Worst comic book film???

[Cyrusbales]

so what do you think is the worst comic book film?

 

[Majik1387]

It wasn't the Rocketeer, Blade 2 or Punisher.

 

[Kable24]

The Rocketeer, Blade II and The Punisher are awesome movies. The Hulk isn't bad. Love the scenes with Hulk in them. X-Men 3 is a fun action movie. B&R sucked royal dick and Superman 4 should have never been made.

 

[Agentsands77]

BATMAN AND ROBIN, without a doubt. At least SUPERMAN 4 somewhat respected its character (and the rest of the films cited aren't *that* bad).

 

[livrule]

I think to answer this question we have to look at potential.

Which movie SHOULD have been great because of the quality of the comic/characters ?

With that in mind ... IMO Daredevil has been the biggest let-down

I know its not on the list but everything from story to casting was just wrong.

 

[CConn]

To my dying day I will argue Superman IV is worse than B&R.

 

[Agentsands77]

To my dying day I will argue Superman IV is worse than B&R.

I could never go there. They both suck, but SUPERMAN IV at least tries to be good to the character.

BATMAN AND ROBIN is a film with no respect at all for the material.

 

[JackBauer]

that a crappy poll, I'll tell you that...

 

[ryankris]

Superman IV is the worst movie ever made! That movie is evil and it should be illeagal to even watch it! The makers of this film should have been arrested and sent to a Cuban prison!!!

 

[Addendum]

Batman and Robin, Superman IV and Blade: Trinity...

The unholy 3

 

[CConn]

I could never go there. They both suck, but SUPERMAN IV at least tries to be good to the character.

BATMAN AND ROBIN is a film with no respect at all for the material.

You haven't read many comics from the 50s and 60s, have you?

 

[Mee]

You haven't read many comics from the 50s and 60s, have you?

At least those didn't have Bat-nipples.

 

[Spoarz™]

Batman & Robin by a mile. At least Superman IV has some redeeming moments thanks to Christopher Reeve.

 

[Kevin Roegele]

I think to answer this question we have to look at potential.

Which movie SHOULD have been great because of the quality of the comic/characters ?

With that in mind ... IMO Daredevil has been the biggest let-down

I know its not on the list but everything from story to casting was just wrong.

How does that make it the worst?

Look at the actual film that exists, not your dreams of what could have been.

 

[Ben Urich]

How is Fantastic Four not on this poll?

 

[CConn]

Because the poll sucks?

 

[HighVoltage]

Superman Returns.

 

[Two-Face]

Batman & Robin obviously but The Punisher, X-Men 3 and Blade 2 aren't worst. CINO(Catwoman In Name Only), FF and Elektra should be in that poll.

 

[Cyrusbales]

I didn't include catwoman out of sheer disgust! I didn't want the poll to be too easy! wanted some discussion. FF4 could be on their, but Dr Doom is a saving grace, even if he is rubbish in the film compared to the comics, he's still an awesome villain.

c'mon, X3 is pretty lame, there's so much wrong with it, ultimate anti-climax of any comic book film series!

 

[DarKush]

1. Batman & Robin
2. Catwoman
3. Superman IV
4. Spawn
5. Blade Trinity (To be fair, it had some good elements, but it was so poorly done and dropped the ball way too often)

If I had seen Steel, Barb Wire, Tank Girl I'm sure they would probably be somewhere on my list.

As for the others on the list: Hulk had a good cast, but the CGI Hulk and Gamma dogs just didn't do it for me. Plus, Nick Nolte's Absorbing Man didn't work for me either. I wish they had gone with another villian.

I liked the Rocketeer, Punisher, Blade 2, and X-3 was okay.

Personally I liked Elektra and FF. Elektra was fairly run of the mill, but I don't understand why it gets such hatred. Same with FF. FF was an entertaining movie. Though Batman Begins was a better movie, I actually had a better time watching FF last year.

 

[Cyrusbales]

Steel is really ****e, but it's so bad it becomes funny, it's quite hilarious really, I didn't want to include it as you can't get it on region 2 DVD so most people haven't seen it.

 

[troika]

OMG how come nobody mentioned the Captain America movie from '91? *****ing horrendous. It was deliberately released that year to counter the Batman film, obviously

 

[Cyrusbales]

I didn't include it, not on region 2 so most people i know haven't seen it,

 

[Jyn]

The worst movie wasn't even on your list. Catwoman was god awful!

 

[Hunter Rider]

Superman 4 out of this lot but you are missing some options like CINO and Elektra