Went to see it last night at the IMAX.
Unfortunetly the more I reflect and think about this film, the more I get annoyed and realise it just wasn't that good. In fact I'm slowly beginning to feel like I dislike this movie. It's Superman Returns all over again (even though they were completely different movies)
Things I hated...
Story
The millions the were plainly and obviously killed while Superman and the Kryptonites were smashing EVERYTHING around them. Superman just didn't really give a f#%k.
The appalling dialogue at times, I actually laughed a couple of times at the pure cheese of the poorly written script.
The flash back scenes didn't have the right pacing, and just didn't gel well enough.
The fortress of solitude/research ship was poor. All the Kryptonian ships looked terrible with very little effort going into the design.
FAR FAR too much action, and incomprehensible action. Mr Bay strikes again.. Oops sorry Zack strikes. Was far too loud as well, and the final fight was ridiculous OVERKILL. I do not want to watch 60mins of continuous CGI even in a comicbook movie. There is so much great material they could use from the Superman universe to flesh out real character development, real romance (in terms of film making and on-screen)
Superman kills Zod, sorry that's a NO.
No warmth about it, for too sterile IMO. I like Henry as Superman, but I just didn't think he was so super compared to Reeves (I don't mean his powers I mean how super protective, super helpful, and super interested he was in us)
Reeves truely cared about humans, Cavill's Superman didn't...clearly.
The devastation on screen was more OTT than 2012!!! That's saying something.
Too many Alien things happening onscreen. It was too much. I did however enjoy Krypton. (3D as good)
Music, Hans Zimmer is NO Williams, not even close. He is a strong composer but def overrated in the comicbook movie world. Most of his scores are not memorable IMO. He doesn't have an ET,BTTF,INDIANA,SUPERMAN, STAR WARS etc etc in his 'we will remember that or hum it' back catalogue. I anted the score to make me feel inspired and to help me root for Superman. I wanted the hairs in my arms to stand on edge because of the combo of superman and soundtrack, it NEVER did. I came out the movie humming Williams as I did going into it. I appreciate the score was subtle and modern, but where was the BIG 'Superman' musical moments.
This Superman won't work in a JL movie, in fact at the moment I CANNOT see how DC can make a JL movie plausible at all.
Zack is a hack, he's a poor director in the bigger scheme of things. Watchman was terrible (you have to adapt scripts) Suckpunch... Please. 300 was above averge JUST... Butler made it memorable, not Zack. This didn't mean I had written off his movie before going in, not at all. I though Nolan could have really helped him develop as a director. Clearly not.
I'm so annoyed about it all actually. It's only a blinking comicbook movie don't get me wrong, but I was so excited. There probably is a happy medium between Singer and Snyder, action and romance. They should have nailed it this time, and again they didn't. Donner's still is the king of Superman directors IMO.