The Amazing Spider-Man The Mary Jane Casting Rumors thread - Part 1

[Troy_Parker]

 

[wondergirl]

it would be great if they could have mary jane in this film it would be really awesome plus she was always peter parker's true love not gwen stacy.

 

[Godzilla2014]

it would be great if they could have mary jane in this film it would be really awesome plus she was always peter parker's true love not gwen stacy.

Yeah, in the comics I always preferred Mary Jane over Gwen.

 

[spideyguy16]

Gwens cool as long as they make it obvious that mary jane is his true love

 

[UltimateWebhead]

Gwens cool as long as they make it obvious that mary jane is his true love

Ok so, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Gwen his true love? Peter only ended up with MJ cause Gwen was unintentionally killed by his webbing after she was thrown from the Brooklyn Bridge by the GG.

I was thinking that he prob would have ended up with Gwen in the long run had it not been for her untimely death.

 

[Curmudgeon]

Ok so, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Gwen his true love? Peter only ended up with MJ cause Gwen was unintentionally killed by his webbing after she was thrown from the Brooklyn Bridge by the GG.

I was thinking that he prob would have ended up with Gwen in the long run had it not been for her untimely death.

Wasn't he going to propose to Gwen?

 

[Rodrigo90]

Only in with Gwen's death did Peter find his true love, Mary Jane.

 

[UltimateWebhead]

Only in with Gwen's death did Peter find his true love, Mary Jane.

Peter and MJs relationship was a tumbling mess. They worked together in many ways but she did turn him down on his proposal because she didn't want to be trapped to one man...a party girl for sure. They eventually married but also divorced.

IMO, Gwen was a better match for Peter.

 

[andrecamilo18]

What about this?

Lyndsy Fonseca

Imogen Poots

 

[Rodrigo90]

Peter and MJs relationship was a tumbling mess. They worked together in many ways but she did turn him down on his proposal because she didn't want to be trapped to one man...a party girl for sure. They eventually married but also divorced.

IMO, Gwen was a better match for Peter.

True, but I dont like the thought of Peter thinking of MJ as second best.

 

[The Infernal]

Ok so, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Gwen his true love? Peter only ended up with MJ cause Gwen was unintentionally killed by his webbing after she was thrown from the Brooklyn Bridge by the GG.

Yeah, but she would have died anyway by hitting the water from that height.

I was thinking that he prob would have ended up with Gwen in the long run had it not been for her untimely death.

The way I've heard it was that Gwen was supposed to be Peter's one true love, but she was killed off when Stan Lee (I think it was him) went on holiday or something like that.

Though saying that it's been MJ and Peter for a few decades now and most people aren't even aware of Gwen Stacy that it feels weird to try and play that angle in a new film. Still, it's not like people aren't going to go to the movie because of that.

 

[spideyguy16]

What about this?

Lyndsy Fonseca

 

[UltimateWebhead]

Yeah, but she would have died anyway by hitting the water from that height.



The way I've heard it was that Gwen was supposed to be Peter's one true love, but she was killed off when Stan Lee (I think it was him) went on holiday or something like that.

Though saying that it's been MJ and Peter for a few decades now and most people aren't even aware of Gwen Stacy that it feels weird to try and play that angle in a new film. Still, it's not like people aren't going to go to the movie because of that.

It's important to tell the story of Spider-man and include Gwen. People are mostly aware of only MJ but it would be another injustice not to have her in these next movies. People need to know about her. She IS Peter's true love, at least initially anyway.

 

[UltimateWebhead]

True, but I dont like the thought of Peter thinking of MJ as second best.

It is absolutely possible for someone to love more than one person in their lifetime but Gwen and Peter had way more in common than MJ and Peter. That's not to say she is second best...just different.

 

[The Infernal]

It's important to tell the story of Spider-man and include Gwen. People are mostly aware of only MJ but it would be another injustice not to have her in these next movies. People need to know about her. She IS Peter's true love, at least initially anyway.

Well I wouldn't call it an injustice to have her in the movies. Some would argue that no inclusion would be an injustice, as if they were trying to erase her. Though personally I'll just be happy if she turns up at some point in this new series of films (well if this one is well received).

I don't think it's mandatory for MJ to be in this first one, but it wouldn't be the worst thing.... unless they got some random actress just for a small cameo which then turned into a staring role in future movies only to showcase her lack of talent. lol

It is absolutely possible for someone to love more than one person in their lifetime but Gwen and Peter had way more in common than MJ and Peter. That's not to say she is second best...just different.

See, this is a great way to put it. Though I get a sick feeling when I think of Marvel's habit of forcing promoting character stories when they're in a movie and that they might do something truly stupid in an attempt to further erase Peter and MJ's relationship and ressurect Gwen. Who lets face it is probably one of the last few dead comic book characters to have stayed dead for the most part.

 

[Scarlettess]

Well I wouldn't call it an injustice to have her in the movies. Some would argue that no inclusion would be an injustice, as if they were trying to erase her. Though personally I'll just be happy if she turns up at some point in this new series of films (well if this one is well received).

I don't think it's mandatory for MJ to be in this first one, but it wouldn't be the worst thing.... unless they got some random actress just for a small cameo which then turned into a staring role in future movies only to showcase her lack of talent. lol

See, this is a great way to put it. Though I get a sick feeling when I think of Marvel's habit of forcing promoting character stories when they're in a movie and that they might do something truly stupid in an attempt to further erase Peter and MJ's relationship and ressurect Gwen. Who lets face it is probably one of the last few dead comic book characters to have stayed dead for the most part.

I wouldn't rule it out, what with Scarlet Spider being ressurected and the Jackal coming back. Myabe they'll bring her in as another clone

 

[UltimateWebhead]

I wouldn't rule it out, what with Scarlet Spider being ressurected and the Jackal coming back. Myabe they'll bring her in as another clone

 

[Immortalfire]

Though I get a sick feeling when I think of Marvel's habit of forcing promoting character stories when they're in a movie and that they might do something truly stupid in an attempt to further erase Peter and MJ's relationship and ressurect Gwen. Who lets face it is probably one of the last few dead comic book characters to have stayed dead for the most part.

God help us.

 

[The Infernal]

@UltimateWebhead and Immortalfire. My thoughts exactly.

 

[spideyguy16]

Leave her in peace!!

 

[Spider-Ranger]

Just watched "The Ides of March"

Evan Rachel Wood could indeed be a great M.J.

 

[I'm Old Greg]

Makes No Sense to me

why didn't they just have girl playing Gwen in this new movie play Mary Jane in the sequel??

she already had red hair, she has a fiesty comedic personality, she had the look

But instead they dye another actresses hair like Rami did...

I know shes really a blonde but she's known as a redhead

 

[Mrs. Sawyer]

You're a year late without that stupid, whiny complaint.

 

[Sebastos]

Makes No Sense to me

why didn't they just have girl playing Gwen in this new movie play Mary Jane in the sequel??

she already had red hair, she has a fiesty comedic personality, she had the look

But instead they dye another actresses hair like Rami did...

I know shes really a blonde but she's known as a redhead

It's called "wanting a different love interest".

 

[Infinity9999x]

It's important to tell the story of Spider-man and include Gwen. People are mostly aware of only MJ but it would be another injustice not to have her in these next movies. People need to know about her. She IS Peter's true love, at least initially anyway.

I agree. However, I think they were both "true loves" of Peter. MJ was there for him when Gwen died, they both worked together. I don't think there's anything wrong with saying he loved both women, for different reasons.