Zaphod said:
Not quite, no. I have been having quite a bit of trouble coming up with a nicely flowing, coherent plot for the Penguin to be a part of, while trying to avoid tying him in to Falcone's role for conveniance, which I have attempted to avoid at the best of my ability. At the moment, the plot stands as this:
(Please, input, input, input!!)
Carmine 'The Roman' Falcone is the head of traditional organized-crime in Gotham City. He has most of the politicians and GCPDl that run the city on his payroll. Through a contact in Commisioner Gillian Loeb, an obscenely corrupt cop, Falcone ensures his illegal dealings and businesses are kept safe at street level. The judges and D.A's either payed up or two scared of the mob-boss, ignore the going's on of his criminail practicies with regularity , all the while decaying the streets of Gotham while making a very bad man, very rich indeed.
Every months, Falcone has a classified shipment brought in to Gotham harbour, guarded and exported by armed GCPD, the shipment carries both weapons and drugs, which Carmine then sells on too low level pushers working through his contacts for a tidy sum, who then push the drugs the desperate, and the weapons to the street gang, all the while accumulating more money for both themselves, and another nice cut for Falcone.
However, certain quantities of Falcone's shipments begin to dwindle, as weapons and drugs are seemingly being stolen after they are of loading into Gotham. When some of the GCPD turn up dead at the harbour, with weapons and drugs stolen, Falcone begins to consider a potential rival. The Penguin, the rich and gentleman mobster, has been using the decadent and desperate souls of Crime Alley, to carry out regular theft on Falcone's cargo. Those who live in Crime Alley, the former Park Row, were condemned to a life of poverty, squalor, desperation and violence, as a result of Falcone's organzied-crime flooding the city, and The Penguin (through indirect channels of course, I dont know how he would do it, perhaps you could help me out with this?) has been exploiting such hate and want for vengence to amass for himself an armoury, to one day use in contest to Falcone's position.
The Penguin's exploitation in this aspect, would be a good way to highlight the fact that Batman doesn't bear down hard on everyone with vices, since those who are working indirectly for The Penguins long term gain are only doing so out of their own desperation and weak-will, having already been impoverished by Falcone's criminal machinations. Since you mentioned in your last post about The Penguin working for wealth and vengence, we could at least pin down the vengence part in this scenario, somehow linked to Falcone?
I like your ideas for Falcone and the police. I'm a little iffy on the Penguin stuff. I don't think it would hurt to put some emphasis on the Penguin exploiting the desperate and needy (keep in mind that, in the end, that's what Falcone and his ilk are doing as well), but I don't want it to come off as too preachy, and I don't want his motives entrenched in pure evil or social class oppression. He's just a greedy, hateful bastard with the brains and will to take what he wants in life, victims be damned. I want him to have the bare-bones criminal mindset, because he's a distinctly different creature from traditional mobsters like Falcone, zealous idealogues like Ra's Al Ghul, and psychotic loose cannons like the Joker. Penguin is the pragmatist you can "reason" with if you put enough muscle to him. Falcone has his twisted, culturally ingrained sense of honor, R'as thinks he's saving the Earth by killing its people, and the Joker is dedicated to chaos seemingly for its own sake. All are selfish, but the Penguin is someone who would, after a beating, admit that's all it is. Well, he should have pretentions of respectability, but it should be obvious that he's "new money," embarrasingly eccentric but still trying a bit too hard to seem like he belongs in the higher class. I wouldn't rule out a personal code of honor for the Penguin completely, and certainly not an illusory standard of civilized conduct, but the Penguin is out for himself in the end, and the difference between dealing with him at least pretending to be civil and dealing with him lashing out violently when someone displeases him may depend on something as trivial as whether he had breakfast that day or whether he has low blood sugar. He's a fake, just like every other villain who affects an air of civility or even nobility, but he's not nearly as good at hiding it as old-school gangsters like Carmine Falcone. Not in the face of other hardened criminals and certainly not the Batman.
That is my
personal take on a boiled-down movie incarnation of the Penguin. That is not to say that your ideas weren't valid or good, because I very much think they are. I don't think our points of view are irreconcilable, either.
