Hello to you all. This is my first post, though I have been lurking the board for years.
I`ve also been following the deveopment of this movie for a while now and I have a few thoughts.
I am not really thrilled with the choice of RDJ for Sherlock Holmes. I think he will put a good take on the character, but he is absolutely not who I would cast. Holmes was described as being 6 foot 2 and so thin that he appeared even taller. I also don`t think RDJ personality is quite right either.
I have a few suggestions for Sherlock that I am going to throw out there just for the fun of it.
First, and this is sort of out of left field, I would like to see Crispin Glover in the role of Holmes. To me, he has the look and is eccentric enough. With a good director to reign him in a little, I think he could be very good.
Someone mentioned Adrien Brody earlier, and I could see him being rather effective.
Does anyone think Kyle MacLachlan would be a good choice? I think he could do it, but he`s a little old. He`s 50 (I didn`t realize he was that old, man does time fly) but he looks younger.
Johnny Depp would be pretty good, too. He`s already done several roles that were similar to Holmes, most notably in ``Sleepy Hollow``. I have a few problems with him, mainly that he`s almost too obvious, but I have to admit that he would be a good Holmes.
Being that as it may, we got RDJ, and I`m looking forward to this movie. Holmes has been one of my favorite characters since I was a boy, almost to the point of obsession at times. And I have to agree with those of you who liked ``Young Sherlock Holmes``.