.
 
Maybe not unkempt, but maybe washed out, like he's gotten more than enough use out of it (numerous wash cycles). Oh, and make it purple.

C1145C29-21DE-433B-8B08-E9FCE6BE70A6.jpeg
26C07BEA-0D6F-4E44-85C1-014AA43F483A.jpeg
To me Joker is wild. His clothes are wrinkled and he doesn’t comb his hair. He doesn’t even brush his teeth.
 
But as we saw at the funeral scene, the fashion aesthetic of this film is NOT that grounded. Reeves is using the campy, over the top real world styles of the 1980s to make the theatrical aesthetic of the comics grounded. I think the example of Gordon Gecko or any of the New Wave rock stars is a good example of how a very theatrical Joker can look of this world.
That IS actually my argument for a more colorful Joker. Much less like a cosplayer and more like David Bowie OR.....a new wave Fred Astaire, if that makes sense. But I'd be perfectly fine with a range anyways; subdued and muted to colorful as well as everything in between.
 
We often talk about a Bowie inspired Joker, but is there an actor out there that has his looks and charisma? I can't think of any (and please don't say Tilda Swinton).


style-2010-10-david-bowie-david-bowie-7.jpg



wBuR8RsOFB1dyEobzqPgaAKbTElhOv45TnK-IztAwR9YsGfe23BXTx5HPY2UIa0CKEH6oXQyKXd2JCsGMbKpK76xHoFFf04lfmuArRPofDOfo67pEyRtxpWSdxQNxq8EVzgWKkBdd8TMEHW5ZoeY9uXiKE0BC6LN0i5cAWS5AVdgKjZzpwuofOq_rqqhvVSQ

1976_duke_grin_600h.jpg

TWK.gif
If you're talking about Bowie's rather effeminate, charming kind of charisma specifically, I can't really name anyone off the top of my head. I feel like, for now at least (and even if someone tries to replicate his whole "thing" in the future, they probably won't come close), he's still essentially one of a kind.

I feel like he essentially kickstarted the androgynous "trend" (is that appropriate usage??) in the mid 70s that later grew exponentially throughout the 80s; and that's 20 years before my time!

*Well, him and maaaaaaaybe Robert Plant.
 
The only person I can even think of that I'd want to see is Jake Gyllenhaal because he can do anything (although his Prisoners freak out scene makes me want him as Harvey for some reason), but if it's not him I'd rather they go with someone who's not very well known. it would be tough to pull off the charismatic Bowie vibes without being too hammy or cringey

Side note: Could you imagine Pattinson, Gyllenhaal and Ryan Gosling all in the same movie? dear lord the sheer acting talent in that cast would be nuts. I love Gosling but I still don't know where he'd fit character wise (and I think he's less likely of taking a Batman role than Gyllenhaal nowadays)
 
Harry Styles. There’s really not that many choices.
I like that he's starting to branch out from his super awkward "teen popstar who caters to elementary school girls" roots but physically, he doesn't really remind me of Bowie.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,377
Messages
22,094,341
Members
45,890
Latest member
Tlebdare
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"