After seeing Pacific Rim, Del Toro is the one for JL. The interplay among the characters and how well he executed the relationships throughout the movie reminded me of how Whedon did his Avengers. They are obviously two different directors with two different filmmaking approaches and vision, but both know how to craft a story with an assemble cast.
I loved Pacific Rim. Holy COW
Boo. I don't want an Avengers movie. I LIKE these characters from MOS, and I don't want to see anyone mucking with them. They're perfect as they are.
But I can see that fandom is willing to ruin the entire thing, just so they can stroke their fannish egos.
The whole reason the Superman franchise has suffered on screen is because it has toed the line, and catered far too much to comic book fans. Guess what? That formula doesn't work with Superman. Avengers is dumb and campy anyway, so it can be that way in the films too. Superman is a totally different character from any of the Marvel ones. Really, aside from Batman, there are no other comic book characters out there who can compare.
The serious, dark versions of both Superman and Batman are necessary if any of you want them to remain relevant going into the future.
While I agree that the humor in MOS could have been better, I don't think a lot of slapstick, stupid humor would have worked for the story. Perhaps they can lighten things up just a little in the next film, but I don't want to see things become campy and stupid.
What makes MOS a good film is that it's a lot different than the stuff we've gotten from Marvel (which is plainly so awful I won't even go see their films any more). I have never seen a set of films become so overrated. They can be entertaining, in a vapid, ditzy sort of way. But there's almost no substance to the film, no weight, and that makes them unimportant.
I don't want ditzy. I don't want stupid relationship ploys to add 'drama'. I want MOS to be smart and interesting. I want the characters to remain intelligent and warm, strong, but also able to show weakness, and to accept help.
Third viewing, Superman was very good again. When it goes to dollar theater, I am totally seeing it like four more times.