BvS Henry Cavill IS Superman - - - - - - - - - - Part 24

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reposting from another thread, cause I'd like feedback:

Alright, so I think I've cracked the knightmare/flash scene. It's a future where Bats and Supes aren't working together, and DS has taken advantage of that. All the JLers are scattered, with nobody working together. Possibly, nobody trusted each other, so nobody helps each other out. Basically, DS has divided and conquered. Nobody has united, so they have all fallen.

The scene with Bats/Supes shows that as a result of this disunity, Lois has died, at some point. Obviously, Supes and Bats having never becoming friends, Bats has no idea what her death would mean to Supes. So he's let her die, probably because he chose not to save her because she stood for helping the alien, and he thus didn't care about her. Without that Martha moment, Bruce sunk into darker depths and likely only cares about killing Supes and Darkseid rather than saving anyone.

Flash's warning is him come from the future to tell Bats that "Lois is the key" to understanding Supes. He says that Bruce "was right about" there being a 1% chance Supes could be our enemy and we should "fear him" if something happens to Lois, cause she is the key to him snapping.

But why warn Bruce about a danger he already knows? That was my problem with the whole scene until I realized: the JL is the prevention of Injustice style Supes.

Flash, knowing that Supes is to be feared, has come back to tell Bruce that he needs to "find them" (the JL members) so that they can work with Supes and keep him good, and Lois safe. But the message is "too soon" and Bruce doesn't understand it.

But after the Martha moment, and seeing Lois come to Supes' aid, and possibly the way he acts with her before he dies, Bruce understands the message. He knows that he should have understood that the key to keeping a good guy good is understanding, empathy, rather than confrontation. He was right to worry about the 1% chance, but wrong to launch a preemptive strike. Instead, he should have talked and worked to get to know Supes, because knowing what makes him tick is the way to prevent the 1% while still taking advantage of all the good Supes could do.

Finding the other metas is the way to make sure none of the other metas become dangers...which is the most effective measure for preventing more disasters. Bruce sees that clearly after learning about the other metas and working with Supes/WW to destroy DD. So even though Supes is dead, Bats ois gonna find them, not because he fears Supes anymore, but because it's the thing that will be his real legacy; it will be the most important thing he ever does, not killing Supes (which is what he earlier thought would be his biggest contribution to protecting the world).

So when Bruce says he "failed him in life" (a statement I thought was strange, given he saved Martha) he is talking about that previous future, where he let Supes down by not being his friend and letting Lois die.

But now, he won't fail him in death, cause he's gonna change his ways, and become trusting....so that his lack of trust doesn't lead to the dystopian future he saw and was warned about. Once he does that, Flash's warning has been heeded, and the future set right. Now they will battle DS together, not alone. He will thus keep goood men good by standing with them....which makes Bats founding the JL totally logical....for him, it's the ultimate preventative measure needed.

*
 
Seriously. It's like he's just there to be everyone's literal or figurative punching bag.

Agreed.
Count how many times Doomsday even harmed Wonder Woman at all. Then compare to how many times he tossed Superman through a building. Who comes off looking tougher? Not the guy being tossed like a rag doll.

This movie is like watching Justice League season 1, when Superman would get blasted off screen and disappear for long stretches of time before coming back. Don't just call him the Michael Jordan of superheroes, SHOW ME THAT HE IS!!!!
 
Last edited:
You'll live Lee. Sorry you had such a reaction. Since Henry is confirmed for JL I don't think he will be the Garfield of this DCEU.

As always I am just seeing some very over the top reactions.

Np. And that's my issue really.

What ends up happening for Superman in JL has ALWAYS been my biggest concern.

At this point, if Superman is being prepped to be used terribly in JL, I would rather prefer that his character
just stay dead

And Idk why people keep assuming that my issues are solely BvS related. My issues are RELATED EXCLUSIVELY TO JL.

And the fact of the matter is, Snyder keeps confirming and burying himself further in his own ******* whenever he brings up on how he plans on using Superman.

If I'm not mistaken, didn't Snyder just confirm that Superman isn't part of the JL lineup?

How are people not reacting badly about it? Am I the only one the freaking cares?
 
If I'm not mistaken, didn't Snyder just confirm that Superman isn't part of the JL lineup?

How are people not reacting badly about it? Am I the only one the freaking cares?

I don't think Snyder said supes isn't part of the line-up, but he did indicate supes won't help gather the metahumans together.

I do worry he'll do sketchy things with supes in JL. You aren't the only one. It feels like he thinks superman must be minimized or compromised in order to be interesting or to function as some plot device to make the story interesting.
 
