DACrowe
Avenger
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2000
- Messages
- 30,765
- Reaction score
- 625
- Points
- 78
That was just talk. The second example especially. She was trying to strong arm her way into Carth.
Talk is easy, but actually slaughter hundreds of thousands of civilians with dragon fire is a whole other level.[/quote]
Again, it turns out it wasn't. And I believe you've read the books. Did you really think it was just "talk" there where they don't have the sweeping heroic music and you see her having "visions" (or delusions) in the final book before deciding "Fire and blood" in her last chapter?
This is the woman that crucified thousands because of their treatment of the innocent. This is the woman that locked her babies up because of a single dead child. This is the woman that agonized over executing a single commoner for crimes so that she wouldnt appear partisan. This is the woman that stood up to a doth raki that was trying to rape a woman. This is the woman that freed thousands or millions in Essos and outlawed slavery everywhere she went. This is the woman that repeatedly refused to reopen the fighting pits because the fighting pits and what they represented were antithetical to her ideas. It took repeated pressure and threat before she caved. Prior to episode 5 she had a temper and strong morals and goals. But what she did in Episode five was so far beyond that that it only makes sense as a sudden acute mania brought on by emotional trauma and depression. Ir wasnt a bloodthirsty nature that naturally developed.
This is the woman who crucified hundreds because she assumed they were all guilty for the treatment of innocent. As it turned out at least one (so probably more than one) was opposed to slavery in the same way there were rich Americans who were abolitionists. She didn't care that much afterward and then burned another rich Meereen man alive who may or may not have been part of the conspiracy she burned him for.
She did lock up her children and fought the fighting pits. And after she was nearly assassinated for her troubles, she unleashed the Unsullied on Westeros, promising them the spoils of war, even as she knew what Dothraki spoils looked like. She'd clearly "evolved" in how wars and liberations should be fought. Hence why she started using dragons again.
I agree there is a big distance between that and "The Bells," and that season 8 rushed explaining that jump. But this side of her character was always there, and as sloppy as some of Season 8's writing is, it's very believable that when pushed out of her comfort zone--just as the Sons of the Harpy had in the past--that all those times it was "just talk" (except in Astapor and for the elite of Meereen), it became more than.

