I really enjoyed this episode, not as much as "Sacrifice" but still good. Here is my breakdown:
The Good:
The best part of the episode were the character interactions -(Clark/Martha, Lois/Perry, Perry/Clark etc.) even Clark and Chloe's scenes were some of the best I've seen since "Hex".
Tess's Illusion-That was such a cool fake out and I'm glad the writers made that hostage sequence seem so bizarre and dream-like to clue in the audience before hand.
The Blur saving the crowd right in front of them-Awesome save and the way it was shot was very Supermanly.
Clark watching Lois save Perry and being so proud-Just priceless!t:
The Clois break/break-up-Surprisingly natural and realistic, with not too much angst or overdramatic dialogue. Even at their worst, Clois is SO much better than Clana ever was!
Great Ceasar's Ghost-Loved the Lois and Clark reference!
Chloe admitting her faults and mistakes-...about TIME!!
Clark discovering the Red Queen's identity on his own-Finally, the future Superman using his brain and not Chloe!
The Bad:
Everyone knowing about the Book of Rao and what it can do-Since when did Martha become an expert on sacred Kryptonian artifacts?
Justin Hartley's cameo-Even though Tess' illusion was well done, Oliver's appearence was pointless!
Merry-Their hook-up wasn't really the main focus but still, wasn't buying this hook-up. At least we know Martha isn't serious about Perry and still has Jonathan in her heart.
Maxell Lord..dead!?-Ummm...WHAT?He better not be!
Anyway, it was actually a good set up for the finale, let's just hope...
Lois said that since Conspiracy happen she investigated more about it and figgured about the aliens. Lois went to high scool before she went to college before she went to Smallville High and the Torch so she could have had high school journalism before and grew into her dislike of reporting.Horrible episode, I can't believe they wasted Martha's return on this crap.
Yeah, I liked Martha as Red Queen and the last Chloe scene but everything else was a mess!
The episode title is "Hostage" and the actual hostage (Tess) had 5 min of ST in the episode!![]()
When was she kidnapped by Lord, when did she took the Book of Rao from Kent farm???? Wee should of seen all that stuff instead of Clois crap!
And when did Lois found out about the Book?
I'm not even gonna talk about Lois and retcons about her education and interests!![]()
And I feel horrible about Clark dragging Chloe back into Watchtower when she doesn't wont to be there, I hate the Watchtower set!
Complete mess!!!!!![]()
Checkmate and the Kandorian arcs have always felt like two separate seasons forcefully combined into one; these arcs could have been more convincing if they were spread throughout the season.
Sucks it was a bit down, as i said in the ratings thread i was hoping for 2.3-2.5mill range. Since before the preempt last week was factored in we had 2.37 for sacrifice. But who knows what were the factors. Probably was ironman 2 release, and also i read on ksite that there was an unexpected preempt for i believe san antonio tx area. Now i dont know how much viewership factors there.#Smallville 'Hostage' delivers 1.92 million viewers/0.8 rating.
I thought lois/clark/marth/perry's times were great. i was glad all 4 of them had the key focus for the episode. Chloe was used well in her short time, same as tess. As for the fake oliver he really wasnt even needed for the episode with how little he was in it.BOUROUX
Forum Whiz
![]()
Join Date: Oct 06
Posts: 721
Hostage screentime
Episode 9-21 Hostage
Clark: 21m, 10s
Chloe: 5m, 13s
Lois: 19m, 19s
Oliver: 1m, 44s
Tess: 5m, 32s
Zod: 0m, 00s
Martha: 17m, 12s
Perry: 15m, 34s
Year to Date ST/episode
Clark: 394m, 22s (21)
Chloe: 198m, 02s (21)
Lois: 278m, 10s (17)
Oliver: 157m, 33s (16)
Tess: 111m, 13s (16)
Zod: 116m, 05s (11)
Small amount of screentime for Chloe but the quality compensates.
Allison Mack is amazing.
no it was the Blackest Night/Brightest Day that brought him back to life when the black ring brought him back from the dead and the white light brought 12(Martian Manhunter, Max Lord, Aquaman, Hawkman and Hawkgirl,Captain Boomerang/ Digger Hawkins, Firestorm,Professer Zoom, Jade(Alan Scott's daughter), Osiris(Isis's younger brother), and Boston Brand/Deadman).Wasn't it Darkseid that brought Max Lord back one time?
Great Ceasar's Ghost-Loved the Lois and Clark reference!
.
I thought this one was mediocre as well.
- I wasn't a fan of Martha as the Red Queen and involved with Checkmate covert operations. It wasn't as awful as SuperLana, Lois as Stiletto, or Chloe the Watchtower, but it was still quite bizarre and lame characterization for good old Ma Kent. How is she an expert on Kryptonian artifacts? This ends justifying the means thing (to protect Clark) is getting old too.
- I didn't like Perry as a soft, gentle fatherly figure to Lois and Clark, being domesticated through his relationship with Clark's mom. I'm disapointed they didn't really end Martha/Perry with Perry still wanting to go after Clark's mom. It's all really strange.
- Chloe's neat and tidy resolution was too easy and convenient; especially after all the dark stuff she's done this season and the last. She got off real easy, obviously TPTB realized she is going to be around next season and are dragging her out.
- The Tess subplot, involving her feelings about Oliver, was pretty boring filler. This Chloe/Oliver/Tess thing is getting too much focus.
- They had Vala resolve to join Zod and now they're undermining that within a week? Wow.
- Charade showed that Lord/The Black King was recruited by the Red Queen/Martha. Does that mean the Red Queen killed him via cellphone in that last scene? That one part confused me I admit.
As much as I like Annette O'Toole and Michael McKean, I didn't like what this episode did with their characters. After last week's setup, I expected bigger things here.
PS: A small nitpick but I hate when the characters constantly refer to themselves in the third person; "Lois Lane" "Clark Kent" it's overly unnatural (and pretentious sounding) dialogue. It's not like we constantly need reminders of who they are.
no it was the Blackest Night/Brightest Day that brought him back to life when the black ring brought him back from the dead and the white light brought 12(Martian Manhunter, Max Lord, Aquaman, Hawkman and Hawkgirl,Captain Boomerang/ Digger Hawkins, Firestorm,Professer Zoom, Jade(Alan Scott's daughter), Osiris(Isis's younger brother), and Boston Brand/Deadman).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackest_Night
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brightest_Day
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell_Lord