But read my above interpretation of the knightmare/flash scene, herolee, Mrs. K.

I think this fully explains where they're going with the JL....

I'm actually feeling a little better about the future.
 
i am 75% positive the next time we see superman, he will be evil and controlled by darkseid...so gonna have to wait at least one more movie for the real superman.
 
Seriously. It's like he's just there to be everyone's literal or figurative punching bag.

he is superman. he can take it. ;)

btw, if not him, then who?

BTW, i thought SR beating scenes are far worse and stupid.
 
i am 75% positive the next time we see superman, he will be evil and controlled by darkseid...so gonna have to wait at least one more movie for the real superman.

Why controlled by DS? Even in that knightmare future, Supes was evil because of Lois, not DS. They might go the Injustice route, but I doubt the mind controlled by DS route.
 
Reposting from another thread, cause I'd like feedback:

Alright, so I think I've cracked the knightmare/flash scene. It's a future where Bats and Supes aren't working together, and DS has taken advantage of that. All the JLers are scattered, with nobody working together. Possibly, nobody trusted each other, so nobody helps each other out. Basically, DS has divided and conquered. Nobody has united, so they have all fallen.

The scene with Bats/Supes shows that as a result of this disunity, Lois has died, at some point. Obviously, Supes and Bats having never becoming friends, Bats has no idea what her death would mean to Supes. So he's let her die, probably because he chose not to save her because she stood for helping the alien, and he thus didn't care about her. Without that Martha moment, Bruce sunk into darker depths and likely only cares about killing Supes and Darkseid rather than saving anyone.

Flash's warning is him come from the future to tell Bats that "Lois is the key" to understanding Supes. He says that Bruce "was right about" there being a 1% chance Supes could be our enemy and we should "fear him" if something happens to Lois, cause she is the key to him snapping.

But why warn Bruce about a danger he already knows? That was my problem with the whole scene until I realized: the JL is the prevention of Injustice style Supes.

Flash, knowing that Supes is to be feared, has come back to tell Bruce that he needs to "find them" (the JL members) so that they can work with Supes and keep him good, and Lois safe. But the message is "too soon" and Bruce doesn't understand it.

But after the Martha moment, and seeing Lois come to Supes' aid, and possibly the way he acts with her before he dies, Bruce understands the message. He knows that he should have understood that the key to keeping a good guy good is understanding, empathy, rather than confrontation. He was right to worry about the 1% chance, but wrong to launch a preemptive strike. Instead, he should have talked and worked to get to know Supes, because knowing what makes him tick is the way to prevent the 1% while still taking advantage of all the good Supes could do.

Finding the other metas is the way to make sure none of the other metas become dangers...which is the most effective measure for preventing more disasters. Bruce sees that clearly after learning about the other metas and working with Supes/WW to destroy DD. So even though Supes is dead, Bats ois gonna find them, not because he fears Supes anymore, but because it's the thing that will be his real legacy; it will be the most important thing he ever does, not killing Supes (which is what he earlier thought would be his biggest contribution to protecting the world).

So when Bruce says he "failed him in life" (a statement I thought was strange, given he saved Martha) he is talking about that previous future, where he let Supes down by not being his friend and letting Lois die.

But now, he won't fail him in death, cause he's gonna change his ways, and become trusting....so that his lack of trust doesn't lead to the dystopian future he saw and was warned about. Once he does that, Flash's warning has been heeded, and the future set right. Now they will battle DS together, not alone. He will thus keep goood men good by standing with them....which makes Bats founding the JL totally logical....for him, it's the ultimate preventative measure needed.

*

It's a very good analysis and I'd like to believe it's true (and it very well could be). It does give me a little hope. :yay:

But some of Snyder's comments still make me worry for Superman's character and position in the JL.
 
Why controlled by DS? Even in that knightmare future, Supes was evil because of Lois, not DS. They might go the Injustice route, but I doubt the mind controlled by DS route.

If they're building to Darkseid in JL, then mind controlled would make sense. I hope we don't see evil Superman at all, whether it be Injustice or Darkseid controlled. I just want Superman!
 
If I'm not mistaken, didn't Snyder just confirm that Superman isn't part of the JL lineup?

How are people not reacting badly about it? Am I the only one the freaking cares?



'Cause he didn't. All he said was that Superman wasn't gonna be the one gathering the team. He's giving that to Batman because with Superman gone Batman would have a hard time trying to make them join forces. Superman will come back later.

Henry posted a picture training saying he was getting ready for JL.
Amy Adams gave interviews saying she's gonna be back for JL 1 and JL2.

Where did you get the idea that Snyder said that about superman or that the superman cast isn't coming back?
 