The issue where we differ the most here is probably the idea that the Penguin has a specific, personal grudge against Carmine Falcone, and the prospect of him directly interfering in the Falcone family operations. If the 'Year One' content and the 'Man Who Falls' content is to fit into the first film, along with material to fill in the gaps, a gang war seems too much to add, and I think that's where a Penguin/Falcone conflict would lead. I also think it's too simplistic to blame the Penguin's hateful nature on something Falcone or someone like him did. The world is full of cruel people of all types, and the Penguin got dealt a bad hand consisting of a dead father, an unstable mother, and a host of peers who tormented him for how he looked. His basis for being evil is much the same as the Scarecrow's, and Dr. Octopus' (who obviously won't be shown in a Batman movie, but he's still a good example). The Mafia makes life hard on a lot of people, but there are forces of work that shape young minds into cesspools of hate and despair that aren't organized or passed down in a strict tradition.
This all ties back to the fact that Bruce Wayne was raised, at least for 8 years, by good people who cared about their fellow humans. Even though his childhood ended all too early and he had to confront evil when he wasn't anywhere near prepared for it, he still follows a good example. In this fictional world (if not the real one), setting a good example for pliable minds is what allows compassion to endure in the face of hardship. Carmine Falcone sets a terrible example in that it's both confusing and destructive, as the consequences of his actions are terrible, but he comes off looking like a strong personality of noble traditions. Commissioner Loeb sets a bad example for the police, allowing corruption to trickle all the way through the ranks. The Penguin couldn't care less who follows his example. As long as he feels respected, feared and comfortable, screw everything else. Who is leaving a positive mark on society in Gotham City? The cop who refuses to be corrupted, the prosecutor who won't back down from the challenges of a broken legal system, and the outraged child that dances with the darkest part of human nature without surrendering to the desire for pure vengeance. And the devoted butler who won't settle for less than a perfectly clean mansion.
Note: I wrote the section above
after the following comments, and I'm under the influence of Tylenol PM. If none of this made sense, I'm not surprised.
I had originally intended (not fervently, just as ideas) the vengeance aspect of the Penguin's history to be mentioned via rumors and half-verified facts the Batman picks up while doing reconaissance on the criminal underworld. He learns the Penguin fancies himself a classy gentleman, wants to be a real player in the underworld but has no deep roots like Falcone and other "family men." He also hears rumors that that Oswald Cobblepot, as an adult, took bloody revenge on everyone who bullied him as a child. He lives in luxury, with a collection of fancy artwork (bird-themed, mostly), but has no financial records of having earned enough money to validate his purchases. He keeps the IRS off his case through bribes and such, and he runs a limited but potent gang in an on-going arms dealing operation. He also dabbles in gambling and drugs.
The Penguin's gang are armed with harmless-looking objects that are disguised firearms and other weapons (like umbrellas, but other things as well). He doesn't mass-market these specialized weapons, and he doesn't give his men the best ones; each of his own umbrellas comes with a bullet-proof Kevlar canopy (except for the helicopter ones, which have canopied that break away), but his men do not have this feature. They are loyal to him because they know they aren't smart enough to run his operations as well as he does, but it helps to keep the hardware uneven, just in case someone gets stupid.
Perhaps the Penguin, in the present storyline itself, will execute a lackey who has failed miserably or tried to betray him. Unlike the old-school Mafia culture that Falcone comes from, where whacking someone is done only in the presence of the executioners and in secret (and sometimes with dramatic symbolism, like rats stuffed in the mouth or shot through the eye, etc., depending on the reason why they needed to be whacked), the Penguin will gather his goons in a room and shoot one of them in front of everyone. The Penguin is smart and can manipulate people and events in secret, but he's not a subtle guy. He's not afraid, and the fear he puts into people isn't in the backdrop, like with the Mafia. He's more like the Batman (but ruthless), taking a direct approach and banking on his brains and hired muscle much more than his reputation and connections in the community (since neither of those, for him, stack up against Falcone's). I wanted to keep the Penguin's stuff mostly seperate from Falcone's stuff; it's not that they can't overlap (it's better thant they do in some ways), but it should be made clear that, while for years the Italian Mafia has been running Gotham and the police force, new blood has come along to cut their own slice of the pie. The Penguin should not be said or even hinted to be related to any Mafiosi, nor should he be trying to emulate their way of life. There are no kisses on the cheeks, family dinners or blood oaths for Oswald Cobblepot and his underlings. He doesn't even have a family, and no human friends. The only blood between he and his goons is the blood that gets shed if they screw up, and if anyone thinks it's demeaning to be killed by an umbrella, tough! A new era is dawning, and the Batman has risen just in time to keep it contained.
