Here is my review of Grant Morrison's run:
Well, I would like to start off by saying I didn't like it at all. E is for extiction was good but had it's bad points. One of the bad points was Secondary Mutations. Yes I know they have been used by Claremont to explain Wolvie's claws and stuff but here it was just lazy story telling. I just got the vibe that he was doing this just because he wanted to give Beast a new design (I don't like the design but if he wanted it, he could have not taken the lazy way out and said it just happend). Another bad point of this was the introduction of a terrible villian. I mean who ever liked Cassadra Nova. I think it could have been brilliant with Mastermind, Mr. Sinister, or even the Dark Pheonix posessing someone! Another bad point was things happening all of the sudden with no huge explination that we just had to except. For example, Beast's Secondary Mutation, Jean and Scott's marital problems (I mean there was no deterioration of their love, it just happend), there were students at the school again (where did they come from), new uniforms with out an explination, among other things. Also his run had lack of Continuity between the X-books. I mean even Austen had character appearences once and a while from New. He also had a lack of continutity between his books. One day Wolvie has a gotee and the next he did not (That was more of a Quilty problem and he was a terrible artist). Another thing is the artist. X-Treme had Salvadore for a while, Uncanny had Tan, Garney and Larroca for a while, while this guy worked with 12. I know that's an editing problem but it made the book hard to read with all the changing artists. Also he must be one of the worst character creators ever. Fantomex, No Girl, Martha, Ernst, Angel, Glob, Kid Omega, Slick, Tatoo, Beak, and many others that never did anything, his only good ones were the Cuckoo's which I hope appear in the reload. My final problem is Jean's death and the love triangle between her, Emma, and Scott. Scott just belongs with Jean. And he wasted alot of time with her death because she will be back because she always does. Sorry to all of you Morrison fans but this is just my opinion.