The Amazing Spider-Man The Amazing Spider-Man General Discussion & Speculation Thread - - - - - - P - - - Part 19

[MACH]

Your from Bournemouth too !!!

Hahaha! I am indeed!

 

[DarthSkywalker]

Explain to me what logic is broken with this scene ?

If you are going to build the film around being realistic and logical, you can't break logic. See Batman Begins microwave. (And I love that movie.)

 

[DarthSkywalker]

You must have me confused with someone else mate because I did no such thing. I can assume you're a teen though right?

Grown man who finds it amusing that fans of Spidey seem to enjoy bullying.

 

[Eggyman]

If you are going to build the film around being realistic and logical, you can't break logic.

Yes, but how is the scene breaking logic?

 

[GENERAL RAAM582]

I take a little cat nap, I come back here, and some of you are still *****ing about this? For ****'s sake.

 

[Infinity9999x]

Unbelievable, does every superhero movie go through this ridiculous microscopic analysis?

Let me direct you back to 2008 and the little debate called Six or Ten.

Compared to that, the Spidey car jacker debate going on seems perfectly logical and relevant.

 

[Ashes2Phoenix]

If you are going to build the film around being realistic and logical, you can't break logic.

But you said the logic was thrown out of the window in this clip ? Explain to me, when others, including myself have given valid reasons why your problems with this scene are beyond petty.

 

[MACH]

That is funny, because the argument has been no one notices such things. Which is it? t:

By the way, I like the scene. But the mentality around here is ridiculous. Just because someone doesn't agree doesn't make their point any less valid. Doesn't mean you just get to start insulting.

Honestly mate, I see where you are coming from but please look back over the last 10 pages and realise that this debate has been discussed to death and gone on too long and it is is all from the same guy lol.

It has been answered every way it can and now it has just got boring. The guy is in the minority (you and him) yet he continues to try and convince everyone else.

Seriously, opinions are great but over and over and over, it just gets a bit dull.

WE GET IT, he doesn't find it convincing. The rest apparently do.

 

[Smoke87]

Yeah, there is. Because that kind of guy is an annoying *****e and actually only interested in making himself seem intelligent, rather than realising that everyone thought the same thing but used logic to find the answer rather than shouting from the rooftops.

hahahaha cracked me up!

I don't want to be mean, but this is such a crazy discussion. He's freaking spider-man. He's able to do things like this. I don't think seeing HOW he got in the car would make this scene better or something?

 

[MACH]

hahahaha cracked me up!

I don't want to be mean, but this is such a crazy discussion. He's freaking spider-man. He's able to do things like this. I don't think seeing HOW he got in the car would make this scene better or something?

THANK YOU! Hahaha

 

[DarthSkywalker]

Yes, but how is the scene breaking logic?

When did Spidey get in the car? The car doors clearly make a bit of noise when opened.

 

[omid17]

Of all the things to debate, seriously, how a superhero gets in a car. Heh.

lol it's quite hilarious actually

eggy i hope you enjoy the film man, can't wait to check out your review

 

[Ashes2Phoenix]

If you are going to build the film around being realistic and logical, you can't break logic. See Batman Begins microwave. (And I love that movie.)

The film is far from realistic. The guy has Spider powers for crying out loud. The relationships between the characters will most likely be handled realistically but the actual concept of the film IS unrealistic.

 

[Ashes2Phoenix]

When did Spidey get in the car? The car doors clearly make a bit of noise when opened.

A couple of seconds before the car thief gets in. This is hilarious.

 

[mayo23]

Do I get a tshirt for joining?

No, but you will get peace of mind...from this debate of how Spider-man sneaks into a car.

 

[Infinity9999x]

This whole discussion has reminded me of this video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FdYs5iDw3mc

It's teh realistic on the sneekiness. It even has a car situation

 

[socool]

Just found this:

[YT]JuaKfFRAG70[/YT]

Pretty much goes to show that the new web-swinging, in my opinion, is so much better than the Raimi swinging.

 

[Ashes2Phoenix]

hahahaha cracked me up!

I don't want to be mean, but this is such a crazy discussion. He's freaking spider-man. He's able to do things like this. I don't think seeing HOW he got in the car would make this scene better or something?

Haha. Could not have put it better myself !

 

[MACH]

Grown man who finds it amusing that fans of Spidey seem to enjoy bullying.

Bit dramatic mate. There is no bullying going on here. No one is making fun of him, we're simply telling him we get the point but that it has been discuss to death by him now.

 

[omid17]

sick tv spot

 

[DarthSkywalker]

A couple of seconds before the car thief gets in. This is hilarious.

I own a car. I have got in it before. You know when another door is opened. You can't open a car door swiftly and quietly.

Also, I think I saw an Aston Martin there. Now who steals another car when perfection is right there? t:

 

[Eddie Brock]

Unbelievable, does every superhero movie go through this ridiculous microscopic analysis?

Unfortunately, yes. However, I think this kind of behavior has been amplified by RIM's vague foreboding comments. Now, everyone's too quick to look for flaws because they're trying to figure out why one guy didn't like the movie - rather than simply enjoying what we have and getting excited for the rest.

(Just my two cents.)

 

[MACH]

Just found this:

[YT]JuaKfFRAG70[/YT]

Pretty much goes to show that the new web-swinging, in my opinion, is so much better than the Raimi swinging.

MATE! That is BADASS!

 

[Spider-Who?]

When did Spidey get in the car? The car doors clearly make a bit of noise when opened.

Sigghhh. Read my post on the. Very first page, as well as the countless other posts addressing this comment. If that's too hard, here are the bullet points:

Based on his comment about dressing like a car theif, it's obvious spidey noticed the theif eyeing car before the valet parked it, which means the most logical time spidey could have gotten into the car was during the trade off, when the owner turned the car over to the valet.

Ergo, Spidey is already in the car before the theif even reaches it (and before this clip starts).

 

[DarthSkywalker]

Bit dramatic mate. There is no bullying going on here. No one is making fun of him, we're simply telling him we get the point but that it has been discuss to death by him now.

Imply someone is a "*****e" gets past that line pretty quickly.