The police are in Falcone's pocket, all the way up to the Commissioner, and there are other mob families that grudgingly accept Falcone's dominance (the Maronis), while Cobblepot only intersects when he's infringing upon mob territory or if he happens to attend the same opera as Falcone. In fact, that should happen. I think Bruce Wayne, Carmine "the Roman" Falcone, Oswald "the Penguin" Cobblepot, and maybe "Boss" Salvatore Maroni, should attend some high-brow event, and Bruce can get a glimpse of all these players. During this scene, you'll see Falcone talking softly to whichever "family members" accompany him about Cobblepot, showing their view of him as a laughable poser. Falcone, being wise and cautious (not crass and trigger-happy, like in 'Begins') will also say that beneath that cartoonish facade lies a character far less controllable than the birds of prey he collects. He's an animal, with a cunning if short-sighted (in his opinion) mind, and should not be underestimated.
Perhaps Falcone should approach Bruce Wayne at this event, trying to lay the groundwork of a valuable connection, mentioning that their fathers were friends. Bruce would make a remark that politely but clearly conveys that their fathers had nothing in common. He's trying to profile Falcone while letting his barely disguised disdain rule out any further conversations. He plans to visit Falcone under different circumstances and try to put a little fear into him, but he decides to go with the Penguin first, since he knows Falcone won't scare easily and his whole network is too deeply ingrained in Gotham to significantly disrupt in the short term. He'll take on the small fry first, while still collecting evidence and information about the mob. But the Penguin doesn't scare easily, either. In fact, the little man can hold his own, and his birds can send him packing.
The Batman decides to leave the Penguin to enjoy his victory for a while, so he can grow cocky (more than usual, that is), putting his concentration on "the Roman's" empire. Conferring with Lieutenant James Gordon, he gets a feel for the routines and habits of the corrupt police force. Doing surveillance on both the mob and the dirty cops yields evidence he runs by Harvey Dent, making sure the young D.A. will see this through if the Batman continues to collect admissible evidence (photos, recorded conversations, incriminating documents), rather than simply strong-arming every mobbed-up criminal in Gotham (because you know he'd do it, too, or at least try). Dent is on board, and Gordon starts thinking positive (although still apprehensive, as he knows he can't fully trust a character like the Batman) for the first time since he was transferred to Gotham City. The police Commissioner declares the Batman a public menace, presumed armed and dangerous, and sets a large police task force on him.
The Batman stretches himself in all directions, doggedly pursuing evidence against both Falcone's mob and a large portion of the GCPD using detective work and physical and psychological intimidation, still keeping tabs on the Penguin's growing syndicate, and continually responding to emergencies and street crimes in the city. When James Gordon is attacked by several police officers (including Flass, of course) right after the Batman wastes a full night's work following a false lead set up by Falcone's people (they knew he was pursuing a real legal case instead of just attacking crooks head-on, since they have at least one spy in the D.A.'s office and figured out from the evidence that kept turning up there that the Batman was in league with Dent), the strain of his constant heroing and detecting catches up with him and he begins to lose hope again. Was all the training and exposing himself to the cultures of fear and violence for nothing?
When he hears about Flass getting beaten, stripped and tied up, with wounds rumored to be inflicted in a similar, Green Berret-style fashion that Gordon was attacked, he follows the example and pushes on, refusing to let his ally down.
