Slightly better than Zombie's degradation of Michael Myers? It was leaps and bounds over that putrid Halloween remake (and its even worse sequel). I thought Platinum Dunes actually got Jason right in Friday the 13th, where Jason was a force to be reckoned with. Ignoring some of the troublesome plot areas, the main character(s) wasn't annoying for a change.
If Paramount decides to go for a sequel to the 2009 remake, I am there. Jason Mears deserves a second shot... he was great.
I honestly don't see the big fuss F13 fans are throwing over the 2009 remake. The original movies weren't exactly good movies, and it pretty much stayed true to the formula for the most part. And aside from Alice, Ginny, Megan and Tommy, the protagonists in the original series were just bland and forgettable.