When a person coming back from death makes a 'itchy joke' to Lois, who is supposed to be 'his world', you know this man cannot be real.
When a person coming back from death makes a 'itchy joke' to Lois, who is supposed to be 'his world', you know this man cannot be real.
If that's ALL he said, I would agree with you. It's not. It's one line in an entire scene. He's addressing a serious subject with levity before actually addressing it. He's dancing around an uncomfortable subject. It's a pretty common thing that people do.
I really don't see the obsession with this single word of diaogue that people have.
Did he ever actually address anything? I honestly do not remember that. I just remember the itchy thing. I don't have a problem with him using levity. I have a problem with the joke feeling tacked on and failing to humanize him in the way they actually wanted. If he'd had said something about just feeling really hungr or gone for irony like him saying he could use a nap, then that would've felt more like an actual and relatable human response.
Itchy just felt like something Joss laughed really hard at in total solitude, so he put it in the movie.
That's because Superman was never real. Just a dream of a farmer from Kansas.

Did he ever actually address anything? I honestly do not remember that. I just remember the itchy thing. I don't have a problem with him using levity. I have a problem with the joke feeling tacked on and failing to humanize him in the way they actually wanted. If he'd had said something about just feeling really hungr or gone for irony like him saying he could use a nap, then that would've felt more like an actual and relatable human response.
Itchy just felt like something Joss laughed really hard at in total solitude, so he put it in the movie.
No, he doesn't really address it, because he doesn't really want to. He doesn't want to dwell on being dead. There are other clues to this in the scene, such as when he tells her that he just got out of a wooden box. He wants to feel alive, and embrace that.
It's not supposed to be laugh out loud funny. If it was, he would have said it in a funny way. He even says "Itchy" seriously, deadpan, after looking rather pensive when she asks the question. He doesn't crack a smile. He thinks about it and doesn't want to talk about it. It's a brief moment of levity meant to set her at ease about his own experience and what has happened; he immediately transfers to "honestly, weird, in so many ways." The entire sequence between them is about him setting her at ease that despite what has happened, which is a big thing, that he's back and things are going to be okay. He doesn't want to dwell on being dead.
They weren't using the bit about death and coming back to life to humanize him. Humans don't generally die and come back to life like that. What they use to humanize him is that he essentially decides not to dwell on it and moves on to more human concerns, like the fact that they can be together again.
Could be, He looked fake too.
![]()

Could be, He looked fake too.
![]()
I see a strange mix of Leather face and Steve Tyler.
I know Cavill has a naturally weird grin, but the CG here really makes him look like the Joker.![]()
McQuarrie seems game to direct MOS2:
The response was so blasé, the cynic in me half-thinks it's sarcasm. But if it's that damn easy to nab him, WB would be morons not to get the contract to him.

The only thing standing in their way, the mustache-gate that fueled the battle between WB and Paramount![]()