Thread Manager
Moderator
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2011
- Messages
- 0
- Reaction score
- 9
- Points
- 1
This is a continuation thread, the old thread is [split]461707[/split]
Superman Returns vs. Spiderman 3.
Tough match up.
She was pregnant too during the movie. Awkward...
SM3 is seen as part of the Raimi trilogy which apparently is still loved(notice all the asm bashing last year). So much so that SM3 was breaking records during it's run I think.
Returns was DOA.
And wasn't part of some genre defining trilogy.
No comparison imo. Especially as international films.
It baffles me that SR only made 50 million opening weekend. Its Superman, doesn't that count for anything?
It had good early reviews as well.
Probably because the aesthetic looked like s*** and the lead looked like a guy playing in a cheap Superman costume?
People were having problems with that movie the moment it was announced. Remember that first photo of Routh? Good god that was a dark day for Superman fans.
She was pregnant too during the movie. Awkward...


I know this doesn't matter anymore in this new thread, but those J.J. Abrams rumors were fake.
Oh well. I guess I know exactly what I will be getting. Which is both good and bad.I know this doesn't matter anymore in this new thread, but those J.J. Abrams rumors were fake.
Oh well. I guess I know exactly what I will be getting. Which is both good and bad.
Obviously I don't know the narrative and the character trajectories. I meant in terms of Abrams directing and aesthetic value, which is both good and bad.We're going to get a shot of a Woman in lingerie!
Woot!Woot!
On a serious note though, what do you expect SW7 to be like with Abrams?
Probably because the aesthetic looked like s*** and the lead looked like a guy playing in a cheap Superman costume?
People were having problems with that movie the moment it was announced. Remember that first photo of Routh? Good god that was a dark day for Superman fans.
ASM was bashed because of rose colored memories of SM1/SM2..
Most ASM haters wouldn't dare defend SM3.
I don't think "rose coloring" has to with anything. I just recently re-watched SM2 and it still holds up great, much better I still hold than TASM.
I don't think "rose coloring" has to with anything. I just recently re-watched SM2 and it still holds up great, much better I still hold than TASM.