I don't think Snyder said supes isn't part of the line-up, but he did indicate supes won't help gather the metahumans together.

I do worry he'll do sketchy things with supes in JL. You aren't the only one. It feels like he thinks superman must be minimized or compromised in order to be interesting or to function as some plot device to make the story interesting.

But read my above interpretation of the knightmare/flash scene, herolee, Mrs. K.

I think this fully explains where they're going with the JL....

I'm actually feeling a little better about the future.

'Cause he didn't. All he said was that Superman wasn't gonna be the one gathering the team. He's giving that to Batman because with Superman gone Batman would have a hard time trying to make them join forces. Superman will come back later.

Henry posted a picture training saying he was getting ready for JL.
Amy Adams gave interviews saying she's gonna be back for JL 1 and JL2.

Where did you get the idea that Snyder said that about superman or that the superman cast isn't coming back?


Even if we're fortunate enough for Superman to not come back possessed or evil/out of his mind, there's no indication that Superman will play a major active role outside of being one of the big guns for fighting against whoever the major threat is.

Frankly, it's depressing and saddening to see Superman being robbed of his canonical heritage of being a part of the JL when it forms. What's the point of adding Superman to the lineup if the group is already functioning and gathered by the time he joins in? What's the point of having him in the middle of the group for the concept art? It's pretty much like when Wolverine and Storm robbed Cyclops of his leadership role due to Hugh's and Hallie's higher star status.


@Andreth: Did Amy really confirm that she's also coming back for JL2?
 
Yes. There's a video on the Amy thread. A few pages back.

I believe fallen_angel posted it
 
Yes. There's a video on the Amy thread. A few pages back.

I believe fallen_angel posted it

Well that's good to know.
If they can't use Superman properly for JL, at least there's a better chance that they'll have a great reunion scene between Lois and Clark take place in the film, concluding with a marriage. Since she's confirmed for JL1 and 2, then that means that she's at least not likely to be killed off in JL

@Rapunzel:
I wish I had your positive outlook on life. Frankly, I've been burned one too many times from Snyder's antics and outlooks so I just can't believe that he knows how to use Superman in the grand scheme of things. It just feels like he's given the keys to the kingdom to Batman alone, who's going to be the head honcho of the DCEU.
 
Why controlled by DS? Even in that knightmare future, Supes was evil because of Lois, not DS. They might go the Injustice route, but I doubt the mind controlled by DS route.

Given Superman's "soldiers" double teamed Batman with the parademons, it's probably fair to say Superman is being controlled by Darkseid. The only other scenario is that he's knowingly joined forces with him which wouldn't fly with the ending of BvS at all.
 
I think it's most likely that he joined forces with DS
 
If you think about it, Superman has no real fighting nor leadership skills. He's still learning. He's not going to just suddenly turn into the Superman people want him to be. I'm betting he will get to that point in JL. Maybe then more people will appreciate seeing his journey from outcast to leader. Only time will tell.
 
It was kinda *****ey of Superman to basically smash the Batmobile and interrupt Batman while he was CHASING CRIMINALS simply to tell him to knock off all the Batman stuff..

Dude couldn't even be bothered to continue the pursuit of the truck either. Just flew off, haha.
 
It was kinda *****ey of Superman to basically smash the Batmobile and interrupt Batman while he was CHASING CRIMINALS simply to tell him to knock off all the Batman stuff..

Dude couldn't even be bothered to continue the pursuit of the truck either. Just flew off, haha.
That was like the moment in TDK where the penthouse scene just ended with Batman saving Rachel. Everyone seemed to forget Joker and his goons were still up there holding hostages. :funny:
 
It was kinda *****ey of Superman to basically smash the Batmobile and interrupt Batman while he was CHASING CRIMINALS simply to tell him to knock off all the Batman stuff..

Dude couldn't even be bothered to continue the pursuit of the truck either. Just flew off, haha.

Chasing criminal??? I thought bat wanna steal thing fr lex?
 
Imagine if Justice League was like Weekend at Bernie's only with a Dead Superman :funny:
 
It was kinda *****ey of Superman to basically smash the Batmobile and interrupt Batman while he was CHASING CRIMINALS simply to tell him to knock off all the Batman stuff..

Dude couldn't even be bothered to continue the pursuit of the truck either. Just flew off, haha.

Isn't that what Gods do? Just mess with something a little bit and then just fly away?
 
For the fans that are still level headed and optimistic (somewhat) about the future, what would you guys says are actual indicators that Superman fans shouldn't worry as much about how he'll be handled in JL?

Do we, as superman fans, actually have something legitimate to look forward to post BvS?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"