The Amazing Spider-Man The Mary Jane Casting Rumors thread - Part 1

[SpaceWay2009]

How about Kirsten Dunst? lol JK.

 

[Sky Captain]

Alex Breckenridge?

 

[UltimateWebhead]

How about Kirsten Dunst? lol JK.

Alex Breckenridge?

Me likes this one.

 

[SpideyFan866]

Alex Breckenridge?

Maybe.

 

[Any Carolina]

Deborah Ann Woll until it is a good suggestion.

 

[Majik1387]

I found what it is with her; She's too geeky looking for MJ. Don't get me wrong, it's a sexy geek sort of thing, but it's not MJ.

 

[lordofthenerds]

Model/Actress Elena Satine

 

[Majik1387]

No thank you.

 

[spider-neil]

Quote from AH friend about Emma Stone....

"I remember when she was cast, or miscast, as I felt. If you’ve seen EASY A, Emma Stone would be the greatest Mary Jane Watson EVER. She oozes that kind of redheaded, husky-voiced sultriness that just screams MJ. I felt having her as Gwen was like saying “We’ve cast Christopher Reeve to be in SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE, and he’s playing Jimmy Olsen!”


I will always remain open-minded, but she looks just like Gwen Stacy because, let’s face it: John Romita drew Mary Jane and Gwen Stacy identically, with different hair. She makes a great-looking Gwen, because she’d make a great-looking MJ.


If I was in charge, Emma Stone’s Gwen would die her fabulous tragic death in the film (or the sequel), and Pete would then meet Mary Jane… played by Emma Stone. Play up his initial attraction being based on the fact that she reminds him of Gwen. Kind of in a Hitchcockian way.



Thank goodness I’m not in charge of such things."

I believe this ^ is a brilliant idea.

that would be kinda funny and the general audience would be WTF?!

MJ - 'face it tiger, you just hit the jackpot'
peter - 'the hell?!'

*checks her neck to see if there is a scar from the break*

 

[spider-neil]

Model/Actress Elena Satine

WHOA!!

 

[WarriorDreamer]

Evan Rachel Wood

Is by no means my first choice but I wouldn't totally object to her getting the part.

British Actress Imogen Poots

Has very pretty eyes, auditioned for Gwen and has a convincing American accent.

 

[Majik1387]

Imogen Poots

 

[KRIM]

Yeah, my vote is for Imogen as well. Very competent actress and she's got one of the most gorgeous eyes in Hollywood. She has a very innocent and goody two-shoes vibe about her, but that is easily altered through acting and the right styling.

She's already got the natural beauty. Dressed in teen sexpot clothing and given she can pull off that carefree and self-assured MJ attitude, I can easily see her being ripped right out of the pages as Stone was for Gwen.

 

[zanos]

She also does a mean scottish accent.

 

[spider-neil]

poots is cute but imho they need to go for 'hot' rather than 'cute'.
say what you want about megan fox's acting ability she is 'hot'.
she is an example by the way I don't want her for this movie. I want to see a dynamic where you have the 'cute' gwen stacy and the 'hot' MJ. spectacular spider-man played that up brilliant.

 

[Majik1387]

Fox is not hot at all. Don't get me wrong, she used to be, but since then she's gotten too skinny and too much plastic surgery. It's apparent and ugly.

 

[SpideyFan866]

Model/Actress Elena Satine

I've suggested her a million times. The guys here just don't like her even though theres a chance she could end up as MJ considering she screentested for TASM and was in the final group considered for a role.

 

[SpideyFan866]

Evan Rachel Wood

Is by no means my first choice but I wouldn't totally object to her getting the part.

British Actress Imogen Poots

Has very pretty eyes, auditioned for Gwen and has a convincing American accent.

Evan Rachel Wood is a no. She was cast in the musical as MJ but I don't want her in the movie.

Imogen Poots is a no because she would work much better as Gwen, not MJ.

 

[spider-neil]

Fox is not hot at all. Don't get me wrong, she used to be, but since then she's gotten too skinny and too much plastic surgery. It's apparent and ugly.

I'm talking transformers 1 megan fox.

 

[Majik1387]

I've suggested her a million times. The guys here just don't like her even though theres a chance she could end up as MJ considering she screentested for TASM and was in the final group considered for a role.

Here's the thing, she lost the role for a reason. Also I'll add, what have any of you posters who suggest her actually seen her in? Other than her half-dressed photoshoots?





That's what I thought. She's TASM's Megan Gale. She'll have supporters simply because she's pretty.

Evan Rachel Wood is a no. She was cast in the musical as MJ but I don't want her in the movie.

Imogen Poots is a no because she would work much better as Gwen, not MJ.

To be fair to ERW, she wasn't cast as MJ for a long time in the musical.
And with Poots, cut and paste her name and Gwen with Stone and MJ and you'll sound like all the negative posters when Emma got Gwen.

I'm talking transformers 1 megan fox.

Even then, I didn't see her as some big sexpot, but I understood ppl liking her look even if it was skanky.

 

[Bats123]

Diora Baird.

She's an actress/model, shes the same age as Andrew's.

 

[Majik1387]

She's looking too old for to be in the same age range as Andrew and Emma. I love her though. She'd be a great Cat Grant in the new Superman movies.

 

[SpideyFan866]

Diora Baird.

She's an actress/model, shes the same age as Andrew's.

She's ok but she doesn't pass as 18 or an early twenty something as well as Andrew does. She looks her age if not older.

So.... no.

 

[spider-neil]

Here's the thing, she lost the role for a reason. Also I'll add, what have any of you posters who suggest her actually seen her in? Other than her half-dressed photoshoots?





That's what I thought. She's TASM's Megan Gale. She'll have supporters simply because she's pretty.

To be fair to ERW, she wasn't cast as MJ for a long time in the musical.
And with Poots, cut and paste her name and Gwen with Stone and MJ and you'll sound like all the negative posters when Emma got Gwen.

Even then, I didn't see her as some big sexpot, but I understood ppl liking her look even if it was skanky.

okay, to get an idea of your taste, who do you think is the hottest girl of the last 20 years?

if I have to answer my question it would jennifer connerly, circa rocketeer

 

[Dark Raven]

Diora Baird.

She's an actress/model, shes the same age as Andrew's.

She looks like she's in her early to mid thirties. She seems more like she would be a business woman who power dresses for work.