titansupes
Avenger
- Joined
- Dec 11, 2010
- Messages
- 11,641
- Reaction score
- 1,894
- Points
- 103
Ooh, strong pick. A little assist from the make-up department... yeah, I could see it.
The official plot synopsis revealed at the panel:
It's set before just before the beginning of ANH. Gareth got the crew that did Zero Dark Thirty, Blackhawk Down, and Saving Private Ryan to help him bring this film to the screen. He says it's going to be gritty and unlike the other films.
First name that popped to my head, though I put absolutely no thought into it, was Colm Feore.
I doubt this movie will have the traditional type of villain we've come to expect in a star wars film. It's a military type story so the antagonist will likely be an officer of the Empire or multiple Imperial officials. Tarkin will likely be in the film. He was head of Death Star One. Vader could show up too, but Gareth seems to want to make a film that doesn't have the Force and Force Users playing a big part.
This whole thing is exciting cause it's a totally new direction for a star wars film.
Any suggestions for who could play Tarkin?
Peter Culling? Is that an amalgam of Cushing and Cullen?![]()
I was initially displeased about Rouge One being a prequel of sorts before the Rebellion truly kicks off in ANH, but Edwards said it's a lot closer to ANH rather in between, like I first thought. So I'm fine with it now. And to emphasize the "war" aspect greatly interests me. I think this will be good.
Changed my tune pretty quick...
I say bring back Wayne Pygram. He was the Tarkin stand in for ROTS. I think he could do a good Peter Culling impression.
Maybe... If it's a very small thing.
I'm very hesitant to recast any major players if 1) they're being portrayed close to the age we've already seen them (hence I'm fine with Guiness being old Kenobi and Mcregor being young Kenobi) and 2) if they've got large parts and are seen or heard a lot. That's why I'm fine with the sound of the TFA flashbacks. I can picture them being shot from the right angles and being obscured with costuming/light and shadow/CG'd so that quick bits of them wouldn't be a problem.
I'd expect Tarkin to have a large role in this film. As for a younger Leia, if the rumors are true with the Flashbacks, just reuse Billie Lourd
![]()
![]()
Stealing the Death Star plans is quite an audacious objective!
In the old canon it was portrayed as a suicide mission. I wonder if our main cast gets out or they all lay down their lives in the line of duty.
Rogue One is going by Los Alamos.
Ok. Well, that's something different. I hope they convey just how oppressive the Empire is for the Rebels, especially in these early days. How a small victory is considered a major victory for them.No, and Edwards mentioned no magical powers here, just a group on a mission in a war.

Ok. Well, that's something different. I hope they convey just how oppressive the Empire is for the Rebels, especially in these early days. How a small victory is considered a major victory for them.
"The Jedi Knights were the guardians of peace and justice in the Old Republic, before the dark times, before the Empire." But, the Jedi won't actually feature in the movie. “It’s about the fact that god’s not coming to save us, and we’re on our own,” said Edwards. “The absence of the Jedi is omnipresent in the film. It hangs over the whole movie.”
No, and Edwards mentioned no magical powers here, just a group on a mission in a war. I'm sure they will be mentioned though. At the very least the Emperor should be.