Here is my ranking of the Friday The 13th films. On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being a complete waste of time and money, and 10 being an absolute perfect horror movie.
Friday The 13th (1980)
9/10: This movie is so close to being perfect, it's tough to beat. There are only a few minor areas where the film can be improved upon, namely in the introduction of Pamela Voorhees. In retrospect, it's a little too obvious that she's the killer, as she's introduced for the first time completely out of nowhere during the last 15 minutes or so of the movie. Having tiny innocent seeming glimpses of her earlier in the movie, like when Annie was in the cafe asking for directions to Camp Crystal Lake, would have been a very simple solution for this.
Friday The 13th Part 2
8/10: Sequels rarely, if ever, live up to the originals, and this movie is no exception. That being said, as far as sequels go, this one is about as good as you can hope for. The story was suspenseful, the characters were likeable, and Jason does make for a great killer. The biggest problem with the film is the ending. They intended to insinuate that Jason had killed Paul and left Ginny alive, but the way they did it was very confusing. Did Jason kill Paul when he burst through the window at the very end? If so, why did he leave Ginny alive? Did Jason kill Paul in the shack, and everything after that was just a halucination? If so, how did Ginny get back to camp with that injured leg? Did Jason kill Paul when they first fought at the camp, and his coming to Ginny's rescue was just a halucination, as was everything that came after that? If so, how the hell did Ginny manage to defeat Jason without Paul's help? This is why I always choose to interpret the ending to mean that Ginny passed out and when she woke up, Paul was showing the police to Jason's shack in the woods.
Friday The 13th 3D
8/10: In terms of likeable characters and writing, this movie was on par with Part 2. The suspense of this movie was good, but not quite as good as the previous installment. However, it does introduce us to the now iconic hockey mask, which makes it just barely match up with its predicessor.
Friday The 13th: The Final Chapter
7/10: This movie had some of the most creative kills in the series. The effects looked great, thanks to the genius which is Tom Savini. The level of suspense slipped significantly, likely due to the producers believing this to be Jason's last appearance and wanting to go out with a bang. However many of the characters were quite likeable, which increases the overall quality of the movie. While not as good as the previous three, it's still well above average.
Friday The 13th: A New Beginning
6/10: At this point in the series, this was the lowest point to which the films had sank. Many people rate it far lower, citing the fact that the killer not being really Jason as the main reason. To me, not having Jason as the killer is irrelivant. He wasn't the killer in the first movie either, and I give that a 9/10. No, the worst part is the lack of suspense. This was due to studio interference, as they wanted a kill or jumpscare ever 7 minutes in the movie. Somehow the studio execs got it into their heads that this was the formula for making a successful horror film. The other problem was with MPAA interference. This movie needed fewer random shots of Roy, fewer deaths, and a couple of red herrings (Tommy halucinating more, seeing Jason just before every kill, and a news report the Vic had escaped from jail and is reported to be at large, armed, and dangerous). That would have improved the film immensely. Still, the film is woefully underrated.
Friday The 13th Part VI: Jason Lives
6/10: This movie is where the series starts to get really bad. By introducing Zombie Jason to the world, he is now officially no longer scary. And next to Part 5, Jason Lives has the highest body count of the series so far (A New Beginning has a bodycount of 20, while Jason Lives is just behind at 18). As with Part 5, this eliminates the time necissary to create a sense of dread and suspense, thus taking away from the quality of the film. I will say this, the characters were, for the most part, rather likeable. And I kinda like that they were poking fun at themselves a little. Plus, it had some of the coolest kills in the entire series. So it's a fun ride, just not a very scary one. This gives it a just above average score.
Friday The 13th Part VII: The New Blood
4/10: The good = Kane Hodder's debut as Jason. Good make up/special effects. I also liked the character of Tina played by Lar Park Lincoln. The bad = just about everything else. Undead Jason = Fail. Most of the kills were pretty generic. Most of the characters were not very likeable. Dr Cruz was so unlikeable you actually WANT him to die. The story wasn't particularly engaging, and the whole thing was completely unscary.
Friday The 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhatten
1/10: Holy crap, where to begin? How about the title? It's called "Jason Takes Manhatten", but only the last 20 minutes of the movie takes place in New York (or Vancouver pretending to be New York). It should've been called "Jason Takes A Cruise". Most of the kills were pretty generic. None of the characters were particularly likeable, not even the heroine. Plus Jason's brand new ability to teleport ahead of whoever he's chasing. Even Kane Hodder's performance as Jason couldn't save this piece of crap.
Jason Goes To Hell: The Final Friday
1/10: I guess the title means that these movies will no longer be called "Friday The 13th", because there are two more in the series. I just don't really care for supernatural horror, which is why most Friday The 13ths with Zombie Jason don't even break even on my scale of 1 to 10. Kane Hodder barely got any screen time as Jason, so unlike other F13's, this movie doesn't even get bonus points for that. Once again, mostly unlikeable characters, no suspense, or even any good jump scares. Lousy writing. Just an all around bad movie.
Jason X
3.5/10: Slightly better than Jason Takes Manhatten or Jason Goes To Hell. This movie has Kane Hodder as Jason all the way through, which is a point in its favour. And it does have some fun and interesting characters, another point in its favour. And while the whole "Jason in Space" thing is kinda silly, I must admit that if this movie were about a killer alien/robot/cyborg/whatever that was NOT Jason, it would have worked as a science fiction/horror space adventure along the lines of Alien or The Terminator, or maybe Saturn 3. Because of this I am willing to be a little more forgiving with my rating. It's still a sub-par Friday The 13th movie, but it's a pretty fun space adventure. Thus, a slightly higher rating.
Freddy vs Jason
3/10: Most of this movie is unscary. Many of the main characters are unlikeable. And they didn't bring back Kane Hodder as Jason. On the up side, it was filmed here in Vancouver and the final showdown between Freddy & Jason was awesome. It just wasn't enough to save this film. But it was enough to rate it higher than JGTH or JTM.
Well, those are my opinions. Feel free to comment.