The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Who would be the best MJ?

[Picard Sisko]

I am calling it now Bryce Dallas Howard for MJ. When i saw her in 50/50, first thing that come in my mind was Mary Jane.

I could see her in that role and this scene as she plays friend and support to Peter after Gwen's death.
http://thepioneeronline.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/50-1.jpg

They already have ridiculous Harry's New Goblin story again so why not recast her also, she is actress. I am under impression she could still have contract with Sony

They're not doing "the New Goblin story" again. You need to pay a bit more attention.

 

[FN Spider-man]

I would actually prefer that in TASM3 MJ is introduced as nothing more than a friend. Meaning that she doesn't yet get too involved in the whole story of Spiderman having to fight whomever (the Sinister Six). That also means that Peter's secret stays a secret.

So the MJ character wouldn't be a huge part of the movie the way Gwen has and will be. By TASM4 the friendship could start to move a bit as Peter will hopefully be coming to terms, possibly with MJ's help, with Gwen's death.

At the same time we need some sort of male-female thing going on and the best way to pull that off is Black Cat. Maybe in TASM3 it's just some flirtation. Of course this will always be with masks on, which will be intersting.

By TASM4 that relationship could be explored and become more. It could actually be used to create tension and jelousy for MJ if and when she finds out the secret.

If anything, scenes like this would be so much fun:

The point is that Black Cat will be the one flirting, so it won't come off as Peter being a jerk since Gwen just died. Move too fast into the MJ relationshop and you'll get that feel. But with Black Cat it's not Peter, it's Spiderman. And that's a fun concept that's never been done on screen.

Heck no I dont want to see Felicia treated as a stand in or being used like that I had enough of what marvel is doing to her, after her recovering from the hospital and that whole thing was marvel's doing and it pissed me off. I love her and Spidey together and plus every time she gives MJ a run for her money

 

[Picard Sisko]

It would be cool to see a love interest in Peter's life as Spider-Man. Perhaps he has to choose between Felicia and MJ in the future films?

 

[FN Spider-man]

I'd agree with that just as long as they do her justice and not make her like Marvel is or treat her as what i've just stated

 

[SpeterMan3]

Yeah, I've been thinking about Black Cat too.

 

[Picard Sisko]

I'd agree with that just as long as they do her justice and not make her like Marvel is or treat her as what i've just stated

If they ever plan to make a spin-off for her, I'm sure they will take her seriously.

 

[Wanksta]

I believe that Jane Levy would make a great MJ.

She really doesn't look that much like Emma.

If you take a blonde Emma stone pic(Gwen)



and compare it to a red hair Jane levy pic (MJ)





I really don't see much in common.

Also Jane is a great actress and very different than Emma in so many ways.

I really can't understand why people are comparing these 2.....is it the red hair..i don't know

 

[fuflipflops]

jane looks like emma's little sister, their features looks incredibly similar. if you just google their names + look alike there are plenty of comparisons, it's not just this forums thinking it, or only one part of the internet, or whatever.

 

[DirtyHarry]

From the other thread:

 

[Nicko-Ray]

I wouldn't be surprised if the MJ casting will be from total left field haha. It's been that way anyway.

 

[Avenging Spidey]

I feel that Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man and Dane DeHaan's Harry Osborn are so terrific choices because they've auditioned for their roles.

I can see Margot Robbie as MJ look wise, not sure if she can actually play her. She is my favorite pick for the role right now, but I hope that she and other girls audition next to Andrew Garfield to see which actress can actually have good chemistry with him. I wonder if it'll be tough for Andrew since he seems so in love with Emma and I feel that his role is pretty personal to him, but I'm sure he can pull it off.

 

[Jeff Chris]

How about Karen Gillan?

 

[Super Jim]

She's already in Guardians, so it's not worth discussing. I think she has similar pros and cons as Shaelene does. It's not gonna happen!

 

[Jeff Chris]

She's already in Guardians, so it's not worth discussing. I think she has similar pros and cons as Shaelene does. It's not gonna happen!

Dakota Johnson?

 

[bapi]

Ali Cobrin from American Reunion (24 years old):

 

[Jeff Chris]

Karen Gillan still has a chance to be MJ, hasn't she? I mean, her contract is only for one GOTG.

 

[fuflipflops]

she's not chris evans.

 

[Super Jim]

Karen Gillan still has a chance to be MJ, hasn't she? I mean, her contract is only for one GOTG.

Karen would make a good Ultimate MJ. But Shaelene would make a better Ultimate MJ. But most of us hate Ultimte MJ!!!!!

 

[Valkyrje]

My personal choices are : Alexis Knapp, Lindsy Fonseca, Margot Robbie, Alexandra Daddario and Brie Larson.

 

[fuflipflops]

But most of us hate Ultimte MJ!!!!!

speak for yourself

 

[LEVITIKUZ]

How about that red head chick in Zombieland?

 

[Super Jim]

speak for yourself

Here we go again!

Versus:

 

[LEVITIKUZ]

The way those hips are in that 616 MJ. That just ain't looking right. That's just unnatural.

 

[Majik1387]

How about that red head chick in Zombieland?

Not sure if serious....

 

[Angryfantasyfan]

Karen would make a good Ultimate MJ. But Shaelene would make a better Ultimate MJ. But most of us hate Ultimte MJ!!!!!

Preferring one version of the character doesn't mean you hate the other. And I've yet to see any evidence that the difference between their appearances is due to anything other than personality and age. after all, adult Peter had no problem recognizing the 15 year old alternate version of his wife in the Spider-Men crossover.