The Walking Dead The Walking Dead Season 3 Episode 11 "I Ain't a Judas" Discussion Thread

[Darthphere]

Oh, Darth... Andrea could give humanity the cure for cancer, AIDS and the zombie virus on the very same day, and you'd still be like "Pffft... **** you. You couldn't give us one for diabetes too? Only wanted to go for 3 out of 4?... *****"

Because she would do it in some really stupid way with a ****** speech attached.

 

[Sakuraba]

I can understand that. It's not crazy to write her off because of everything that has gone down with her character. Andrea, if not beyond redemption as a competent character, isn't far from the border crossing.

But since she's probably not dying anytime soon, I'll take what I can get.

 

[Darthphere]

She should die. Die very soon.

 

[Sawyer]

lol the girl playing Beth giving the "Why you kiss Rick's cheek? You wanna **** Rick?!" question exactly the response it deserves.

 

[Darthphere]

lol the girl playing Beth giving the "Why you kiss Rick's cheek? You wanna **** Rick?!" question exactly the response it deserves.

What does she know? She ain't read no scripts.

 

[ShredderX]

Well the actress that plays Beth just confirmed on " Talking Dead
" that the kiss on Rick's cheek was her just being happy to have her sister back, and nothing more. I always knew that. Hopefully that will put that argument to rest now.

 

[Sawyer]

And then Hardwick giving the "YOU GOT THE EYE WRONG!" complaint the same response. Suffer no fools, TWD. Keep it up.

 

[Darthphere]

Nope. Again, that's what her idea of the scene was. She has no idea what the writers have planned.

But yeah probably. It won't stop people from speculating.

 

[ShredderX]

lol the girl playing Beth giving the "Why you kiss Rick's cheek? You wanna **** Rick?!" question exactly the response it deserves.

Damn Sawyer, you beat me to the punch. LOL

 

[Evelisse]

Tv not ready for a Beth Carl connection, four years? Lets just try and make it four more episodes Beth.

 

[Sawyer]

It might have something to do with the actress being like 14 years older than Chandler Riggs...

 

[Sakuraba]

Well the actress that plays Beth just confirmed on " Talking Dead
" that the kiss on Rick's cheek was her just being happy to have her sister back, and nothing more. I always knew that. Hopefully that will put that argument to rest now.

Are you Robert Kirkman or something?

 

[Elevator Man]

Well the actress that plays Beth just confirmed on " Talking Dead
" that the kiss on Rick's cheek was her just being happy to have her sister back, and nothing more. I always knew that. Hopefully that will put that argument to rest now.

Agreed. Besides who wants to see a Rick and Beth romance anyway?

 

[bullets]

-Merle being less harsh and assimilated into group
-Rick not being mentally ill
-Michonne and Andrea having some resolution
-Tyreese's Group at Woodbury
-Andrea putting forth her best episode since she went fishing with her sister
-governor building his militia
-Herschel continuing his run as best character
-Daryl and Carol acting like they actually have a bond

Productive episode

The downfall of this show will be fans complaining whenever the episode doesn't feature a "shocking" death.

I thought it was a decent episode, but Andrea seemed too naive. Also I was expecting The Governor to wake up and finsh her off.

 

[Sawyer]

Agreed. Besides who wants to see a Rick and Beth romance anyway?

I love that alot of the people bringing that up were the same ones accusing Axel of being a murderous pedo. It's like... surely Rick and Axel aren't that different in age.

 

[Thundercrack85]

Refusing to let those four survivors join their camp was a really dumb move.

 

[Sawyer]

lol both Carl and Rick glaring at Michonne as they get stuck. "****ing women drivers."

 

[Sakuraba]

Do we have to revisit this? Here are the facts, since I was the first to bring it up here in real time during that episode:

-I said it would used as excuse for Carl and Rick to have difficulties. Nothing about Rick returning any affection to Beth.
-I said it probably wouldn't go anywhere, but that it was shot in a way that we would notice it. It was SPECULATION with cause. This is a forum for such things.
-I said I didn't want it to happen. We all said it would be kind of lame in that it wouldn't be handled properly.

 

[Sawyer]

Refusing to let those four survivors join their camp was a really dumb move.

It obviously wasn't a conscious move. Everyone was saying it was good idea to let them in and then Rick's psychosis took the wheel. He wasn't in his right mind.

Besides it's not like they thought the bastards would run directly to Woodbury.

 

[Thundercrack85]

It obviously wasn't a conscious move. Everyone was saying it was good idea to let them in and then Rick's psychosis took the wheel. He wasn't in his right mind.

Besides it's not like they thought the bastards would run directly to Woodbury.

They should have overruled Rick. I'm surprised no one tried that.

True, they might not have gone straight to Woodbury, but they should have figured that could happen (it's the only other place nearby that is "safe"). Even best case scenario, they never see them again, but it's still able bodied people they're passing up on.

 

[Darthphere]

Agreed. Besides who wants to see a Rick and Beth romance anyway?

Do we have to revisit this? Here are the facts, since I was the first to bring it up here in real time during that episode:

-I said it would used as excuse for Carl and Rick to have difficulties. Nothing about Rick returning any affection to Beth.
-I said it probably wouldn't go anywhere, but that it was shot in a way that we would notice it. It was SPECULATION with cause. This is a forum for such things.
-I said I didn't want it to happen. We all said it would be kind of lame in that it wouldn't be handled properly.

Pretty much. I didn't see anyone calling for a relationship. Is it that far from the realm of possibility for a young girl to develop a crush on someone? Of course not. Not on the zombie show.

 

[Sawyer]

Except that it was clearly a "thank you" that folks blew up into an "I love you".

 

[Darthphere]

Except that it was clearly a "thank you" that folks blew up into an "I love you".

I don't think it was that clear. Either way, I'm happy it won't be a plotline going forward.

 

[Zatanna]

 

[Darthphere]

Next you're going to tell me that Carl doesn't have a crush on Beth.