The corrupt police force shouldn't be shown to be as cunning as Falcone, so I don't want them to draw the Batman out on purpose, but somehow the Batman will be caught in a car chase where he has to get out of his vehicle, and a physical confrontation commences. I'm thinking he'll become aware, while trying to evade capture, of an emergency where lives are in danger and he knows that even good police won't be likely to respond, since everyone-- not just the task force-- is supposed to move in on the Batman if he is spotted. He can't ignore it, even if he might get killed or arrested, so he gets out of the car and tends to the emergency. After saving whoever was in danger, the cops are right on his heels, and he has to go all-out with the smoke bombs, flashbangs and tear gas (the latter of which the task force is prepared for, since they're trying to use it on him as well... don't worry, he's got a gas mask, he'll be okay) to keep from getting shot full of holes, and then he pulls his subsonic bat-call trick (inspired by the Penguin's bird attack) and escapes the police.
I don't have specifics in mind for the elements of the case the three crime-fighters of the story are building, but it ends up being substantial enough to scare the dirty cops into plea bargains (which at the very least gets them thrown off the job, if not put in jail or prison) and put many of the mobsters in a position where they're being watched and have to scale back their activity. Falcone is still untouchable legally, but he's taken down a peg. Good people start going to the police academy again, less afraid of being trapped in a corrupt environment than before. Gordon is promoted to Captain, and although the new Commissioner is just as bad, if not worse than Loeb, a precedent has been set and a the ranks are cycling so that, with enough dirty cops put away in the future, the good ones might still be standing and in a position of power. By the third movie, Gordon should be Commissioner.
Having heard about the blow to the mob inflicted by the D.A. and a new crackdown on racketeering and the trafficking of contraband by the police, the Penguin suspects the Batman's hand in the shift in power and has as much evidence of his own crimes and conspiracies destroyed or safely stowed away as possible. He still needs to be put in his place, however, so the Batman returns to where he first confronted the nasty little man. He immediately throws gas capsules into the bird cages that incapacitate the birds, so even if Cobblepot opens them remotely as he did last time, none of them will be able to attack. The Penguin thinks the Batman has killed them, not knowing the Batman has compunctions about killing non-human animals and not knowing for sure he wouldn't kill a person, either. The Batman then knocks out all the lights with shuriken or Batarangs and blocks the light of the city and moon coming through the window with smoke. Easily overpowering the Penguin and manually breaking his umbrella-gun, he shoves him out the window, dangling him over the street several stories below. He tells him in no uncertain terms that if he finds any evidence that the Penguin is responsible or part to the distribution or manufacturing of weapons or drugs, or is involved in any violent crime activity, he'll make him regret it dearly. He can't even so much as back loan sharks, since that easily degenerates into retributive violence. That basically leaves just gambling operations as a low priority the Penguin can content himself with, if he behaves himself. Step out of line, and the crooked bastard will wish he was never born.
Oh, and his beloved birds aren't dead...
this time.
His suped-up sports car Batmobile was impounded by the police, and the Batman isn't going to ask if he can get it back. Some schematics for a new Batmobile are seen in the Batcave, complete with jet/turbine engine and afterburner, sophisticated defense systems, night-vision windshield, rear-deploying drag-chute, grappling hooks and anti-pursuit measures (caltrops, smoke-screens and oil-slicks, etc.) and all the fancy stuff we expect from a quality Batmobile. Not all of these features are mentioned or apparent on the visual scematics, but it will be shown that this is the kind of car he's going to build.
Final scene features the, Bat-signal and tentative congratulations and acknowledgments between Gordon and the Batman. I would keep the remark about escalation from 'Begins,' because I think that's a good way of putting a pseudo-logical spin on the endless roster of supervillains who appear after the Batman casts his shadow over Gotham. Some of them are just plain crazy, but using outrageous gadgets and unpredictable tactics is the new effective method of throwing one's weight around, which the Penguin already picked up on before the Batman set a more dramatic example.
Damn, that's a lot of crime drama content; I didn't leave any room for a romantic interest. I'll just have to live with that.
Comments?
