X-Maniac
Storm In A Teacup
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2003
- Messages
- 15,205
- Reaction score
- 627
- Points
- 103
Sorry no, but SR was not even NEAR in the same category as X3. X3 was the final installment in a franchise that people had been waiting for, X3 was coming off of the back of two very successful and very high thought off 2 movies. SR was both a franchise starter and a continuiation of a franchise began over 20 years before, ther is a BIG difference my friend. Plus, did you see the SR vs X3 thread on here? SR won by more than 100 votes, not to mention people who hated SR still thought it was better than X3.
Who cares about a thread on here!? The general public doesn't. I spoke to a woman I know about X3 and as soon as I said the death of Cyclops had caused uproar online, she was stunned. She had no idea of that reaction, and she didn't share that reaction. She was shocked Xavier had died, but she didn't hate it. For her, the deaths and the curing of two characters worked within the dramatic context of the story.
As for SR, I think it is better than X3 in some ways - there is more thoughtfulness in it (you can 'feel' Bryan's sense of craft and purpose) and the technical quality is better, and it does have some beautiful scenes, and there is suspense in the plane rescue (I was gripping my seat during that part) but I find it less exciting and entertaining than X3. I find the absence of the Krypton sequence a glaring mistake, I didn't like the opening scene with Lex, I didn't like the reuse of the original theme - in fact I didn't like the nostalgia and remake quality in it. Bryan stuck too closely to the original movie, instead of being more daring and dynamic. I think it was a shaky move to include Richard White as Lois's new partner as the point of Lois and Superman is the 'will they, won't they' love factor, the possibility of him being with her and telling her everything... the movie just made him seem terribly alone, it pushed him out of the way, it gave no real possibility of him being happy. I wanted to see the love and chemistry between Lois and Superman, not Superman acting the way he did.
I was excited when I saw X3, disappointed when I saw SR - I knew SR wouldn't do hugely well because it wasn't what people expected and it was a bit long and flawed in places. I heard a crowd of people talking about it afterwards as I left.. one young woman in her 20s liked it, the other women and the guys didn't like it and they were quite definite about that.
I liked SR more when I saw it at home on DVD - I got sent a free copy of the ultimate collection.
Bryan is a talented director. I think he was better suited to the X-Men franchise and should definitely have fought like mad to stay on and finish his story the way he wanted. But he didn't. So we got different people who finished the way they, and the studio, wanted. Most of the choices made by those different people still make sense. The cure is the perfect way to bring in Angel and Beast and the Morlocks, to incite Magneto into a full-on assault, to show Storm's views, the use of Leech as the source of it was an inspired choice rather than making it some anonymous serum, and connecting Phoenix to Magneto and the cure fight was a good idea too. Not all those ideas worked out perfectly for sure - I know this. I didn't like the Danger Room sequence that much, I didn't like the quick way Cyclops was killed off, I didn't like Colossus's screentime, I wanted at least another scene with Angel. BUT I still enjoyed the movie. It delivered the Phoenix and the Magneto war that the previous movies had promised. It may not have delivered them in the way Bryan had intended, but he wasn't there so that shouldn't need to be stated. Only Bryan could have seamlessly finished off the stories in his two movies... but he wasn't there so we got another interpretation of how the story ended.
Of course there is point in wishing and wondering something else, otherwise the studio's will never learn, are you that naive to accept any **** a studio will put out with the X-Name on it?
Which means you are bashing just for the sake of bashing and just for the sake of irritating people on this forum. That's stupid. Fox isn't sitting there reading your posts and Rothamn isn't weeping at how sorry it is and how right you are. Don't be so ridiculously arrogant and political. Ratner wasn't asked to do X4 or any spin-offs, Singer was asked about Wolverine - Fox is fully aware of exactly how the movie did, and why, and what they are doing. Ratner was needed to get the film made to meet its deadline. He wasn't picked as the next golden child of the movie industry. Rothman even said he loved SR as a first-class movie. So what's the point of your vile attitude? People are entitled to love X3. You are taking it on yourself as a personal crusade to discredit people who like the movie in order to create what you think is some kind of campaign against Fox. And that's out of order.
Fox liked SR, Fox aren't rehiring Ratner, Fox wanted Singer back to do Wolverine at first, Fox has now asked other directors to do Wolverine and Magneto. So what's your problem? Drop your bad attitude againt me and others who liked the movie - we are entitled to do so and you are not going to make me change my mind. As I said before, buzz off.